Opening Arguments
Greg Bovino's Unhinged Rutgers Speech and the Decade-Old 'Flight 93 Election' Essay
For the Amuse Douche, we have former Border Patrol commander-at-large Greg Bovino's rambling, conspiracy-laden speech at Rutgers this week. Then we revisit Michael Anton's 2016 essay "The Flight 93 Election," published under the pseudonym Publius Decius Mus, which argued conservatives had no choice but to back Trump, and see how it holds up after this month's wave election.
Sources discussed:
- Greg Bovino's speech at Rutgers University (video)
- The Flight 93 Election, Claremont Review of Books, by Michael Anton (writing as Publius Decius Mus), 2016
Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!
To support the show (and lose the ads!), please pledge at patreon.com/law! $2+ patrons also get a new Law'd Awful Movies every month.
Transcript
This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors — the audio is the record.
0:00:09 Thomas: Hello and welcome to Opening Arguments. This is Vapid Response number 50. Back with a bang. I feel like it's been far too long. I'm Thomas. That over there is real-life attorney Matt Cameron. How you doing, Matt?
0:00:20 Matt: Celebrating number 50 with a golden classic. Looking back on some super pretentious bullshit, like beyond any pretentious bullshit we've read on this show before, I promise you that.
0:00:23 Lydia: Wow.
0:00:23 Thomas: Oh. All right. We'll see.
0:00:30 Matt: Yeah.
0:00:32 Thomas: Everyone will They'll write in, be like, that was like not even close to as pretentious as some of the bullshit you've had on here. And producer Lydia, how you doing?
0:00:32 Lydia: Well. Yeah, we'll see. Hey. Good, yeah, I feel like it's been forever since we've done this. I don't know why, but yeah.
0:00:44 Thomas: Does feel like that. Been like several
0:00:47 Lydia: Seriously.
0:00:47 Thomas: Wave elections ago, you know. Least one
0:00:50 Matt: And it's several voices ago.
0:00:53 Lydia: A Good. One.
0:00:53 Matt: I've had a number of voices over the past month, so that's what happens.
0:00:56 Lydia: True, that's
0:00:54 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. Matt can you do a steroid injection and some cocaine right now real quick and then, and get you right back to your former glory? Technical difficulties, I'll put up a screen real quick, and then we'll come back. And white powder all over your nose.
0:00:57 Matt: Yeah. Yeah.
0:00:57 Lydia: True.
0:01:04 Matt: Comfortably numb. All right. I'm here. I'm
0:01:09 Thomas: Ah, Matt's all chipper now, so yeah, what are we going to be talking about?
0:01:10 Matt: Ready. Well, we've got, of course, an amuse-douche from something that just happened. If people haven't seen or heard this, I'd never actually heard Greg Bobino talk, so you're going to have the pleasure of hearing former.
0:01:22 Thomas: Haven't heard Greg Pavino talk.
0:01:22 Lydia: Wow.
0:01:24 Matt: I've avoided it. I've seen pictures of his Nazi uniforms, but I had not seen him talk.
0:01:25 Thomas: Wow. You are so lucky. I did a whole fucking episode with that guy talking.
0:01:32 Matt: I mean, I go through enough pain every day. I don't need to just voluntarily expose myself over there.
0:01:35 Thomas: I find out Matt's not a listener. I'm just kidding, guy's the worst.
0:01:38 Matt: Not every episode. But yeah, we got this Greg Bovina clip. You've got to hear it if people haven't heard it yet. It just happened at Rutgers this week, just to really get a taste of where he's at and what's going on and how apologetic he is for everything that he did. And then we're going to revisit, we're going to get the whole episode for the Flight 93 election, which was a classic of 2016. It was the rallying cry for intellectual conservatives to get behind Trump in 2016. And the Claremont Institute, John Eastman, all the rest, getting behind intellectual conservatism that could finally back Donald Trump.
And it was one of the things that put him over the top with the conservative movement. So I thought it'd be worth a look after this big wave election that we just had, because arguably, and again, I think the entire concept of a Flight 93 election is super offensive. I even hate saying it out loud, because that's horrible. You're talking about actual heroes who took a vote and rushed a a cockpit because that was what they could do. You'll see in the piece just how offensive it gets.
0:02:32 Matt: He knew it was offensive.
0:02:32 Lydia: Be
0:02:33 Thomas: I'm trying to think of how that even, even applies really. I get I even, even adjusting for hyperbole, like if I was going to go with them, because I would think voting, you know, like not letting Trump get elected is an emergency that I'm willing to to be hyperbolic about. But how's that, so you're going to fly the country into the ground rather than yeah, how does that work? You're going to fly yourselves, themselves into the ground rather than let the country, the country be attacked. Yeah, I can't I can't
0:02:34 Matt: Yeah. Well, you'll probably still struggle. Yeah.
0:02:53 Matt: Yeah. Yes, just basically take Hillary Clinton win.
0:03:04 Lydia: Hijacked. Yeah.
0:03:05 Thomas: Fit it together. How does it work? Where's, who's the, is the Pentagon the country, is the plane Hillary, or is the, we'll see, we'll work it out.
0:03:06 Matt: Yeah. I can't promise it'll make any more sense after you've read it, but this is, yeah, we'll get into it. But promise I this was a very Very influential piece at the time. I thought it was worth revisiting. It should not be forgotten. And Michael Anton should forever be associated with it. And we'll talk about Michael Anton before we get going. But very much kind of with us Forrest Gump of right-wing evil types. He's been around everybody you hate and all the causes you don't like. Been He's involved somehow.
0:03:16 Thomas: No.
0:03:35 Thomas: Like Forrest Grump would vote for Trump, yeah.
0:03:38 Lydia: Depressing, just you saying that makes me not want to watch the movie.
0:03:40 Thomas: It's hard because it's Tom Hanks, but he would be a Trump voter.
0:03:42 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. God.
0:03:43 Matt: Well, yeah, you're not wrong.
0:03:46 Thomas: Yeah. Statistically he would be an older white man.
0:03:47 Lydia: Yeah. That's true. That's true, statistically speaking.
0:03:51 Matt: He's in the demographic.
0:03:51 Lydia: Speaking
0:03:52 Thomas: Been going through some of the election results and polls and stuff for my, for SIO, and uh, yeah, there's like one group that went, went more for Republicans in 2024, and it's older white men, it's the only
0:04:01 Lydia: The exact group. You think it would be because
0:04:05 Matt: Who knew?
0:04:05 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah, weirdly men, actually, we, uh, Democrats won men for the first time in like a billion years in the, in the midterms.
0:04:12 Lydia: Of Hispanic voters, right?
0:04:15 Thomas: Well, it's, see, that's the complicated thing. It's, it's that, but it's also because of people staying home, like it's hard, it's always hard to, yeah, I'm gonna do a whole Serious Inquiries on me about it, but it's always We just, should have everybody fucking vote, every single, it should be mandatory, I've said this, this before, because we do this thing where it's like you read all these messages out of the voting, and it's like, oh, people change their minds, it's like, well, no, like one group of people stayed home because they barely voted the first time, and then they're like, I'm not going to quite vote this time, and then other people were motivated to go vote, and it's like, we make all these judgments about what the whole population is doing based on differing populations and a
0:04:19 Lydia: Well. I'll tune in, I'll check it out. Yeah.
0:04:24 Matt: I do
0:04:51 Lydia: Right. Yeah.
0:04:56 Matt: Think for that last point, you have to account for the fact that women under 30 probably probably aren't that excited at this point around the country of, you know, getting with Trump voters. So maybe that's just Boston. It could just be I live in a bubble. That's very possible. But I don't know. That has to help.
0:05:08 Lydia: I think I think
0:05:09 Thomas: Wait, what's the, sorry, what's the point being made there? I didn't, I don't understand.
0:05:09 Lydia: Interesting.
0:05:11 Matt: That more men are going to vote now, Democratic, going to go blue because they don't want to. They're like, maybe this is actually working. I don't know. This is just, you know, like women are actually maybe make the difference. Who knows? Who knows? I'd like to believe that.
0:05:16 Thomas: Oh, okay. Yeah. Oh yeah. I mean, women are, are the backbone of the democratic party. It's just the, yeah, The, uh, the asshole men that, that have never been, all right. Well, uh, we are going to get to the Flight 93 election and I'm going to do the thing I always do where I try try to make your stupid fucking metaphor make sense. Cause I can't, if you're going to do it, your analogy, whatever I'm gonna, yeah, I can't, You're, you did it. You, I didn't do it. You did it. Uh, and then also I'm sure we have an amuse douche, which you mentioned, hey, support the show, patreon.com/law. We've got a Law'd Awful Movies coming at you pretty soon. That's going to be a really interesting one, uh, and avoid the ads and just mostly support the show. If you like the content, support it or share it, uh, and, or both would be be great that's all awesome.
0:05:25 Lydia: Well, Black women.
0:05:25 Matt: Sure.
0:05:41 Lydia: Rhetoric with Thomas Smith, the new show.
0:06:05 Lydia: Yeah.
0:06:06 Thomas: All right, we'll take a break and then we will, oh wait, no, sorry, it's been too long since we've done VR. We are going to thank our uh hall of famers, our all-time greats, on patreon.com/law. Can't believe I almost forgot that. That's what we do here, yeah.
0:06:18 Lydia: How could you? How could you?
0:06:20 Thomas: Uh, and we will start with the uh lower third here. Thank you to Jason Smith, trapped in a shout out but Mac got me sick, Way in 14, my house is a mess but I read a lot of books, Griff the tired 2L, status status quo level thing, Matthew Cutler, twitch.tv slash mtc underscore streams, forgetting to change my patreon name, I've had crunch wraps more supreme than this court, unpronounceable nerd reference, new guy mountain court is now in session, all highs stupid, Amina, Donna Treadaway, mother of heritans, still rooting for the hamburgers to deliver more timely justice than the current system, Mike Lapinski, golden golden mantled howler monkey. That's a new one, but I'm not totally sure. Yeah, I don't know. Cyanitis. How many fettersmen is Haley Stevens? Oh man. God, what a pathetic. Yes. Someone,
0:06:28 Matt: Sorry.
0:07:13 Lydia: Fettersman. Sorry.
0:07:14 Thomas: Someone, yeah. Someone managed to out fettersmen, fettersmen. Out fettermen, fettermen. Yeah. Can't find a fetterman. Yeah.
0:07:19 Lydia: Yeah.
0:07:20 Matt: They're not man's fetter, sure.
0:07:24 Thomas: She's, that's a song that Matt drummed for. Uh, can't find a fetter man. Uh, great preponderance of the evidence, last train to Skanksville, and el dia del pan, don't know what that is, but okay, Yeah, bread, I mean, sure.
0:07:39 Lydia: Bread day? Cool.
0:07:41 Thomas: The day of the bread.
0:07:41 Matt: Every day
0:07:42 Lydia: I like it. I like the day of bread. Good.
0:07:44 Thomas: Yeah. Thank you so much, uh, hall of famers, all-time greats, you can join their ranks, patreon.com/law. We'll take a break and then we'll get right to it. Man, I see a Nazi and a subtitle that says that is the solution, which I can only imagine refers to the final solution. Uh, he's Giving some sort of talk.
0:08:00 Matt: Unfortunate.
0:08:03 Thomas: It looks like a yeah, it looks like, like I'm, why am I getting like a Muppets vibe from this? You know what I mean, like the curtains or something, and the seats, like it looks like them, they're seated there, I don't know.
0:08:03 Lydia: That a hat on the podium? Yeah. Yeah,
0:08:10 Matt: Does look like a muppet
0:08:16 Thomas: It's not going to be as delightful as the Muppets. What's what's going on here?
0:08:17 Matt: Well, I would rather be watching the Muppets, but
0:08:19 Thomas: Yeah. Well, that's always true.
0:08:19 Matt: Yeah, this muppet. Uh, Gregory Kent Bovino, he's now now 56 years old. Famous, of course, for having led U.S. Border Patrol. The commander-at-large, that's actually what they're called, the commander-at-large. And he held that office from October 2025 to January 26th, 2026. I want to point that out because it seems like he was there for a long time.
0:08:40 Thomas: Yeah.
0:08:41 Matt: But it was a particularly dramatic period in CPP history when they were out in the streets with ICE, wilding out. And of course, he eventually had to go after murders the of Rene Good and Alex Preddy in Minneapolis. He's going to mention Minneapolis on this clip, so I want to be sure to bring that up. He's still bitter about it, of course, because that's what he's forced out.
0:08:44 Lydia: Right.
0:08:57 Lydia: He's not involved with the administration at all anymore.
0:09:00 Matt: He's actually still in CBP somehow, but just not leading it anymore.
0:09:01 Thomas: Didn't he take a retirement or something?
0:09:05 Lydia: Oh, okay. Wow.
0:09:09 Thomas: Like racist, like senior status, racist, racist, a judge.
0:09:12 Matt: Just to warn you up front before we watch this clip, it has been reported that he was considering a campaign for president recently. So Godspeed, Greg Bovino.
0:09:20 Thomas: Good luck, dude. Good luck. There's there, you know, like some people get afraid, like, oh, don't, you know, you never know. Like when people talk about Vance, he's not winning. I'm sorry. Vance isn't winning. And the good news, if I'm wrong, I'll just kill myself. So it's fine. I don't have to live with the consequences. Vance is not winning. There's no chance.
0:09:22 Lydia: Wow.
0:09:22 Matt: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No.
0:09:39 Thomas: Same with this guy. Nobody likes this guy.
0:09:40 Matt: Yeah. Less so.
0:09:41 Lydia: Yeah. No.
0:09:42 Thomas: There's he, could, he could, I don't even know that he could capture the Nazi vote. I think the Nazis are like this guy here. He is towering over a two foot five podium. You know, he's just this tiny little guy with this terror, this ego problem and this bad Nazi haircut. Nobody likes this fucking guy.
0:09:42 Matt: Even more so, rather.
0:09:51 Matt: Yeah.
0:09:58 Lydia: No.
0:09:58 Matt: Yeah, I wouldn't usually comment, but I had to look it up. He's 5'4". So maybe that's not...
0:10:01 Thomas: Of course he is. Of course he is.
