The Serious Pod Network

Thomas and Lydia
Opening Arguments

Kushner (Allegedly) Traded Foreign Policy for Real Estate Deals, with Matthew Cole

Investigative reporter Matthew Cole joins us to discuss his new book, Princes and Thieves, which alleges Jared Kushner held secret access to bank accounts funded by the UAE and Saudi Arabia while serving in the White House. We get into how Dutch intelligence stumbled onto the scheme, the Qatar blockade and the 666 Fifth Avenue bailout, and Kushner's current overseas business dealings. It's also this month's OA Book Club pick!

Cases and sources discussed:

Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!

To support the show (and lose the ads!), please pledge at patreon.com/law! $2+ patrons also get a new Law'd Awful Movies every month.

Follow Opening Arguments:

Transcript

This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors — the audio is the record.

0:00:37 Clip: Hello, and welcome to Opening Arguments. This is episode 1314. I'm Thomas, and in a moment, I'll be joined by not one, but two Matthews. It's, of course, Matt Cameron, real-life immigration attorney, and also investigative reporter, Matthew Cole. Hey, stuff in the news lately about Jared Kushner and the just unbelievable, amounts of corruption that he's accused of taking part in. Well, Matthew Cole is the investigative reporter whose new book, Princes and Thieves, alleges that Kushner had access golf-funded to accounts while in the White House. The book is so good that we're making it this month's OA Book Club read, but this interview is something else. Folks, you need to listen to this, especially in the later parts of the interview.

0:01:26 Clip: Just way Matthew details out his reporting. It is so staggering, especially pairs nicely, shall we say, with how good the election news has been lately, because these allegations are something that a very, very different Congress, in about two months, a little less than two months, are going to want to look at. They'll probably want to look into this. I cannot wait for you all to hear this. So I won't. Let's take our first break. Get that out of the way. Hey, support the the show and episodes like this, patreon.com/law. Skip the ads, get the Law'd Awful Movies, patreon.com/law. It's after this break. We're going to get to Matthew Cole discussing Princes and Thieves and all of the insane allegations, Jared Kushner. Thank you for watching.

0:02:12 Matt: Matthew Cole, welcome to Opening Arguments. We're Um, here to talk about a book, Princes and Thieves, that both Jared Kushner and myself have called incredible, but for very different reasons.

0:02:21 Matthew: Thank you for having me.

0:02:22 Matt: And thank you for writing this. This

0:02:23 Thomas: Good reviews across the political spectrum, I guess, yeah.

0:02:24 Matt: That's right, that's right. We, um, before we even talk about, I mean, these are shocking allegations, like even, we're numb to this stuff, even at the point at which you know that this is a corrupt family, that we have a royal family. This is really something. There should be multiple life sentences, if not prison, execution for treason in what you're alleging here. So before we even get into the story, I just want to give you a chance, because I know that this is the most controversial part of the book, to talk about your sources and about why, as somebody who, as the audience knows, I love footnotes, I love endnotes, there are no documentary sources of any of the bank transfers in particular, which is the most explosive allegation that we'll talk about.

0:02:58 Matthew: Let me First start by, by saying, of course, that as you alluded to with, uh, Kushner's reaction and response, uh, that he denies all the allegations in the book and has said unequivocally and emphatically that he never had access to any kind of foreign bank accounts, had no, he has no idea what these bank accounts are, and that everything that he did while he was serving in the White House was at the, the direction and with the permission of the president of the United States. Um, so he's not here. Uh, so we'll give him his, uh, opportunities to, uh, and statement on his behalf, which is that he denies everything.

0:03:33 Matt: And we will actually link, just so everybody knows, to the response, just so that you can read it for yourselves. But I will note, just so you don't have to say it, he has declined to sue you to prove this in court yet. So as far as I know, as of today, is that right?

0:03:44 Matthew: Uh, yes, as of today. Your question The question was, why are there no documents or why is there no evidence of bank accounts?

0:03:45 Matt: Okay. Just to be clear, just what I'm asking, because it is, I just want to get out of the way, because I really enjoyed read this book. I think you're onto something here, obviously, but it is based on primary sources, on people that you spoke with. That is my understanding of what the meat of the allegations comes from, is that right?

0:04:05 Matthew: What I say in the book is that, first of all, the book is a culmination of more than 50 sources. Let's start there. Secondly, I have a combination of first-hand and second-hand sources throughout the book, and the reporting is a combination of that, but also includes documents, just generally and generically. Exactly. Difficulties, and I think, you've read the book from start to finish, I presume. So, you know, one of the things that Princes and Thieves lays out is that some of the people that we're talking about in this book, in particular, the rulers in