0:10:03 Matt: Yeah.
0:10:03 Lydia: Okay, but here on OA, we like short kings, but not if they're racist.
0:10:05 Matt: Sure.
0:10:05 Thomas: This is not a short King. There's there's short kings and Then there's, yeah, there's... there's men who do a do a Nazi about it who are so mad about being short, they start a race war, there's the, yeah.
0:10:07 Lydia: That's what I'm saying. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. Agreed.
0:10:06 Matt: Absolutely. Absolutely. No. It's just losers. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And to take it back, he's not actually active. He did retire, fortunately. Excuse me. So that's... Yeah, you're right. And also, Also, I want to note again, since we've all seen one battle after another, clearly Sean Penn, whether he knew about Bovino or not, is channeling Bovino in one battle after another, uncannily sometimes.
0:10:20 Lydia: Oh, okay. All right.
0:10:21 Thomas: That's like that okay, and he couldn't help but put more life into that character than Bovino has in his eyes, it was
0:10:40 Lydia: Right.
0:10:40 Matt: But totally. So just for context, this is at Rutgers University on Tuesday night this week that we're recording.
0:10:49 Lydia: What entity invited him?
0:10:52 Matt: Well, it's the young Republicans, of course, campus Republicans.
0:10:52 Lydia: Do you know?
0:10:53 Thomas: Monday night it's Tuesday Hasn't Tuesday night hasn't happened yet. This was yesterday, right?
0:10:55 Lydia: Yeah.
0:10:56 Matt: Yeah. Yes, that's right. Right. I don't know what day it is. It's fine. Why would I know what day it is?
0:11:00 Thomas: Unless we're showing you the future, that's why you watch this show, everybody. We show you the future. Here's what's gonna happen.
0:11:07 Lydia: Exactly.
0:11:05 Matt: It's right. Yeah, but never the sports. We never tell you what's going to happen in the sports.
0:11:09 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah.
0:11:10 Lydia: No.
0:11:13 Matt: So Rutgers, of course, I have to point this out because I did go to Seton Hall Law School, and Seton Hall would I'm sure they would never invite this man. But there were sustained campus protests, including during the speech. We're not going to watch that part. But he was shouted down pretty hard because this guy is a fascist. It isn't just the usual thing of, like, this is a person I disagree with. This is somebody who never should have been in the job and who is now saying the kinds of things he's saying right now that prove that he shouldn't have been in the job. Let's just roll it. Let's hear what he's saying.
0:11:32 Thomas: There are people, they're right, look, there's... There's the Ann Coulter, they did this shit within the 2016, the Ann Coulter's, the Ben Shapiro's, who I would probably, if I were there, I'd probably like protest and be like, "This is dumb," or I'm not even sure I would, because that's what they're wanting, you know, like, I'm not sure I would. I'm nothing against people who protested those folks. This one is just like, no, no, this guy is such a piece of shit that like, this is your civic duty to come yell at this guy. Like, this isn't like, "Oh, protest." No, it's not even like protest, it's like the devil is there, go yell at him to get the fuck out of there, like you know what I mean
0:11:43 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
0:12:00 Matt: Yeah. Yep.
0:12:14 Matt: And if you didn't want to yell at him before, you will now after hearing this.
0:12:17 Thomas: I yeah, like, I wouldn't even think of this as protest. You know, it's it's almost like, oh, there's a, there's a, there's an emergency in my town or something, you know what I mean, like, we got this, this can't happen. Uh, yeah, he should.
0:12:20 Matt: No, sure. Yeah. This person is speaking in public to a group, right?
0:12:24 Lydia: Yeah.
0:12:31 Thomas: Tomatoes. Everybody have tomatoes at all times. This is what they invented throwing tomatoes at someone for is this guy. All right. Am I hitting play at the beginning here?
0:12:32 Matt: Yeah, exactly.
0:12:34 Lydia: Mm-hmm.
0:12:40 Matt: Let's do it. Yeah.
0:12:40 Thomas: All right. Let's see. Hmm.
0:12:48 Clip: That these young folks here, Republicans, New York Republicans, Texas Republicans, young conservatives, I've had an opportunity to speak with a lot of you. There's 107 million illegal aliens, bringing false aliens. And now, war's on American soil. The war is right here on American soil. We either win this, because if we don't, what awaits us? If we don't win this, just a few years, just a few years, you'll find out we'll find out what really awaits us when a hundred million are granted amnesty and throw you into oblivion I think that pride flag there, you know, what's the name of the city there, you know, and Michigan ham
0:13:00 Thomas: Aliens.
0:13:02 Matt: Weird.
0:13:13 Thomas: Who's us? Okay.
0:13:27 Thomas: Wow. Huh? Ham.
0:13:28 Matt: Barbecue.
0:13:35 Clip: Track, you think ham track, well, I'm just scratching the surface, I'm just scratching the surface you know the folks battling here. I call them the human fodder or useful idiots, you know, uh, when Stackpole went in front of the town council and said, hey, we helped you out, hey, we helped you out, you know, what are you doing, you know what, hey, the caliphate is upon us, and
0:13:40 Thomas: Is he talking Sorry.
0:13:46 Matt: Made that up. Useful idiots.
0:13:56 Thomas: Matt. I don't- I, this is seven levels of racist inception. Like, what is he talking about? I haven't understood a single thing he said beyond like some white genocide type flavor.
0:14:06 Lydia: Mm-hmm.
0:13:58 Matt: Yeah. This is what we call high-context communication. You really have to be in on whatever talk show he's listening to every day.
0:14:12 Thomas: Yeah. Jesus.
0:14:14 Matt: But yeah, just for a little bit of context, Hamtrak, Michigan is a majority Muslim community. It's perfectly fine from everything I've seen. It seems like a nice place to live. But that's the caliphate, apparently, that is upon us. He just can't bring himself to say fuck in public, apparently, so he had to be like, fuck you into oblivion, which is very strange. I just wanted to note that. Very strange thing to say. 107 million also.
0:14:15 Lydia: I'm
0:14:33 Thomas: Who are the illegal aliens are
0:14:36 Matt: Aliens. Aliens.
0:14:36 Thomas: That, like, like Tim alien, like, Tim, who's who's coming for us
0:14:39 Lydia: Yeah,
0:14:39 Matt: Yeah. But that 107 million, I don't know. I mean, that's obviously not...
0:14:44 Thomas: One-third of all America is illegal, everybody
0:14:46 Matt: Yeah. What he means is that has some connection to foreign born, I guess. I mean, obviously, he's counting legal immigrants and all of that. But even with that, I don't know. I mean, now we're just talking about non-white people, obviously. There's more than that. But yeah. I mean, 107 million is a very specific number. I'd like to know where he got it, but I have no idea. I mean, I don't know where he get any of this stuff.
0:14:59 Thomas: Yeah.
0:15:06 Lydia: I feel like Rutgers had a responsibility to its students to not let this happen because it made everyone dumber. No, but it like made you more stupid having watched it and you're supposed to be getting an education like this is so bad.
0:15:11 Thomas: Well yeah you can't know but the student groups invited that, you can't stop them.
0:15:19 Lydia: Yeah, I know. I know.
0:15:20 Matt: Yeah.
0:15:20 Thomas: It's the lawsuits
0:15:20 Lydia: I know. But like, I just think like it's so dumb. It's so dumb.
0:15:24 Thomas: Is really dumb. Like, he's not even a good racist. Like, come on, get some, get some gumballs or what was it, the marbles, the, the one,
0:15:27 Lydia: There's nothing intellectual about this. It's just like, I don't know. It's embarrassing. Yeah, the gumballs.
0:15:33 Thomas: Matt?
0:15:34 Matt: Yeah, the gumballs.
0:15:35 Lydia: Yeah.
0:15:34 Thomas: Oh, gumballs? Yeah! Give me some gumballs, at least. Do something fun with your racism. Alright, should we finish this?
0:15:35 Matt: Yeah, yeah. A little bit, yeah.
0:15:35 Lydia: Yeah.
0:15:42 Clip: She gets around, the caliphate, the caliphate, hey, I don't give a damn about the caliphate, I'm American, you know, when we rolled into, into Little Mugadishu there, Minnesota, I thought the caliphate was gonna, and the old Mean Green team was going to fall back into the caliphate, right? They did fall back into the caliphate. It was exactly the opposite, the way it should have been, the way it needs to be, in this upcoming battle here on American soil. There ain't no damn caliphate here. Piss on your caliphates. It's America, right?
0:15:45 Matt: Yeah,
0:15:46 Thomas: What?
0:16:18 Thomas: Amerikr?
0:16:18 Clip: It's called our traditions, our values, our culture. That's why they say, hey, we'll be back. I think I heard, what's his name? My name is Bobby Jim Paul Mullen, that guy with all the first names, oh that guy, I think he's on Hannity tonight, they put him on Hannity there, apparently I'm speaking, got him all riled up here, that's good stuff.
0:16:40 Thomas: Wow, that's it?
0:16:37 Matt: That's why. So he thinks that they put the secretary of DHS on Hannity so that we wouldn't watch this. I wasn't going to watch this anyway, but sorry to make you watch it. Yeah, that's right.
0:16:47 Lydia: That's insane.
0:16:46 Thomas: Yeah. Those were my two choices. I have two channels. Hannity or this random place in Rutgers. Those are my two channels.
0:16:55 Lydia: Yeah. Right after Monday Night Football. Right. Which one am I going to tune into this Rutgers random talk?
0:17:00 Thomas: God, this is Amerikr.
0:17:00 Matt: So America, I would not usually put on unmitigated hate speech on our show, but this is from the the person who was running border patrol at the time when they killed two U.S. citizens in Minneapolis. I mean, this is really relevant, unfortunately. And this is who this man is, and this is what CBP is about. I mean, this is really pretty good representation.
0:17:14 Lydia: I
0:17:18 Thomas: Yeah. Absolute piece of shit There's, yeah.
0:17:22 Matt: Yeah. If
0:17:23 Thomas: Unacceptable that this person is alive in our country, don't even
0:17:26 Matt: Don't understand by now that immigration enforcement is a form of ethnic cleansing, and I'm saying that, of course, at the moment in a nonviolent sort of way, dragging people off the street and locking them up is pretty violent. Like that's what the intention is and that's what we're doing here. So, FYI, that's Craig Bovino, everyone.
0:17:39 Lydia: Just can't believe like the low level intellectualism, like zero intellectualism. Like I would be embarrassed as a college Republican. Like that's that's the big thinker we're getting to like sit and listen to in this, in this room. Like, absolutely not
0:17:44 Matt: Yeah.
0:17:45 Thomas: I can imagine yeah I imagine one of the racist college Republicans being like, uh, yeah, question what I don't like I'm with you on all the racism in the white genocide, but like, what was any of that? Like, I didn't understand
0:17:59 Lydia: Yeah
0:17:55 Matt: Well, can you finish a sentence, man, somewhere?
0:18:06 Thomas: Yeah What, who's something about of handy
0:18:07 Lydia: Bad
0:18:10 Matt: Imagine though,
0:18:10 Thomas: Yeah
0:18:10 Lydia: Gonna talk about Mark Wayne Mullen's name now
0:18:12 Matt: The nightmare blunt rotation of Kristi Noem, Tom Homan, and this guy, at the point at which they're all running things during this period in Trump history, having to be in a room with them, making decisions, talking, running the country,
0:18:17 Lydia: Yeah yeah policy being driven by Stephen Miller right like he's your bonus nightmare blunt rotation guy
0:18:26 Matt: Yes, of course. Yeah, that's right.
0:18:26 Thomas: I often make the joke of it's just racism noises, but this literally was just racism noises I don't even think, well, now she's on America now caliphate yeah caliphate, piss on caliphate what
0:18:34 Lydia: Was nothing else caliphate, caliphate caliphate
0:18:31 Matt: Yeah, straight up. For the record, I did look it up, and he made it 15 minutes into one battle after another. He said he had to watch it because he kept being told that the Stephen Locke job was just like him, and he couldn't make it. He just couldn't. He said it's freaking leftist DA nonsense.
0:18:39 Thomas: Oh probably because there's some, some sexual contact that happened between what's his name in that movie and the black woman, so he's probably like, I couldn't
0:18:52 Matt: Right. Well, the author pointed that out. He made it 15 minutes, which would be approximately when that happened. So there you you go.
0:18:59 Lydia: Wow
0:18:59 Thomas: Oh yeah, that must be it, he's like, this is not, can't watch this, yeah oh
0:19:01 Matt: Yeah. Yeah.
0:19:05 Lydia: Accurate this is not accurate, this is not something I would do
0:19:07 Thomas: Boy
0:19:08 Matt: All right. Well, we can go from something very, very stupid to the heights of intellectual conservatism. That's our next step. So let's take a break and let's do it.
0:19:08 Thomas: All right do we need to take our second break here All right, let's, uh, thank our second round of Hall of Fame patrons before we get to the Flight 93 election. Looking, looking forward to that. Thank you to Apprentice of Adventure, Charlie Charlie Kelly, Attorney Birdlaw. Nick Fish, probably a real person. Who is more insufferable, J.D. Vance or Ron DeSantis? I think we had that one, right? A negative phenomenon. 911, I forgot where I parked my stolen Patreon name. You got to fight for your right to ex parte. J. Sank, VML's last day as a GC is October 30th, next project TBA. What's a GC?
0:19:54 Matt: General contractor, I guess. I don't know. He a lawyer?
0:19:56 Lydia: No, no, no. Because they, well, they were on, they were, they were elected city council.
0:19:58 Thomas: It's vehicular men's laughter.
0:20:02 Matt: Oh, that's right.
0:20:03 Lydia: Was that it? But GC general council? I don't, yeah, I don't know. I don't think it's over.
0:20:04 Matt: Yeah.
0:20:04 Thomas: That can't to already be over right up
0:20:11 Lydia: VML. Yeah, follow up. Let us know what's going on.
0:20:11 Thomas: I don't, yeah, Congressional Dems are ready to rumble. Yeah, hero of Shapier and Mordavia.
0:20:21 Matt: Feel like I should know what that is. Sorry, folks.
0:20:22 Thomas: Don't know today's episode brought to you by the letter or something. Thomas Freeman, Cajunkilla, fraud fishy hates everything, Cavalry, Chris Simpson, increasing pledge to get into the top third. Oh, thank you so much, you're almost there, you are right there. I think another, if more people pledge, you'll get even higher. And anonymous Akilah, thanks so much. Top patrons, number two there. Group number two, Matt, the Flight 93 election, this is on Claremont Review of Books. Was this a a book, yeah.
0:20:34 Lydia: Dang.
0:20:49 Matt: Yep. We're really hitting in the Heights here. This is a Claremont Review, of course, published by Claremont Institute, which is a very interesting organization. If we haven't talked about it before, you're probably somewhat familiar, but they are very pretentious. Claim They to be very conservative, very intellectual, but they embraced Trump pretty quickly. I mean, they were one of the major drivers of Trump in 2016. I just want to note before we talk about anything else, and of course I would say this, but they should not be allowed to use Jensen Pro, which is the font that is throughout this website that we're looking at right now.
I just want to note the small caps that in the masthead are beautiful, just gorgeous if you're not looking right now. And then the small caps in the title, and then of course the Jensen-Perrow in the body, just beautiful font. And it just annoys me that these cretins are using it to publish this absolute shit. So this is one of those things where like many of the pieces we read, I think if you're not very smart or if you read it very fast, you might think he's making some kind of point, but we're going to
0:21:20 Lydia: It's too beautiful. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
0:21:44 Matt: Read didn't find a reason.
0:21:44 Thomas: Right away okay So we have, by Publius Decius Mus, okay.
0:21:47 Matt: Yes. So not only are you too cowardly to put your name on it, but you're going to put a pretentious Latin name on it. Let me tell you, Decius Mos, now the reason he used that is because that's a Roman general who sacrificed himself. The word devotion actually comes from the act of devotio, of sacrificing yourself during a battle to get the attention of the Chthonic powers or whatever so that you could win the battle. So he's naming himself after a pretentious thing from classical history of a general who sacrificed himself to save the nation.
0:21:51 Thomas: Yeah I
0:21:57 Lydia: What does that mean it's Always the Roman Empire with these men. I swear
0:22:17 Matt: Of course.
0:22:17 Thomas: Know it's just like that's their like easy shortcut to like, I'm smart, I'm using like, I don't fucking don't care but right away we've got the Flight 93 election and then we've got a like a revolver with one bullet in it.
0:22:18 Matt: Of course. Yep. Yep. Nope.
0:22:22 Lydia: Western civilization, let me virtue signal.
0:22:32 Matt: Russian roulette. We're mixing metaphors already.
0:22:34 Thomas: That's not even close, there's no connection to either of either of those things at all.
0:22:34 Lydia: Just put a plane
0:22:39 Matt: Yeah. Yeah, just call it the Russian roulette election because leave Flight 93 out of it. I mean, really, I had actually went back after I reread this. I hadn't read this in 10 years. I read it again. I actually went back and read the story of Flight 93 just to remind myself of how offensive this actually is. And
0:22:43 Lydia: Yeah
0:22:52 Thomas: Well others may have during the recent 25th anniversary yeah
0:22:57 Lydia: Yeah
0:22:58 Matt: Right. Oh, I also point out this was published very intentionally. This was published around the 15th anniversary, right? So this is right before, I think it's September 5th, yeah. So a week before the 15th anniversary, he publishes this nonsense.
0:22:58 Thomas: Oh yeah, September yeah September 5th 2016, wow. We're on the 10th anniversary of the the 15th, the anniversary of double anniversary.
0:23:15 Matt: Yeah, right, right. And obviously, Flight 93 was an incredible act of heroism from people that knew that they had no other choice. They knew what was going on by that point. They've been talking to loved ones, people on the ground. And to use this metaphor for the idea that you're going to vote for Donald Trump, that's the same. That's the same level of heroism and sacrifice.
0:23:27 Thomas: Yeah
0:23:37 Matt: Just to start with, yes,
0:23:37 Thomas: In in the Flight 93, did the did the people on the plane vote to put the terrorist in charge of the plane, they're like that's
0:23:44 Matt: Actually voted to charge the cockpit. They took a vote in the back of the plane.
0:23:45 Thomas: Yeah no I'm saying like the the for the for this to work they all vote and we're like, we like terrorists, but let them fly.
0:23:48 Lydia: For the metaphor, yeah. Man
0:23:47 Matt: Oh, right, yes. Yeah, I see what you're saying. Right. Yes. Right. That's right. That's That's right. What's the worst that could happen?
0:23:55 Lydia: Right
0:23:54 Thomas: Okay yeah but this is a hell of a first little disclaimer paragraph here. I assume they revealed later, right?
0:23:55 Matt: Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yes. So at the time in 2016, it might've actually still been too offensive to publish this under your own name. But of course, by the time that he was working in the Trump administration, nobody cared.
0:24:09 Thomas: It seems like it that's what I was gonna say, if you want to read that national
0:24:16 Lydia: Plubius Decius Moose was the pseudonym of Michael Anton, who in January of 2017 left the private sector to serve on the National Security Council.
0:24:24 Thomas: Security Council.
0:24:25 Lydia: For his many other writings.
0:24:25 Thomas: Uh
0:24:27 Matt: Yes. But as a flack, as a PR writer person, he was never actually in intelligence because this is not intelligent stuff.
0:24:28 Lydia: Yeah.
0:24:35 Thomas: It's still funny that you're like, oh yeah, guy the who wrote this as a suit under pseudonym, um, he mere months later was made part of the administration. Oh, okay, I'm sure I'm getting an unbiased take here.
0:24:44 Lydia: Yeah. Man. It was Deputy Assistant to the President for Strategic Communications was his title. Yeah. Yeah. Proceeded by Ben Rhodes. It was the position that Ben Rhodes had.
0:24:54 Thomas: Bad analogies head torture of analogies
0:25:01 Lydia: Yeah.
0:25:02 Matt: Just want to point a few things just before we get going about Michael Anton because this man has been, as I said, all over the place. He worked for Giuliani. You got to start with Giuliani as a speechwriter. He worked for BlackRock, company the that basically destroyed the housing market for a couple of years as an executive there, any number of other terrible corporate places. Hillsdale College, you might be familiar, obviously, as a Christian nationalist hub. I'm sure you've covered it where this worker will be sometime soon. Still associated with Hillsdale, I believe. Well, I'll probably think of a few others as we go, but he's just been all over in all kinds of places.
0:25:12 Thomas: I
0:25:13 Lydia: Crazy.
0:25:35 Matt: Of course, yes, but one of the big guys for charging 2025 in heritage. In the way we've been talking about this, there's only a few guys that are actually getting paid a lot of money to do this stuff. He's one of the guys.
0:25:34 Lydia: Project 2025 contributor, right? Yeah.
0:25:47 Thomas: Love that, so then he went on to like write something that was like, "Hey, we need to build a new plane to put terrorists back in it to fly into" more things, that's
0:25:54 Lydia: All right.
0:25:56 Matt: Now that we've taken the cockpit, yeah. Let's read this nonsense.
0:25:56 Thomas: Okay.
0:26:01 Lydia: 2016 is the Flight 93 election. Charge the cockpit or you die. You may die anyway. You or the leader of your party may make it into the cockpit and not know how to fly or land the plane. There are no guarantees.
0:26:13 Matt: We may have forgotten by now that Osama bin Laden was running for president against Donald Trump in 2016. With that information, Maybe this makes sense.
0:26:22 Lydia: Except one. If you don't try, death is certain. To compound the metaphor, for. A Hillary Clinton presidency is Russian roulette with a semi-auto. With Trump, at least you can spin the cylinder and take your chances. To ordinary
0:26:34 Matt: You can't play Russian with a semi-auto. I don't know very much about guns, but you can't do that.
0:26:36 Thomas: Yeah. What are you talking about No.
0:26:36 Lydia: Conservative ears, this sounds histrionic. The stakes can't be that high because they are never that high, except perhaps in the pages of Gibbon.
0:26:48 Matt: I just want to point out to any ears, this sounds histrionic. This is absurd.
0:26:51 Thomas: The pages of Gibbon, I don't know, fuck this stupid
0:26:54 Matt: Bryson Fall, the Roman emperor, the guy, Gibbon.
0:26:55 Thomas: Cool. Oh, could it get, that was my guess, yeah.
0:26:56 Matt: Yeah.
0:26:56 Lydia: Again, Roman Empire. Conservative intellectuals will insist that there has been no end of history and that all human outcomes are still possible. They will even, as Charles Kessler does, admit that America is in, quote, crisis. But how great is the crisis? Can things really be so bad if
0:27:12 Matt: I like this. Sorry, I just want to point out Charles Kessler is a big guy at the Claremont Review of Books. I think he was actually the editor. He is the editor now. So it's kind of funny to get to that little dig. But he's very very much inside the house. He's a Claremont guy all the way. So just a little internal fighting there for you.
0:27:28 Lydia: Eight years of Obama can be followed by eight more of Hillary, and yet constitutionalist conservatives can still reasonably hope for a restoration of our cherished ideals? Cruz in 2024.
0:27:40 Matt: Literally, that's how it's supposed to work. You get eight years of somebody you don't like, and then you elect a different guy that you don't like as much or you like more.
0:27:47 Lydia: Not to pick too much, in parentheses, on Kessler, who is less unwarrantedly optimistic than most conservatives, and who, at least, poses the right question, Trump or Hillary. Though his answer, quote, even if Trump had chosen his policies at random, they would be sounder than Hillary's, is unwarrantedly ungenerous. The truth is that Trump, the truth is that Trump articulated, if incompletely and inconsistently, the right stances on the right issues, immigration, trade, and war, right from the beginning.
0:28:07 Thomas: Did choose his policies at random? Oh,
0:28:08 Matt: Yeah, pretty much.
0:28:19 Thomas: Sure
0:28:20 Matt: All things he's been great on since then.
0:28:22 Lydia: Yeah, yeah.
0:28:23 Thomas: Let's catch up, let's see how did immigration go, how did trade go, how did war go? Oh, zero for three here.
0:28:24 Lydia: Oh my god. Yeah. But let us back up. One of the paradoxes, there are so many, of conservative thought over the last decade, at least, is the unwillingness even to entertain, attain, in italics, the possibility that America and the West are on a trajectory towards something very bad.
0:28:44 Thomas: Because that's all you fuckers do all the time all you say is how it's going to hell
0:28:47 Lydia: Yeah. It's better for them when they lose, actually, because then they can just sit in that and complain and whine.
0:28:52 Thomas: That's their whole thing so this is just one of these assholes doing that more like out, out, trajectory towards something bad in the rest of the party
0:28:56 Lydia: Fear monger. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
0:29:00 Matt: There is a theme that will develop throughout this piece about what he thinks is really wrong, and it's pretty hard to miss. Also, the things he thinks are wrong are funny to me.
0:29:09 Lydia: On the one hand, conservatives routinely present a litany of ills plaguing the body politic. Illegitimacy, crime.
0:29:15 Matt: Illegitimacy. I just want to point out, he starts out with people being born out of wedlock as his number one issue.
0:29:21 Lydia: Is that what he really means?
0:29:22 Thomas: Not, don't think that's what he means so if he's playing the body politic, illegitimacy massive expensive
0:29:23 Matt: I think that's what he means. I think just from knowing these people, I'm pretty sure he means people who are not married having kids.
0:29:30 Thomas: Intrusive out of control government, illegitimacy, huh?
0:29:35 Matt: He could just mean that he doesn't think the Obama administration is legitimate. I guess that's possible.
0:29:40 Thomas: Is it the birther thing? That's my mind went to the birther thing, like it's illegitimate because he wasn't born here, but I could be wrong because crime also doesn't, yeah. Maybe you're right. Let's see
0:29:40 Lydia: Yeah. Oh.
0:29:48 Matt: He's talking about social ills for the most part. I think he really means –
0:29:51 Lydia: Right.
0:29:50 Thomas: Yeah. The body politic being, you know, everybody essentially, but then illegitimacy, you might be right, like I'm genuinely grappling with this illegitimacy yeah.
0:29:59 Matt: Hard to imagine, but I think that's what he's saying.
0:30:01 Thomas: Okay.
0:30:02 Lydia: Moving on. Crime. Massive, expensive, intrusive, out-of-control government. Politically correct McCarthyism. Ever-higher taxes and ever-deteriorating services and infrastructure.
0:30:14 Matt: Because people from the Claremont Institute and Heritage are destroying the government.
0:30:17 Thomas: Ever higher taxes, yeah. Taxes are so fucking high for you
0:30:22 Lydia: Inability to win wars against tribal sub-third-world foes.
0:30:26 Matt: Just racism, straight up. Yeah,
0:30:28 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah, wow.
0:30:29 Thomas: Will change all that, don't worry.
0:30:31 Lydia: A disastrously awful educational system that churns out kids who don't know anything and at the primary and secondary levels can't or won't discipline disruptive punks, and at the higher levels saddle students with six-figure debts for the privilege.
0:30:45 Thomas: Are you talking about Bart Simpson what are you talking about disruptive punks
0:30:49 Lydia: Oh my god, what a terrible sentence.
0:30:52 Thomas: Yeah.
0:30:53 Matt: Terrible.
0:30:54 Lydia: And so on and drearily on. Like that portion of the mass where the priest asks for your private intentions, fill in any dismal fact about American decline that you want, and I'll stipulate it.
0:31:05 Matt: Okay. There are too many Republicans, Michael Anton. That's my dismal fact.
0:31:08 Thomas: That's that's too inside Catholic conservatism for me. I don't know what the fuck he's talking about. You know, that when you're at mass and the priest asks you for your private intentions, what the fuck you talking about? No, I'm not into your weird cult.
0:31:23 Lydia: Conservatives spend at least several hundred million dollars a year on think tanks, magazines, conferences, fellowships, and such, complaining about this, that, the other, and everything, oh, like you are right now, and yet these same conservatives are at root keepers of the status quo. Oh, sure, they want some things to change, they want their pet ideas adopted, tax deductions for having more babies and the like, many of them are even good ideas, but are any of them truly fundamental? Do they get to the heart of our problems?
0:31:50 Matt: Like how he's complaining that conservatives are at root keepers of the status quo. That's literally what it means, that that's what a conservative is, by definition.
0:31:57 Lydia: Yeah, to be conservative conservative,
0:31:51 Thomas: Wink yeah. To be fair, my my sister who went to Claremont, something yeah, like, they, this was how they felt, like in 2016, they, like, they hated Mitt Romney, they thought that was like, the you know, they felt they, about conservatives, I talked about this before, it's kind of interesting, they felt about Republicans rather how a lot of the left and far left feel about Democrats, where it's like, not, like they're they're not doing anything like they're just, and I think for us on the left, in my opinion, it's because the system is designed to not let you do anything. I mean, it's also, we have some bad Democrats here and there, but I think for me, my opinion, it's overwhelmingly because the system is designed to stop anything from happening and it's fucking impossible to get anything done.
The Supreme Court, the veto, the, the, um, filibuster, the structure of the Senate, like it's just designed to be impossible on the right. Right. I think what it is, is when you've promised a series of insane things and you've built your worldview out of lies, then you get into power and you can't do the things that you said because it's not real. Then the people who believe the lies still are like, well, they must not be trying hard enough or they must, you know. And so there was this attitude that like there's sort of a corporatist Republican that was
0:32:04 Lydia: Affiliated, kind of, yeah.
0:32:08 Matt: Mm-hmm. Right.
0:33:11 Thomas: Fine with the status quo because they're benefiting and they really needed somebody like Trump to come. So, I mean, this is how a lot of people felt.
0:33:16 Lydia: It up
0:33:19 Matt: Out Anton that is also one of the proponents of the the Red Caesar meme. Do you remember this? Red Caesar? It was the idea that Trump...
0:33:26 Thomas: Red Caesar, Red Caesar, send Trump right over.
0:33:27 Lydia: Another Roman Empire thing,
0:33:30 Matt: Yes, another Roman Empire thing. That we needed a Republican dictator, Red Caesar. That's literally what he was saying. And it goes straight to Thomas's point. That's the only way that anything's going to change. We got to get somebody who can cut through everything and just take over and do everything we want and get daddy in office, basically. And so he's very much behind the idea of the Red Caesar, which is obviously inherently undemocratic, but he clearly has done with democracy. It's pretty obvious from this piece.
0:33:52 Lydia: If conservatives are right about the importance of virtue, morality, religious faith, stability, character, and so on in the individual, if they are right about sexual morality, or what, what came to be termed, quote, "family values," if they are right about the importance of education to inculcate good character and to teach the fundamentals that have defined knowledge in the West for millennia, if they are right about societal norms and public order, if they are right about societal nor-
0:34:01 Thomas: No, they're not.
0:34:12 Thomas: You can stop. You're not right. The answer is no. This is like when you're doing the equation in Excel and you do like the formula tracker and you're like, where did this go wrong? And it's the very first thing you did was like false, wrong. You know, you're like, oh, well, the rest of this doesn't need to happen.
0:34:21 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah,
0:34:28 Matt: And there's some of this I can agree with, but it's so preachy and not very much of it I can agree with.
0:34:33 Lydia: I don't know. If they are right about the centrality of initiative, enterprise, industry, and thrift to a sound economy and a healthy society, if they are right about the soul-sapping effects of paternalistic big government and its cannibalization, yeah, that'll drive a strong economy, yeah.
0:34:43 Thomas: Thrift, thrift. Know. What's good for your economy? Thrift. Everybody just being cheap and not spending money, that's what's good for the economy.
0:34:54 Matt: Just wear sweaters. Don't put your head on. Yeah.
0:34:58 Lydia: If they are right about the soul-sapping effects of paternalistic big government and its cannibalization of civil society and religious institutions, if they are right about the necessity of a strong defense and prudent statesmanship in the international sphere, if they are right about the importance of all this to national health and even survival, Then they must believe, mustn't they, that we are headed off a cliff.
0:35:19 Matt: The only conclusion you could possibly draw that we're headed off a cliff. Again, I don't remember Flight 93 going off a cliff, but I guess that's...
0:35:29 Lydia: Man,
0:35:29 Thomas: Really doesn't fit, like the metaphor just does not fit whatsoever.
0:35:30 Matt: No. No.
0:35:32 Thomas: Why?
0:35:33 Lydia: I also just can't get over that this is like a single sentence. It's driving me crazy.
0:35:36 Matt: Right. Well, and also, the implication that we don't care about any of those things, like we don't think that education is good for character, that we don't think that people should work hard and start businesses. I mean, it's just that we're the complete opposite of everything. Yeah, come on. You've just talked to us. Come on.
0:35:43 Lydia: Oh, yeah. Absolutely condescending. Yeah. Yeah. Not real. But it's quite obvious that conservatives don't believe any such thing, that they feel no such sense of urgency of an immediate necessity to change course and avoid the cliff. A recent article by Matthew Continetti may be taken as representative. Indeed, almost written for the purpose of illustrating the point. Continetti inquires into the, quote, condition of America and finds it wanting. What does Continetti propose to do about it? The usual litany of, quote, conservative, quote, solutions with the obligatory references to decentralization, federalization, quote, civic renewal and, of course, Burke. What's Burke?
0:36:25 Matt: The kids love Burke, Edmund Burke. I can't say I'm right on myself, but just traditional
0:36:30 Thomas: Is it So what does that mean in that
0:36:31 Matt: Conservatism.
0:36:30 Lydia: I don't know who he is. Who he is? Who is he?
0:36:33 Matt: He's, I believe, an English philosopher from I think 19th century, but I can triple check.
0:36:36 Thomas: Like I recognize the name but I can't think immediately of what that means in this sentence?
0:36:42 Lydia: Which is to say, conservatism's typical combination of the useless and inapt with the utopian and unrealizable. Decentralization and federalism are all well and good, and as a conservative, I endorse them both without reservation. But how are they going to save or even meaningfully improve the America that Continente describes? What can they do against a tidal wave of dysfunction, immorality, and corruption? Option. Quote, civic renewal would do a lot, of course, but that's like saying health will save a cancer patient. A step has been skipped in there somewhere. How are we going to achieve, quote, civic renewal? Wishing for
0:37:16 Thomas: The cancer patient a very large tumor, a massive tumor to shake it up, that's how we're gonna do it, okay.
0:37:22 Lydia: A tautology to enact itself is not a strategy.
0:37:27 Thomas: Yeah, so so there's a couple options here, maybe they don't really believe it, and maybe, you know, or they're not understanding how bad things are, or maybe things just aren't as bad as you're saying. Like the things this guy thinks are bad are just not real, that could be part of it.
0:37:37 Matt: Yeah, yeah. Maybe Hillary Quinton. Well, this is one of the reasons I want to read this is because you'll start to see, this starts to unravel as we go. We can skip the continuity paragraph. Honestly, I don't want to hear any more of this continuity piece. This piece is long enough as it is. There's something that he's going to be, of course, by the end of the piece, the mask will slip and we'll see what it's really about. So yeah, we might ask,
0:37:59 Thomas: Do you want want to skip to okay.
0:37:59 Matt: I think. Yeah, Yeah, there you go. Yeah, right there.
0:38:01 Lydia: We may also reasonably ask, what explains the Pollyanna-ish declinism? Is that how you would say that? Declinism?
0:38:08 Thomas: Maybe your teclanism? I'm not sure.
0:38:10 Lydia: What explains the Pollyannish declinism of so many others? That is, the stance that things are really bad, but not so bad that we have to consider anything really different. The obvious answer is that they don't really believe the first half of that formulation. If so, like Chicken Little, they should stick a sock in it. Pecuniary reasons also suggest themselves, but let us forswear recourse to this explanation nation until we have disproved all the others. This is so obnoxious.
0:38:32 Thomas: I'm glad you found your dad's dictionary.
0:38:35 Lydia: Yeah, this,
0:38:37 Thomas: Are trying to prove
0:38:37 Matt: Forsooth, good sir. What does forswear recourse?
0:38:38 Thomas: Yeah. God
0:38:39 Lydia: It's infuriating to read.
0:38:41 Thomas: Let us forswear recourse to this explanation until we have disproved all the others.
0:38:47 Lydia: Obnoxious.
0:38:48 Thomas: You can just talk man, you just say fucking things.
0:38:48 Matt: Dumb guy's idea of a smart guy. Yeah. Yeah.
0:38:49 Lydia: Yeah. Whatever the reason for the contradiction, there can be no doubt that there is a contradiction. To simultaneously hold conservative cultural, economic, and political beliefs to insist that our liberal left present reality and future direction is incompatible with human nature and must undermine society, society, and yet also believe that things can go on more or less the way they are going, ideally, but not necessarily with some conservative tinkering here and there, is logically impossible.
0:39:14 Thomas: Man, man, or, and again, or just even going from the conservative point of view at this time, or they're like, well, maybe the solution to the person's cancer isn't throwing that person in an incinerator. Like, no, just, but I'll change it up, you can't keep going how you are. Yeah. But I, I, I think that's worse. Like, I think, I think throwing the person in an incinerator, I might get rid of the cancer, I guess, in a way, but I don't think that's good. You know, could just be that because this idea that you have, oh well, there's no choice, we have to elect a fucking insane person to do whatever, like that's just the only way, it's the only way.
0:39:40 Matt: And the person. Yeah.
0:39:54 Lydia: Well, but that's his whole like Flight 93 position, right? It's like, well, the plane's going down anyway. So like, I with regard to the cancer patient, like the person, it's terminal anyway. So what's the difference? Like, let's do the more terrible approach and just kill them now. I don't, yeah, I don't know.
0:39:56 Matt: Right.
0:39:59 Thomas: Don't, flight, there's no rehabilitating the Flight 93 metaphor, I'm sorry.
0:40:11 Matt: No. It's...
0:40:13 Thomas: It doesn't make sense, like yeah, like, even going, he's thinking we're, so we're, we're flying toward something bad, but his whole, whole point is that other people are saying we are, but they're not really acting as though we are, right, like that doesn't fit at all with the metaphor it'd Be like if you're flying to like, uh, your death, and then other people like, "No, we're just kind of flying to Florida, which sucks, but it's not as bad, arguably," and then you're like, "No, we gotta, we gotta take control of the cockpit and possibly just die." Like, I don't, I don't, that doesn't, it's not even what he's saying. It doesn't make any sense, it doesn't make any sense.
0:40:13 Matt: Yeah. And he's not even going to try by the end. Yeah. No. It's terrible.
0:40:28 Matt: They don't mean it. I mean it. Right.
0:40:54 Matt: But neither does saying that the liberal left present reality, which remember remember, is Obama's second term. That's what he's writing about. It's incompatible with human nature. The idea that we're just trying to give people healthcare and education is incompatible with human nature. And it may rein in capitalism a little bit.
0:40:59 Lydia: Yeah.
0:41:08 Lydia: It's a dark way to think about human beings, like trying to take care of people is incompatible with human nature. Cool. Let's be very blunt here. If you genuinely think things can go on with no fundamental change needed, then you have implicitly admitted that conservatism is wrong. Wrong philosophically, wrong on human nature, wrong on the nature of politics, and and wrong in its policy prescriptions.
0:41:11 Matt: It sure is. Yeah.
0:41:30 Matt: Go with you there, sure.
0:41:31 Thomas: Sure.
0:41:32 Lydia: Because, first, few of those prescriptions are enforced today. Second, of the ones that are, the left is busy undoing them, often with conservative assistance. And third, the whole trend of the West is ever leftward, ever further away from what we all understand as conservatism.
0:41:46 Matt: What we all understand is conservatism. Okay.
0:41:47 Thomas: Boy. Yeah.
0:41:50 Lydia: If your answer, Continetti's, Doothat, wow,
0:41:52 Thomas: Dude hat. We get a dude hat reference.
0:41:53 Matt: Shout out.
0:41:54 Lydia: Little Doothat shout out, Solemn's, is that how you say that?
0:41:57 Matt: I know him.
0:41:58 Lydia: And so many others, is for conservatism to keep doing what it's been doing, another policy journal, another article about welfare reform, another half-day seminar on limited government, another tax credit proposal, even though we've been losing ground for at least a century, then you've implicitly accepted that your supposed political philosophy doesn't matter, and that civilization will carry on just fine under leftist tenets, indeed that leftism is truer than conservatism, conservatism, and superior to it.
0:42:24 Matt: Just by being a a regular conservative, you're admitting defeat, I guess.
0:42:28 Thomas: Again, it's just by them saying Trump's not a good idea, that's all it is. Like, you could just be like, no, I, I'm, I'm super conservative, I agree with all that, I also think we're not headed in a good direction. Like, if you're conservative but Trump is, that'll make it worse.
0:42:43 Lydia: That's not the answer.
0:42:43 Thomas: Like It's Like
0:42:44 Matt: The smartest
0:42:44 Lydia: Yeah. That can't be the answer.
0:42:45 Matt: Thing that Lindsey Graham ever said, that it'll take the party down and we'll deserve it. He was right.
0:42:49 Thomas: Eventually, I don't know what
0:42:52 Lydia: Will say, in words reminiscent of dorm room Marxism, but our proposals have not been tried here, our ideas sit waiting to be implemented, to which I reply, not really, many conservative solutions, above all welfare reform and crime control, have been tried and proved effective, but have nonetheless failed to stem the tide. Crime, for instance, is down from its mid-70s and early 90s peak, but way, way up from the historic American norm that ended when liberals took over criminal justice in the mid-60s.
0:43:20 Matt: That? No, that's not history. That's so facile.
0:43:25 Lydia: Doesn't make sense.
0:43:21 Thomas: There's no possible way That's true. There's no way the tracking was the same back then, you know, like there's just
0:43:28 Lydia: Mm-hmm.
0:43:28 Matt: No, the concept of crime, it's always fun the way they... Yeah.
0:43:29 Thomas: Absolutely no way took over, we did, we take over criminal justice in the mid-60s?
0:43:37 Matt: I mean, there's the Warren Court. I think that's what he means. That was the height of in terms of rights for people so that police don't beat them up to get confessions.
0:43:40 Lydia: Uh. Yeah.
0:43:37 Thomas: Yeah. Oh, oh, okay. Just that Okay. When someone says they, we took over criminal justice, I would assume they mean, like, we became in charge of the, yeah, criminal justice.
0:43:48 Matt: Deny them lawyers. Cops. Yeah. All the police chiefs.
0:43:53 Thomas: Yeah, not we made it so you can't beat a guy to a confession, like that's the court was like, hey, you have to give a guy a lawyer, ah, he's fucking liberals taking over criminal justice.
0:43:54 Matt: Yeah. FBI. Yeah. And yeah.
0:43:58 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah.
0:44:06 Matt: Yep. I think that's what he means. And there's also a bunch of other reasons and we don't need to get into now, but sociologists talk about the thing we call crime rising and falling during these times, but nothing Whatever. Anyway.
0:44:06 Thomas: Okay. Once again, maybe you're right.
0:44:10 Lydia: Wow.
0:44:15 Thomas: Yeah. And it's, you have to invent a fake past that was better to try to deny the fact that crime is massively down, a lot of, and they're like, you said, they're like, there's lead fucking paint and lead, like, there's just a bunch of weird reasons that kind of combine to to, uh, to, there was a real crime wave and then, uh, you know, and it was really bad, and now it's way, way, way better, in order to deny that you have to invent a time probably before the stats were kept in the same way, whereas, like, yeah, no, it was all great, you know, it was, it was, it was the time, what does he say, up from the historic American norm that ended, what is that historic American norm, I wonder,
0:44:23 Matt: Yeah. Oh, yeah. Ah, yes. The
0:44:23 Lydia: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
0:44:58 Thomas: Like what fire hoses on black people and stuff, like, what do you think that was?
0:44:59 Matt: Elusive historic American norm.
0:45:01 Lydia: Yeah. I think it would have to be. And it's rising fast today in the teeth of ineffectual conservative complaints. And what has this temporary crime or welfare, for that matter, decline?
0:45:12 Thomas: You're just declaring it temporary, I've seen that, by the way, I'm from the future, it's temporary.
0:45:21 Lydia: What is the temporary crime or welfare, for that matter, decline done to stem the greater tide? The tsunami of leftism that still engulfs our every literal and figurative shore has receded not a bit, but indeed has grown. All your our victories are short lived.
0:45:37 Matt: Tsunami. Tsunami.
0:45:37 Thomas: I love this, yeah, because it's like, I don't get it, crime has gone on down, and yet things still aren't like how I wanted them to be. Well, maybe it's because you were fear-mongering on crime and that wasn't an issue. Like maybe that's what it is. Oh boy.
0:45:49 Lydia: Mm-hmm. More to the point, what has conservatism achieved lately? In the last 20 years? The answer, which appears to be, quote, nothing, might seem to lend credence to the plea that, quote, our ideas haven't been tried.
0:46:04 Thomas: It's a lot worse than nothing. I would take nothing in a heartbeat over the Iraq war and that entire decade, you know, that entire eight years of Bush. Nothing would have been a massive upgrade.
0:46:06 Lydia: Mm, yeah. Mm-hmm. Except that the same conservatives who generate those ideas are in charge of selling them to the broader public. If their ideas, quote, haven't been tried, who is ultimately at fault? The whole enterprise of conservatism incorporated Incorporated reeks of failure. Its sole recent and ongoing success is its own self-preservation. Conservative intellectuals never tire of praising, quote, entrepreneurs and, quote, creative destruction. Dare to fail, they exhort businessmen. Let the market decide. Except, um, not with respect to us. Or is their true market not the political arena but the fundraising circuit? Only three questions matter. First, how bad are things really?
0:46:55 Thomas: You go. Yeah.
0:46:56 Lydia: Second, what do we do right right now? Third, what should we do for the long term?
0:46:58 Thomas: Okay. I kind of want to see how he answers these.
0:47:04 Lydia: Conservative Inc.'s answer, in quotes, to the first may at this point simply be dismissed. If the conservatives wish to have a serious debate, I for one am game, more than game, eager. The problem of, quote, subjective certainty can only be overcome by going into the agora. But my attempt to do so, the blog that Kessler mentions, was met largely with incredulity. Is that how I would say that? Sorry, guys.
0:47:20 Thomas: Shut up.
0:47:28 Lydia: I don't Know. Know, whatever.
0:47:28 Matt: I love the pettiness of this, of complaining about what the editor of the Claremont Review of Books said about your blog post in this influential piece.
0:47:29 Lydia: Yeah.
0:47:30 Thomas: This is Doesn't Matter, like Yeah.
0:47:37 Lydia: Can they say that? Question mark, exclamation point. How can anyone apparently of our cast conservative intellectuals not merely support Trump, however lukewarmly, but offer reasons for doing for doing So doing do Is What he wrote, doing So Is what he means
0:47:52 Thomas: Doing Do Ah You Idiot.
0:47:50 Matt: Doing due. Come on. Claremont Review of Books, get a proofreader.
0:47:55 Lydia: Uh Yeah.
0:47:57 Thomas: Illiterate. Fucking Piece of shit
0:47:58 Lydia: Assistant Deputy, whatever Of strategic Communication One of, one of the Journal of American Greatness's deeper arguments was that only in a corrupt republic, in corrupt times, could a Trump rise. It is therefore puzzling that those most horrified by Trump are the least willing to consider the possibility that the republic is dying. That possibility apparently seems to to to them so preposterous that no refutation is necessary. As does, presumably, the argument that the stakes in 2016 are everything. I should here note that I am a good deal gloomier than my former JAG colleagues, and that while we frequently use the royal, quote, we, when discussing things on which we all agreed, I here speak only for myself. How have the last two decades worked out for you personally? If you're a member or fellow traveler of the Davos class, chances are, pretty well. Well, if you're among the subspecies, conservative, intellectual, or politician, you've accepted, perhaps not consciously, but unmistakably, your status on the roster of the Washington Generals of American Politics. Your job is to show up and lose, but you are a necessary part of the show and you do get paid.
0:48:01 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah.
0:48:10 Matt: Correct.
0:49:02 Thomas: We Won One Presidential election in 2008 and the, you know, good congressional results after the biggest fuck up piece of shit president in history who ruined the world, and then they wiped us out in 2010. Like, what is all this victory that, like, like, weird, like, the left is the fucking Globetrotters What Are you talking about
0:49:03 Matt: Hey, I've got the
0:49:17 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah.
0:49:21 Matt: Tsunami. Yeah. And it turns out when you are the globe charters, you actually can't do the job either. So you're still the generals.
0:49:29 Lydia: Yeah.
0:49:29 Thomas: So Weird It's just the victim, victim complex here.
0:49:32 Matt: Yeah.
0:49:33 Lydia: To the extent that you were ever on the winning side of anything, it's a sophist who helped the Davoisi oligarchy. I don't know. Is that how it is? Okay.
0:49:40 Thomas: No, yeah, that is it. It is, but it's just like this fucking jack-off motion of writing. Davois-y oligarchy.
0:49:44 Lydia: Yeah, exactly. Rationalize open borders, lower wages, outsourcing, de-industrialization, trade giveaways, and endless pointless winless war. All of Trump's 16 Republican competitors would have ensured more of the same, as will the election of Hillary Clinton. That would be bad enough. But at least Republicans are merely reactive when it comes to wholesale cultural and political change. Their, quote, opposition may be in all cases ineffectual and often and indistinguishable from support, but they don't dream up inanities like 32, quote, genders. Oh, Michael is 72 now.
0:50:16 Thomas: See, back then, yeah.
0:50:17 Matt: Here we go.
0:50:18 Lydia: It's 72. We've grown, Michael.
0:50:20 Thomas: This is going to be confusing for current listeners.
0:50:22 Lydia: Aren't you happy?
0:50:23 Thomas: Back then, we were only at 32 genders. You have to do the convert. Yeah, exactly.
0:50:26 Matt: Inflation, man.
0:50:27 Thomas: Man, it really, and it was comparable to 32 for a while until COVID hit, and then it was just like, fuck, it was like 60, you know, because it's just inflation.
0:50:25 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Everything's more expensive now. Elective bathrooms.
0:50:37 Thomas: Elective bathrooms. What, as opposed to like mandatory bathrooms? We have the, I love how when they pretend like there isn't such a thing as an all-gender bathroom when that's obviously how most bathrooms are, like just like your small business or something it's like, yeah, we have a bathroom in the back is it for penises or it's like, no, you just, there's a toilet, you, you fucking idiot. Just go use the toilet.
0:50:39 Lydia: Yep. Yeah. Yep. Yep. A single bathroom that everybody uses. Crazy. Honestly, like, just a second on the bathroom talk. Like, the most egregious thing about bathrooms is the fact that the United States doesn't have walls that go all the way down. Like, that is the single most ridiculous thing I've ever heard and seen in bathrooms.
0:51:05 Thomas: God. Yeah. Yeah, it really is. Some of our airports have the good kind.
0:51:17 Lydia: Oh, it's so
0:51:18 Thomas: And then I'm like, oh my God, this is the best.
0:51:18 Lydia: Nice. And then it doesn't matter. Everybody go in the same area together. You have a completely closed-off room, and then we wash our hands next to each other because it's not a big deal. None of it matters.
0:51:22 Thomas: Yeah. Doesn't matter. I could be going to the bathroom next to the queen. Wouldn't care. Oh, she's dead.
0:51:29 Lydia: Wouldn't care.
0:51:31 Thomas: I don't want to use, the king's not as fun.
0:51:31 Matt: We're also bad at having them.
0:51:33 Thomas: It's fun to say like the queen. Or you say, oh, the king, like fucking kick his ass in the bathroom. Fuck that guy.
0:51:34 Matt: Yeah.
0:51:32 Lydia: No, King Charles sucks. Yeah. All right, he continues his list. Single-payer, Iran sycophancy, quote, "Islamophobia" in quotes, okay, and Black Lives Matter. They merely help ratify them.
0:51:50 Matt: I can promise you he is Islamophobic. That is not supposed to be in quotes. But yeah. So Iran's sycophants, yeah. I love the alternative that we've come up with.
0:51:55 Lydia: A real thing.
0:51:58 Thomas: Yeah, no. So he's saying that we've come up with the fake concept of Islamophobia to and we're labeling them that.
0:52:03 Lydia: Yes. Exactly.
0:52:03 Matt: Yes, of course. Yes. That's right. That's what I'm saying. Yeah. But he's, I promise.
0:52:06 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah.
0:52:06 Lydia: Right. Lives matter in 2016 is pretty early, isn't it?
0:52:11 Thomas: Yeah, it is pretty early, but
0:52:13 Lydia: Yeah, I mean that that movement yeah yeah fair,
0:52:14 Thomas: Were they hated it right away.
0:52:13 Matt: He's on it. He's ahead of it. Yeah. Before it was
0:52:16 Thomas: They wouldn't let those black lives matter for even a second.
0:52:17 Matt: Cool.
0:52:17 Lydia: Fair. A Hillary presidency will be peddled to the metal on the entire progressive left agenda. Okay.
0:52:25 Thomas: Yeah, oh yeah, yeah, no.
0:52:25 Matt: Oh, no doubt.
0:52:28 Lydia: Plus items few of us have yet imagined in our darkest moments. Wow.
0:52:33 Matt: Is that good?
0:52:33 Thomas: You're already doing that all the time. The thing you fuckers produce is the just like a brainstorm of horrors that you're imagining every day that aren't real.
0:52:38 Matt: Yeah.
0:52:35 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yep. Nor is even that the worst. It will be coupled with a level of vindictive persecution against against resistance and dissent hitherto seen in the supposedly liberal West only in the most, quote, advanced Scandinavian countries and the most leftist corners of Germany and England. We see this already in the censorship practiced by the Davoisese social media enablers.
0:52:51 Matt: Wow.
0:53:01 Thomas: Oh, Man. Are you talking about? Who the fuck is any of that? God.
0:53:10 Matt: They're so mad about shadow banning. They're still talking about shadow banning.
0:53:11 Lydia: Yeah. In the shameless propaganda tidal wave of the mainstream media and in the personal destruction campaigns operated through the former and aided by the latter of the social justice warriors. We see it in Obama's flagrant use of the IRS to torment political opponents, torment political opponents, the gaslighting denial by the media, and the collective shrug by everyone else.
0:53:28 Thomas: My god, so stupid, stupid. No, man, there's a report into that. It's fucking nothing. Literally fucking nothing.
0:53:37 Lydia: Yeah.
0:53:38 Matt: He's never going to believe what Trump's going to use the IRS to do.
0:53:40 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. And it's also like, even if there was anything untoward in that IRS, it had nothing the fuck to do with Obama, like at all. And there, I think my understanding is there, I looked into that once. It's something we could debunk sometime, but it was just like nothing. It was fucking nothing.
0:53:48 Lydia: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. It's absurd
0:53:58 Matt: Like everything else in this paragraph.
0:53:58 Thomas: Yeah. Nothing even happened. That IRS one is so dumb. It was like, oh, there's some some conservative groups who's like they needed a little more like what was it like a little more processing or paperwork for their status, you know, or five ones, but it didn't even matter, none of them lost their state, it was nothing. That's my memory of it, I, correct me if I'm wrong, it's been a minute, but anyway, go on, we don't have time right now.
0:54:20 Lydia: To assume that any of this would stop or slow, would do anything other than massively intensify, in a Hillary administration. It's even more ridiculous to expect that hitherto useless conservative opposition would suddenly become effective. For two generations, at least, the left has been calling everyone to the right Nazis.
0:54:35 Thomas: Memory Lane, everybody, sorry, this is important as he's speaking, Matt, how long has, uh, a seat in the Supreme Court gone unfilled? Because of incredibly, I mean, whatever you want to call it, effective by a conservative who's now a vegetable.
0:54:46 Lydia: At this point.
0:54:54 Matt: Mitch McConnell. Yeah. No, very effective.
0:54:57 Thomas: What are you talking about? What was the timing on that, how long was it, it was it wasn't like 10 months?
0:54:58 Matt: Yeah. It was a long time. It was way too long. I was
0:55:03 Lydia: Yeah.
0:55:03 Thomas: Literally as this asshole speak, go ahead, sorry, man, yeah.
0:55:06 Lydia: Yeah.
0:55:07 Matt: Going to say, this is fascism though. This is the classic thing of we have no power. We're so weak, but yet we're also the strongest country on earth, right? We have no power. We can't possibly do anything. We're just poor little Little bennies.
0:55:12 Thomas: Yep. Yeah. 293 days.
0:55:18 Matt: Great
0:55:19 Thomas: So from March 16th, 2016 to, and mind you, this is September, what was it? Fifth or something, 2016. So at this point it's been six months, unheard of, right, Matt? Unheard of. Six months of the Republicans, Republicans, not even allowing the black man to get a Supreme Court pick, and it's just empty, this is just empty at this point.
0:55:19 Lydia: Wow. Hmm.
0:55:30 Matt: Point. Great point. Yeah.
0:55:40 Thomas: He's like, "Oh these do-nothing Republicans are like, 'Fuck you, asshole.'"
0:55:40 Matt: I think you mean the hitherto useless conservative opposition, I think is what you're talking about there. Yeah. Hitherto useless.
0:55:48 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah.
0:55:48 Thomas: Yeah, exactly. Fucking Jesus Christ, at least give Corpsey whatever, it's just absolute He's no longer with us, his body is here but he's no longer with us.
0:55:56 Matt: Some credit.
0:56:00 Lydia: Yeah.
0:56:00 Thomas: Give McConnell his due, Jesus, Jesus Christ. Guy did more for the Nazis than you ever will.
0:56:07 Lydia: Honestly. Honestly.
0:56:07 Thomas: I mean, yeah,
0:56:07 Matt: It's funny. I also want to point out that I had not been calling everyone to my right Nazis until a couple of years ago when they actually started to become Nazis, Nazis. So, yeah.
0:56:15 Thomas: Yeah. I mean, it's probably been more than a couple of years, but it was right around this time, to be honest with you. You know, when they were doing the Charlottesville thing, it was when they all became Nazis. If I'm thinking about it, it was kind of then it was when I started calling them Nazis.
0:56:19 Matt: Yeah, I'm sure. Yeah, right. Yeah. That'll do it.
0:56:26 Lydia: According to him, though, it's been two generations of the left calling everyone to the right Nazis. I mean, I guess there's an element of it where if you go back two generations at that point in time, it is closer to like there being actual Nazis.
0:56:26 Matt: Yeah.
0:56:30 Thomas: Oh yeah, sure.
0:56:40 Matt: There were Nazis.
0:56:40 Thomas: Well, What he's probably talking about is the times when there were actual, actual Nazis. Like when what's his name ran, you, the KKK guy, ran for what, his governor or something. Uh You know, there have been individual cases, like, if he's trying to go back to like the '80s and '90s, like, but it was not the case. Like, I was alive then.
0:56:41 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm.
0:56:59 Thomas: You know, it was not the case that everyone called every Republican a Nazi or whatever. It's not true, it's fucking fake.
0:57:02 Lydia: No. Yeah.
0:57:04 Matt: Well, and traditional conservatives were pretty openly supporting Hitler right up until the war and are enabling him in lots of ways in America. So that's something too.
0:57:13 Lydia: Sorry. And But again, he's saying generations. He's not saying decades. He's saying it's been two generations, like like going back to the boomer or I guess.
0:57:16 Matt: Yeah. Right. That's what I'm saying. Yeah.
0:57:20 Thomas: Well, How many generations? Yeah, that is like 30 years, right?
0:57:21 Lydia: Yeah. From 2016, that would be not Gen Z. So it'd be it would be boomers.
0:57:27 Thomas: A generation isn't, in like, 15 years usually that you think of until the next one, or is it like 20? I can't remember. It's not it's yeah.
0:57:31 Lydia: Yeah, I don't know.
0:57:33 Matt: You're giving it more thought than he did as
0:57:34 Lydia: Yeah, that's probably true. True. This trend has accelerated exponentially in the last few years, helped along by some on the right who really do seem to merit and even relish the label.
0:57:43 Matt: Why is that, do you think?
0:57:45 Lydia: Yeah.
0:57:46 Thomas: Man, and it's been helped along by, you know, the Nazis
0:57:49 Matt: Nazis.
0:57:49 Lydia: The Nazis that vote along with us, our friends and neighbors.
0:57:53 Thomas: That's such a funny sentence.
0:57:56 Lydia: There is nothing the modern conservative fears more than being called, quote, racist. So alt-right pocket Nazis are manna from heaven for the left.
0:57:58 Thomas: Uh,
0:58:01 Matt: Don't think that's true. Pocket Nazis?
0:58:05 Thomas: I mean I will give him credit, I I do think that that was true in a sense. I think there there was a real dichotomy. I think that a lot of the reactionary right and center right was they might, they, they went to Trump and they went to these culture war, the other side of the culture wars with a perception that things they were doing that used to not be racist were now racist. Like they were deathly afraid, especially under Obama.
Like they would have, there was a lot of just like poison pill arguments where it's like, oh, so this is racist, I'm doing if I'm doing this. And there was a lot of reactionary white people who just got, they, they really did care that like they thought they were being called racist all the time and they really weren't, like maybe sometimes, but like for the most part it's it's that thing where again it's it's the fascist, it's the reactionary mind. Any little perceived insult from some, you know, the other side or someone who's a person of color is perceived as this massive deal to them, like if if anyone said like, hey, that might be a little racially problematic, they'd be like, oh, oh, so I'm the KKK. Like, it's
0:59:00 Lydia: Right. Right.
0:59:07 Thomas: Just this overreaction. That's how they work.
0:59:07 Matt: All right. I do want to know what a pocket Nazi is. It sounds easier to defeat, I'll tell you that.
0:59:14 Thomas: So alt-right pocket Nazis are manna from heaven.
0:59:17 Matt: I'd love to be able to. You can squash them.
0:59:17 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. They're for travel. You know, they can, they fit in the overhead bin. Alt-right pocket Nazis.
0:59:23 Matt: Pocket Nazis.
0:59:21 Lydia: Just like Bovino, right? It's just like little short guys. He's a little pocket Nazi.
0:59:29 Matt: A pocket Nazi with
0:59:29 Thomas: We let off. You're right. This is perfect, Matt. You planned it. You accidentally planned it perfectly. We let off. It should be the new segment.
0:59:34 Matt: A pocket Nazi.
0:59:35 Thomas: When it's not an amuse-douche, it's an alt-right pocket Nazi, he fits in your pocket.
0:59:39 Matt: It's a really funny thing to call somebody.
0:59:41 Thomas: You take him and you put him down, okay. Gregory, here, go back in my pocket now, little guy.
0:59:42 Lydia: Yeah. A little Keebler elf.
0:59:42 Matt: New from Hasbro.
0:59:46 Thomas: He's like, you picture him, like, tussling in the, in the fabric, you know, like like a cartoon yeah, you see, he had arms and Nazi salutes in there, oh, good times, god.
0:59:50 Matt: Trying to do his salutes and...
0:59:49 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But also wholly unnecessary. Sauce for the goose. The left was calling us Nazis long before any pro-Trumpers tweeted Holocaust denial memes.
1:00:05 Matt: So, okay, this is who you're in bed with. You understand it, at least.
1:00:07 Lydia: So leave us alone. Leave us alone.
1:00:10 Thomas: That's so, imagine that being part of your argument. It was like you guys, you you were calling us Nazis too early and so yeah, now people are Nazis. But like, but Yeah. You didn't, you can call it now because they are Nazis.
1:00:13 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You could have just waited. And
1:00:13 Matt: Right.
1:00:25 Thomas: But like, but it was early when you said that, yeah.
1:00:27 Matt: All those warnings, come on, what are you doing?
1:00:29 Thomas: This
1:00:30 Lydia: How does one deal with a Nazi? That is, with an enemy one is convinced intends your destruction. You don't compromise with him or leave him alone. You crush him. So what do we have to lose by fighting back? Only our Washington generals' jerseys and paychecks. But those are going away anyway. Among the many things the right, in quotes, still doesn't understand is that the left has concluded that this particular show need no longer go on.
1:00:40 Matt: Yes, we should have done that.
1:00:54 Thomas: Be the dumbest thing he said in this whole thing. The right-wing paychecks are not going away, you fucking idiot.
1:00:58 Matt: No.
1:00:59 Lydia: Yeah.
1:00:59 Thomas: Those were not, you have all the money, you have oil billionaires, the fucking Coke brothers, the everybody and now Elon.
1:01:04 Lydia: Rupert Murdoch, who you write speeches for. Yeah.
1:01:07 Thomas: Yeah, but back then too, like, there was, they've always had the billionaire asshole money.
1:01:07 Lydia: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yep.
1:01:10 Matt: Hillary Clinton was not going to take your money, I promise.
1:01:13 Lydia: Yeah, unfortunately. Fortunately. They don't think they need a foil anymore and would rather dispense with the whole bother of staging these phony contests in which each side ostensibly has a shot. That is crazy talk.
1:01:22 Thomas: Just all they wanted, the, they that is even in the, like, to the extent they existed, because Trump won, let us remember, like, he did win. So how many people is he even talking about in this article that are, like, I mean, it's it's a few, you know, like the actual, like, principled never Trumpers, you know, but it's like 10. It wasn't that many. And all they were saying was, maybe let's just sit this one out for four years. Like, let's get a different asshole in four years and go from there. And like, there's, they controlled the Senate at that time, right? I mean, they controlled the Senate. That's why we couldn't get Merrick Garland through, I think, if I remember right. Yeah. And I forget where the house was, but like nothing was going to happen. If you had any branch of government, which you definitely would have, nothing happens. Like, what are you fucking worried about? That's all. This is so hyperbolic.
1:01:26 Lydia: Wow. Yep. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
1:01:50 Matt: Right.
1:02:15 Matt: We can skip the pretentious Roman stuff down to you because the deck is stacked, because that's fun.
1:02:19 Thomas: I think we do need what the hell he's talking about there. It was just, it was that, um, you know how to win a victory, but not how to use one. And aside from 2004, is lackluster 50.7%, we can't win the big ones at all. So he's pointing out that the Republicans, that's the one time they won the popular vote in until Trump too was the was but
1:02:20 Lydia: Oh, okay. Right.
1:02:40 Matt: But they still won things.
1:02:42 Thomas: They still won and they still had an advantage, you know, in uh in the House, in the Senate, just inherently um, so okay, so that's what he's saying when he says because this the deck is stacked over really you who get to have a senator, two senators per every, you know, 10,000 people in fucking Mississippi or whatever, you know, like, well, now we get one of of those, but like, you know, Alaska, I've made the joke, but I keep seeing these results where they're like, well, you know, Peltola has a commanding 47 vote lead and that's 20% of the voting public in Alaska.
1:02:47 Matt: Yeah. Okay. Sure. Right.
1:02:53 Lydia: Yeah. Cow. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:03:18 Thomas: And you're like, there's nobody there. Why do they get two senators? They should not, these states should not get two fucking senators.
1:03:19 Lydia: Yeah. I know.
1:03:22 Thomas: God, unbelievable. Yeah. But the deck stacked against them, guys. Stacked against them.
1:03:28 Lydia: Let's see. Okay. So we have the universities and the media above above all, yada, yada, yada. What else are the wars on, quote, cisgenderism, formerly known as, quote, nature, and on the supposed, quote, white privilege of broke hillbillies really about?
1:03:32 Thomas: Sure
1:03:41 Matt: That's what we're talking about. Burk Hill Bill is, yes.
1:03:43 Lydia: If it hadn't been abundantly clear for the last 50 years, the campaign of 2015-2016 must surely have made it evident to even the meanest capacities that the intelligentsia, including all the organs through which it broadcasts its propaganda, is overwhelmingly partisan and biased. Against this onslaught, quote, conservative media is a nullity, barely a whisper.
1:04:02 Thomas: Isn't, man. Sure fucking isn't.
1:04:05 Matt: Doing fine.
1:04:05 Lydia: Yeah.
1:04:06 Thomas: Fox news, the top cable news channel for this entire fucking time. I just, I love this broke hillbillies. Yeah, man. All right. I'll give you a quick pop quiz. The year is 1850. Would you rather be a broke white person or broke black person at that time? Just random, like you just random assignment, Which you think is so, so is there such a thing as white privilege, even when you're broke?
1:04:08 Lydia: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right.
1:04:13 Matt: Yeah.
1:04:30 Thomas: Yes, it's like that has existed this whole time and uh, it's maybe not as stark as in 1850, but it's still there. You can't just point to, so well, that white person doesn't have a great life. Yeah, man, it's still white privilege. They still can probably, like, drive without getting pulled over for being white. Anyway.
1:04:34 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:04:43 Matt: It's primarily not what we're talking about. We talk about white privilege, but he knows that. Of course he knows that.
1:04:50 Lydia: Yeah.
1:04:51 Thomas: No, it's just bad faith.
1:04:52 Matt: Yeah.
1:04:53 Lydia: It cannot be heard above the blaring of what has been aptly called, quote, the megaphone. That's Fox News, apparently. Can't be heard over the megaphone.
1:05:00 Matt: Sure.
1:04:59 Thomas: Sure. Don't, yeah, I actually don't know what that would be. I
1:05:04 Matt: Yeah.
1:05:04 Lydia: Second.
1:05:04 Matt: He knows.
1:05:04 Lydia: Are Washington General's self-handicap and self-censor to an absurd degree. Lennon is supposed to have said that, quote, "The best way to control the opposition is to lead it ourselves." But with an opposition like ours, why bother? Our quote leaders and quote dissenters bend over backward to play by the self-sabotaging rules the left sets for them. Fearful, beaten dogs have more, more thymus.
1:05:24 Thomas: Will give him credit on this one because I actually think, think this turned out to be true, you, and that was horrifying to learn that, you know, a bunch of people just weren't saying slurs because they were self-censoring, not because they didn't want to say them the whole fucking time. I think he was right about that. I think conservatives, we, the thing that has always been true is the culture is liberal and the halls of power have been conservative and so they react to the culture and think that that's the halls of power. It's just not. It hasn't ever been. It's never going to be probably. And we'll see. We're trying.
1:05:46 Lydia: Yeah.
1:05:24 Matt: Okay. Yeah. Well, I mean, they're mad because they don't have SNL, but what would SNL be if they ran it? I mean, come on. Who wants that?
1:05:58 Thomas: Yeah, exactly. SNL doesn't pass laws. SNL can make fun of them every single week and they still win, you know, up until five minutes ago lately. So it's like, that's what they do. So they're constantly on their back foot with that. That and the idea that, like, it, I think it was true that a lot of, because the culture was more liberal, a lot of conservatives were self-censoring all the time, and we missed, I mistook that, I'll speak for myself, I mistook that as them being maybe less racist than I thought they were back in like 2015-16, you know, and it's like, oh no, they were way more racist, they just were censoring.
1:06:05 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:06:31 Matt: The second point, though, about how they're bending over backwards to play by the rules, I think we've already agreed is not Quite
1:06:31 Lydia: Yeah.
1:06:36 Thomas: Yeah. Oh. But. Oh yeah, let's see, let me check on that, uh, Supreme Court seat, does it fell, no, it's still being held open right now as you're writing this.
1:06:43 Lydia: Maybe
1:06:36 Matt: True. Yeah. So, now, We're going to get to the real heart of it, this is what he really wants to talk about.
1:06:46 Thomas: Oh,
1:06:47 Lydia: We should take our last break then.
1:06:49 Thomas: A good idea. Let's take our final break before we do that. And I've got to thank our top patrons at the, this is the top third, this is the best of the best with honors, patreon.com/law. Thank you too. Check out galenacomic.com for a cool webcomic, Bob Loblaw's Law Podcast, Philly Basement Bar bar, shops at Stan's Used Coffins. E.T., Elect Thomas Smith President, American Honkytonk Bar Association. Baltakatei, Philip Kizer, my PhD is in studying palindromes. I'm Dr. Awkward. Oh, nice. Dr. Awkward is, wow, I didn't know that.
1:07:25 Lydia: Oh, it works.
1:07:25 Thomas: Yeah, Dr.
1:07:23 Matt: Like that, that's A good one.
1:07:25 Lydia: Oh, wow.
1:07:26 Thomas: Awkward is a palindrome. Nice. Coryn_Lann, A string of unpronounceable characters. Malaika Chandler, David in Brooklyn, RhondaTheDork.com, Chris Waltrip, Big Easy Blasphemy, hors d'oeuvres in the court before we report, Sam Donow, Classic libtard, FRED R GROOTHUIS, who is perhaps one month away from being top patron, but I, so it's even more important to give our top shout out to Mitchell, our top patron, but Fred is on schedule to overtake Mitchell.
1:07:27 Lydia: Oh, Fred's inching up. Wow.
1:07:54 Thomas: So that's big news here. Uh, but we love them both, of course, and all our top patrons. So please support the show. All right, we'll take a break we can get to the final bit of crybabying, but this time finally saying the racism that was Under it all along. Right, here we go. Third and most important, important,
1:07:55 Lydia: Wow.
1:08:06 Matt: Okay.
1:08:11 Lydia: And most important, the ceaseless importation of third-world foreigners with no tradition of, taste for, or experience in liberty means that the electorate grows more left, more democratic, less lowercase Republican, and less traditionally American with every cycle.
1:08:15 Thomas: God, The amount of racism in that sentence. Yeah.
1:08:29 Lydia: Incredible.
1:08:29 Matt: The one sentence and I could spend the other hour just on the sentence. But yeah, don't come here for the liberty, for our freedoms, apparently.
1:08:32 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah.
1:08:33 Thomas: Tradition of taste for liberty, guys, You know, those people are probably fleeing, as, you know, who are Matt's, you know, clients who are fleeing, like, awful torturous fascist regime, they just don't have a taste for liberty, you know, they just don't have a, they don't have the, they haven't acquired the taste for it yet, you know, know.
1:08:40 Lydia: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
1:08:55 Thomas: God.
1:08:49 Matt: If do, they're eating liberty junk food. Or
1:08:55 Thomas: Yeah. That's incredible and the idea too that those people would just be automatically left. Like, why would that even be? I mean, if we, if we gave all immigrants or like all, yeah, like all current immigrants citizenship today, I don't, like, would, would you expect them to all vote Democrat? I don't even think I would.
1:09:04 Lydia: Mm-hmm.
1:09:17 Thomas: I mean, it might, yeah, maybe.
1:09:14 Matt: The... No. I mean, maybe now after seeing ICE,
1:09:19 Lydia: Yeah.
1:09:19 Thomas: Maybe. After you terrorize them very publicly.
1:09:19 Lydia: Yeah. After you've dug your grave. Yeah.
1:09:23 Thomas: Yeah.
1:09:19 Matt: But traditionally, no.
1:09:23 Thomas: But, but in 2015, 16, like, I don't mean, I mean, maybe, but it's not like the sure thing that they're talking about.
1:09:26 Matt: Yeah. No.
1:09:29 Lydia: If immigration was like a non-issue in both parties and all of all of the people who've come over here are citizens and could automatically vote, I could see like people aligning more based off of religion and traditional values and stuff, which is usually the GOP. So, yeah. Why wouldn't they vote that way?
1:09:32 Thomas: Yeah. They're more conservative. Yeah. Yeah.
1:09:44 Matt: Right. Traditionally. And also, he's basically positing that these people just become citizens, which, as we all know, is also insane, that they just get to vote as soon as they get here. And less traditionally American. Let's not forget that little phrase there, less traditionally American.
1:09:51 Lydia: Right. Right.
1:09:58 Thomas: Stupid.
1:09:58 Matt: We know what we're saying there, traditional Americans.
1:09:58 Thomas: Traditionally American. Yeah.
1:10:00 Lydia: Right. As does, of course, the U.S. population, which only serves to reinforce the two other causes outlined above. This is the core reason why the left, the Democrats, and the bipartisan junta, junta? Categories, junta?
1:10:12 Thomas: I thought it was Junta. I can't remember. Yeah.
1:10:14 Lydia: I don't know, you guys. Categories distinct but very much overlapping. Think they are on the cusp of a permanent victory that will forever obviate the need to pretend to respect democratic and constitutional niceties because they are. Are.
1:10:23 Thomas: Yeah. Junta. To
1:10:26 Matt: Just, again, every accusation, a confession. Fashion.
1:10:29 Lydia: It's also why they treat open borders as the, quote, absolute value, the one, quote, principle that, yeah,
1:10:34 Thomas: Sure. Don't, this is 2016. Fuck off.
1:10:37 Matt: Who are you quoting? What are the quotes about? Like, what's going on?
1:10:40 Lydia: Yeah,
1:10:39 Thomas: Yeah, Absolute value? Oh, they're just quoting, you know, that time when Obama said, "Open borders are my absolute value." That's what, God, what?
1:10:46 Matt: Yeah, clearly.
1:10:46 Lydia: The one principle that when their principles, in quotes, collide, they prioritize above all the others. If that fact is insufficiently clear, consider this. Trump is the most liberal Republican nominee since Thomas Dewey. He departs from conservative conservative orthodoxy in so many ways that National Review still hasn't stopped counting.
1:11:07 Thomas: Hey, man, so maybe this is why the conservatives don't like it, you know what I mean? Like, he's waiting until now to say, oh, also he's super liberal. Okay, well then maybe the other, other Never Trumper conservatives can be like, hey, he's too liberal, you know, this
1:11:20 Lydia: Yeah, I'm not voting for a rhino, you know, kind of thing.
1:11:21 Thomas: Yeah, this fucking argument is all over the place. It's
1:11:22 Lydia: Yeah. But let's stick to just the core issues animating his campaign. On trade, globalization, and war, Trump is to the left, conventionally understood, not only of his own party, but of his Democratic opponent. And yet the left and the junta are at one with the housebroken conservatives and and their determination, desperation, not merely to defeat Trump, but to destroy him. What gives?
1:11:39 Thomas: Hunter?
1:11:49 Thomas: I see. It also can pronounced be junta. Okay. You can do either? Then go nuts. Yeah, yeah.
1:11:51 Lydia: Okay, thank you. All right. Good to know. I hope that word does not show up ever again in the rest of this article. Oh, right. There's that other issue in italics. The sacredness of mass immigration is the mystic cord that unites America's ruling and intellectual classes.
1:12:09 Thomas: No.
1:12:10 Lydia: Their reasons vary somewhat. Somewhat, the left and the Democrats seek ringers to form a permanent electoral majority.
1:12:15 Thomas: God. No.
1:12:17 Lydia: They, or many of them, also believe the academic intellectual lie that America's inherently racist and evil nature can be expiated only through ever greater, quote, diversity. I forgot the
1:12:28 Thomas: I mean that's kind of of a weird way of putting that, I would think. What they're probably saying is, hey, it's super racist to be against diversity, and like, that's what, that's how I would have put it, you know, not like, hey, I'm gonna cure your racism by making diversity. It's not really that, it's like, no, why are you on the other side of this argument, is it because you're racist, a weird way to put things.
1:12:31 Matt: Yeah.
1:12:51 Lydia: Junta.
1:12:52 Thomas: There's that word 10 more times. Yeah.
1:12:52 Lydia: Of course, I know. I was like, I was like, oh crap, what did Thomas say? How can I I pronounce it again? Of course, craves cheaper and more docile labor. It also seeks to legitimize and deflect unwanted attention from its wealth and power by pretending that its open border stance is a form of, oh my God, noblesse oblige, whatever.
1:12:56 Thomas: Well, That's true. Who cares.
1:13:15 Lydia: Okay. The Republicans, see, okay, I'm not, listen, listen, you're saying, yeah, you're saying like the Democrats, the left is like, you know, so, you know, this upper elite intellectual and here I am being like, can you use smaller words, please?
1:13:14 Matt: Speak English. He's
1:13:19 Thomas: Use our language. I'm an American, speak English. Yeah, no. God, fucking jacking off onto
1:13:33 Lydia: I'm so tired of this.
1:13:33 Thomas: The typewriter over here, just trying to like see as smart as possible. Oh, I'm so fucking smart, look at all these references and weird languages.
1:13:36 Lydia: God, trying so hard. The Republicans and the quote, conservatives, both, of course, desperately want absolution from the charge of quote, racism. For the latter, this at least makes some sense. No Washington general can take the court, much less cash his check, with that epithet dancing over his head like some satanic spirit.
1:13:42 Thomas: Yeah.
1:13:58 Thomas: What is this analogy? Like, what are you talking about?
1:13:58 Matt: So bad at writing.
1:14:03 Thomas: Do you know how basketball works?
1:14:02 Lydia: But for the former, this priestly
1:14:05 Thomas: No, I don't know. It's like, what is this? Okay.
1:14:06 Matt: Why is spirit capitalized?
1:14:08 Thomas: I don't, I don't satanic spirit and, and racism.
1:14:08 Matt: What's going on? Is that a trademark?
1:14:11 Thomas: Like what? Uh, so weird.
1:14:09 Lydia: Grace comes at the direct expense of their worldly interests. Do they honestly believe that the right enterprise zone or charter school policy will arouse 50.01% of our newer voters to finally reveal their, quote, natural conservatism at the ballot box. It hasn't happened anywhere yet and shows no signs that it ever will. But that doesn't stop the Republican refrain. More, more, more. No matter how many elections they lose, how many districts tip forever blue, how rarely, if ever, their immigrant vote cracks 40 percent, the answer is always the same. Just like Angela Merkel after yet another rape, shooting, bombing, or machete attack. More, more, more.
1:14:51 Thomas: Okay. Oh boy.
1:14:54 Lydia: This is insane.
1:14:55 Thomas: Oh, that's what I was thinking.
1:14:56 Lydia: This is the mark of a party, a society, a country, a people, a civilization that wants to die. Trump alone among candidates for high office in this or in the last seven at least cycles has stood up to say, I want to live. I want my party to live. I want my country to live. I want my people to live.
1:15:12 Thomas: Boy, does he not give a shit about that?
1:15:15 Lydia: I want to end the insanity. Yes, Trump is worse worse than imperfect. So what? We can lament until we choke the lack of a great statesman to address the fundamental issues of our time, or more importantly, to connect them.
1:15:27 Thomas: Yes. The incinerator is not a perfect method of cancer reduction in a human, but, but well, we can wait around for like a cure for cancer or we can just put the person in the incinerator.
1:15:36 Matt: It's worse than imperfect. Tom
1:15:35 Lydia: What? While they're alive. Since Pat Buchanan's three failures, occasionally a candidate arose who saw one piece. Dick Gephardt on trade, Ron Paul on war, Tom Tancredo on immigration. Immigration.
1:15:39 Thomas: Yeah.
1:15:50 Thomas: Don't even remember who that is. Tom Tancredo.
1:15:52 Matt: Pancrato. Oh, yeah.
1:15:53 Thomas: Wow.
1:15:54 Lydia: Tancredo. Okay.
1:15:56 Thomas: Like what era is that before my time, senior or I don't remember that guy.
1:16:03 Lydia: Yet among recent political figures, great statesmen, dangerous demagogues, and mewling gnats alike, only Trump, the alleged buffoon, not merely saw all three and their essential connectivity, but was able to win on them. The alleged buffoon is thus more prudent, more practically wise, than all of our wise and good who so bitterly oppose him. This should embarrass them, that their failures instead embolden them is only further proof of their foolishness and hubris.
1:16:03 Thomas: Okay.
1:16:30 Matt: He's not prudent.
1:16:31 Thomas: Look, man.
1:16:31 Matt: He's doing exactly what you say he should do. He's being racist. That's what you're saying he should do.
1:16:34 Thomas: Well, and it's not just yes. And it's also like, okay. He's found the right combination of lies to tell to appeal to enough people to win, by the way, the primaries that were winner take all that accelerated him to the victory. He's found the right lies to tell. That doesn't mean he's going to like, even again, even as a conservative at this time, if you were like wondering what to do, like, cause I, you know, I, I somewhat sympathize with if you were a Republican at that time and you were like, I can't support this guy, but also I'm a Republican. So I've I've watched decades of Fox News and I think Hillary's a lizard.
1:17:10 Lydia: Right.
1:17:10 Thomas: Like, what are you going to do? You know, like, they might just think, well, yeah, but he's just lying. So it's not worth voting for him because he's a liar. He's a documented liar, like a liar, a rapist, like, yeah.
1:17:22 Lydia: A con man. Yeah.
1:17:23 Thomas: So they might think, OK, yes, you're right. He's found the right lies to tell to appeal to enough people to win this primary process. But does that mean he's going to make anything good happen? Why would you think that? You're an idiot if you think you could trust like this liar to do anything, and you know, point in fact, whatever, like the Iran War, like he eventually undid everything that he promised to do, even by his own terms, even by Republican terms.
1:17:48 Lydia: Which they self-lawed as, quote, consistency, adherence to, quote, conservative principle defined by the 1980 campaign and the household gods of reigning conservative think tanks. A higher consistency in the service of the national interest apparently eludes them. When America possessed a vast, empty continent and explosively growing industry, high immigration was arguably good policy. Arguably, Ben Franklin would disagree.
1:18:12 Matt: Ben Franklin, of course, who opposed the Germans, thought he we were going to end up speaking German.
1:18:15 Lydia: It hasn't made sense since World War I. Free trade was unquestionably a great boon to the American worker in the decades after World War II. We long ago passed the point of diminishing returns. The Gulf War of 1991 was a strategic victory for American interests. No conflict since then has been. Conservatives either can't see this, or worse, those who can nonetheless treat the only political leader to mount a serious challenge to the status quo, more immigration, more trade, more war, as a unique evil.
1:18:41 Thomas: So it is a book. This is the Claremont Review of Books, because this is a fucking novel. It's never gonna end, man.
1:18:47 Lydia: No.
1:18:47 Thomas: When is it? This is too much. It's never ever gonna
1:18:48 Matt: It's almost over. We can skip a bit, but it's just getting to the good part. Well, no, I mean, there's no good part, but, you know,
1:18:50 Thomas: Oh, really? Okay, I'm gonna keep going. Yeah,
1:18:53 Lydia: Alright. Trump's vulgarity is in fact a godsend to the conservatives. It allows them to hang their public opposition on his obvious shortcomings and to ignore or downplay his far greater strengths, which should be even more obvious but in corrupt times can be deliberately obscured by constant references to his faults. That the left would make the campaign all about the latter is to be expected. Why would the right? Some, a few, are no doubt sincere in their belief that the man is simply unfit for high office. David Frum, who has always been an immigration skeptic and is a convert to the less war position, is sincere when he says that, even though he agrees with much of Trump's agenda, he cannot stomach Trump. But for most of the other, hashtag never Trumpers, is it just a coincidence that they also happen to favor invade the world, invite the world? I don't know what that is.
1:19:03 Thomas: Yeah, Like allowing immigration and also still being for pro-war and pro-immigration, basically.
1:19:43 Matt: Doing lots of war.
1:19:42 Lydia: Oh, I see. Gotcha, gotcha. Another question Jag raised without provoking any serious attempt at refutation was whether, in corrupt times, it took a, let's say, quote, quote, loudmouth, to rise above the din of the megaphone. We, or I, speculated, quote, yes. Suppose there had arisen some statesman of high character, dignified, articulate, experienced, knowledgeable, the exact opposite of everything the conservatives claim to hate about Trump. Could this hypothetical paragon have won on Trump's same issues? Would the conservatives have supported him? I would have, even had he been a Democrat.
1:20:15 Matt: If he were racist enough, I would have supported him. Yes, that's what you're saying.
1:20:18 Lydia: Weird. What? Wow. Back on planet Earth, that flight of fancy at least addresses what to do now. The answer to the subsidiary question, will it work, is much less clear. By quote it, I mean Trumpism, broadly defined as secure borders, economic nationalism, and America first foreign policy. We Americans have chosen, in our foolishness, to disunite the country through stupid immigration, economic, and foreign policies. The level
1:20:19 Matt: Yeah.
1:20:41 Thomas: Man, it's because of all the fear-mongering about it. It's not, there's no, there isn't mass immigration happening. You just made it up.
1:20:48 Lydia: Of unity America enjoyed before the bipartisan junta took over can never be restored. God, I'm so mad.
1:20:52 Thomas: Now He's just doing it to spite you.
1:20:56 Lydia: Just to piss me off.
1:20:57 Thomas: Yeah, He's like, I just said it's edited.
1:20:57 Lydia: Yeah. There's like, I look at the edits. Yeah, just check the code. But we can probably do better than we are doing now. First, stop digging. No more importing poverty, crime, and alien cultures. We have made institutions by leftist design not merely abysmal at assimilation but abhorrent of the concept. We should try to fix that, but given the left's iron grip on every school and cultural center, that's like trying to bring democracy to Russia. A worthy goal, perhaps, but temper your your hopes and don't invest time and resources unrealistically. By contrast, simply building a wall and enforcing immigration law will help enormously by cutting off the flood of newcomers that perpetuates ethnic separatism and by incentivizing the English language and American norms in the workplace.
1:20:59 Thomas: Yeah, Alien cultures, do You become an influential writer by just battering everybody to death with words until everyone's like, I can't take any more words, you win. Can't take this anymore, man, this is too, too much.
1:21:47 Lydia: Yeah.
1:21:51 Matt: It's almost over, Thomas.
1:21:52 Thomas: Yeah, No.
1:21:52 Lydia: You just said that.
1:21:55 Matt: Well, really, we're closer to almost over.
1:21:56 Lydia: How many more juntas do I have to say?
1:21:57 Thomas: Yeah. We're only like four or five hooters left.
1:21:59 Matt: I think zero. I just want to point out it's the flood of newcomers that are perpetuating ethnic separatism. That's what's going on here. Okay.
1:22:08 Thomas: Yeah. Exactly.
1:22:06 Lydia: Right. These policies will have the added benefit of aligning the economic interests of, and we may hope, fostering solidarity among the working lower middle and middle classes of all races and ethnicities. The same can be said for Trumpian trade policies and anti-globalization instincts. Who cares if productivity numbers tick down or if our already somnambulant GDP sinks a bit further into its pillow? Nearly all the gains of the last 20 years have accrued to the junta anyway. Anyway, gosh, OK, like how many more times do you guys like could throw out a number? I think I might be done now.
1:22:23 Thomas: We'll
1:22:39 Lydia: That might be the last one.
1:22:39 Matt: I think that's it.
1:22:40 Thomas: See, I'm betting on one. I'm just gonna bet on one more. Just for fun.
1:22:43 Matt: Singlehood too.
1:22:43 Lydia: One more. OK. It would at this point be better for the nation to divide up more equitably a slight slightly smaller pie than to add one extra slice.
1:22:50 Thomas: Okay, I agree with that. Oh.
1:22:52 Lydia: Only to ensure that it and eight of the other nine go first to the government and its rentiers and the rest to the same four industries and 200 families.
1:22:56 Thomas: Shut up That's what's happening, the pie is being divided such that the government gets all of it. What No, dude, it's the billionaire who literally is paying your fucking paycheck yeah well now, yeah, but back then it's yeah I mean, back then he was wealthy, but it wasn't, yeah, exactly.
1:23:02 Lydia: Yeah. Yep. I was going to say Elon Musk. Ask. It's Elon Musk. He's getting it. Yeah. Back then, not. Yeah.
1:23:05 Matt: Carmen is working very hard to make sure, know, onto something with the four industries and 200 families. Is That certainly the idea.
1:23:16 Lydia: Mm-hmm. Will this work? Ask a pessimist. Get a pessimistic answer. So don't ask. Ask instead. Is it worth trying? Is it better than the alternative? If you can't say forthrightly, quote, yes, you are either part of the junta. OK.
1:23:29 Thomas: I didn't look ahead, I promise. Now I wonder if it'll be more. Did Did Matt take the over on that?
1:23:30 Lydia: OK. All right. A fool.
1:23:35 Thomas: We'll see I already win then
1:23:36 Lydia: You're at zero. OK. Wow. Are
1:23:34 Matt: No, yeah, I said zero. Yeah, you said one.
1:23:38 Lydia: You one? Bummer. A fool or a conservative intellectual. And if it If it doesn't work, what then? We've established that most, quote, conservative anti-Trumpites are in the Orwellian sense, objectively pro-Hillary. What about the rest of you? If you recognize the threat she poses but somehow can't stomach him, have you thought about the longer term? The possibilities would seem to be Caesarism, secession slash crackup, collapse, or managerial Davoisi liberalism, as far as the eye can see, which, yeah, an incinerator with the cancer patient, I guess, is our other option, which, since nothing human lasts forever, at some point will give way to one of the other three. Oh, and I suppose for those who like to pour a tall one and dream big, a second American revolution that restores constitutionalism, limited government, and a 28% top marginal rate. But for those of you who are sober, can you sketch a more plausible long-term future than the prior four following a Trump defeat? I can't either. The election of 2016 is a test, in my view the final test, of whether there is any virtue left in what...
1:23:38 Thomas: Yeah
1:23:38 Matt: Yeah.
1:23:59 Thomas: I was like a c-section, yeah.
1:24:10 Thomas: What if I can't understand any of those words, then what are my options? Yeah Say virtue, why for the listeners, it's spelled weird, yeah.
1:24:51 Matt: Yes. It's an English word.
1:24:51 Lydia: Yeah. Virtue. Virtue.
1:24:54 Matt: It's like the French, yeah.
1:24:56 Lydia: Left in what used to be the
1:24:56 Matt: Okay. It means the same thing, I promise.
1:24:58 Thomas: Yeah, you could just write in a different language if you want, just fucking write it in French. Or whatever, dick. What?
1:25:05 Matt: That was funny.
1:25:07 Thomas: An idiot.
1:25:02 Lydia: Core
1:25:08 Matt: That was three years ago. It's actually Latin, means strength, but whatever. I mean, that's what virtue is. Yeah, whatever. Fine. Just say virtue. Yeah, that too.
1:25:17 Thomas: Just say strength, that we have an
1:25:19 Matt: That's also a word.
1:25:19 Thomas: English word for this God, a
1:25:20 Matt: That's right.
1:25:19 Lydia: Of the American nation, if they cannot rouse themselves simply to vote for the first candidate in a generation who pledges to advance their interests, and to to vote against the one who openly boasts that she will do the opposite. A million more Syrians, anyone? Then, they are doomed.
1:25:35 Thomas: Million more
1:25:37 Matt: That's what she promised.
1:25:37 Thomas: Yeah we We have a million Syrians,
1:25:39 Matt: Yes. I remember that campaign promise very clearly.
1:25:39 Lydia: Yeah.
1:25:39 Thomas: Right? Well, yeah. Did we, let's say a million more. Did we, did we get a million Syrians?
1:25:43 Lydia: A million more.
1:25:48 Thomas: First off, if we did good, cause they needed it. But I doubt, I, doubt we just got a million.
1:25:47 Matt: I don't know. Yeah.
1:25:56 Thomas: I just took in, in 2016 or whatever, a million Syrians. Did we? I don't think so.
1:25:50 Lydia: Yeah. Yeah. A million Syrians that just came in. Yeah. I'm
1:26:01 Thomas: Anyway, we're almost done.
1:26:01 Lydia: Not sure. They may not deserve the fate that will befall them, but they will suffer it regardless.
1:26:08 Thomas: Who? Oh, whatever. Oh, the people who won't vote for Trump. Yeah. All right. Well, fuck that guy, Matt. And I'm mad at you for making us do that. Matt.
1:26:11 Lydia: Yeah. That was so bad.
1:26:17 Thomas: Matt's in the doghouse.
1:26:15 Matt: You're welcome. I promise this is a very important piece of literature. This is the height of conservative intellectualism, of MAGA intellectualism. It is the smartest piece we're ever going to read on Vapid Response.
1:26:18 Lydia: Yeah,
1:26:20 Thomas: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Well, and you can tell it's so smart because it uses different languages at times, and only smart people can do that.
1:26:30 Matt: So so many different words. Yeah, words in sequence.
1:26:33 Thomas: Mm-hmm.
1:26:34 Lydia: Man.
1:26:34 Matt: So there you go, Michael Anton.
1:26:35 Lydia: Does he have does he have beef with Sebastian Gorka? I just saw a thing on the Wikipedia that says he was a leading candidate to be Donald Trump's deputy national security adviser, but removed himself from consideration after learning the National Security Council would include a position for Seb Gorka.
1:26:41 Thomas: Hmm.
1:26:52 Matt: Yes. They've had something about a speechwriting in credit or something. It's something super petty.
1:26:55 Lydia: Oh, my God. Something so petty.
1:26:56 Thomas: Oh, is it? Because I was going to give him, I don't know why, I was going to give him the benefit of the doubt and be like, oh, I don't want to be a part of anything where that idiot could be on it. No, okay. It's just some petty bullshit.
1:26:57 Matt: Yes. No, no. It's literally about like a petty credit thing.
1:27:06 Thomas: Okay.
1:27:04 Lydia: Wow. Oh, my God. Amazing.
1:27:07 Matt: Yep.
1:27:07 Thomas: Sounds right. Yep.
1:27:08 Matt: He's a petty man.
1:27:09 Thomas: Well, this person sucks, and that was dumb and the analogy never made sense in any way, uh, but this was a fun trip down memory lane celebrating the 10th anniversary of the 15th anniversary of 9-11, uh, thanks so much listeners, thanks Matt and thanks Lydia for having to read all those huntas, it was, uh, I wish I wish very few huntas in your future.
1:27:13 Matt: Nope.
1:27:13 Lydia: Nope.
1:27:28 Matt: We are quite the junta.
1:27:29 Lydia: Who to count. Thank you so much.
1:27:32 Thomas: Uh, thanks everyone for listening, and we'll see you on Rapid Response Friday.
1:27:40 Clip: This has been Opening Arguments, produced by Thomas and Lydia Smith, with editing help from Peter Baird. The intro is by Thomas Smith. This outro is by Matt Cameron. Support the show at patreon.com/law. Contact us through Patreon or openarguments@gmail.com. Make sure to follow our blue sky, at OpenArgs. But most of all, please share the show. Thanks for listening.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeart
Support on Patreon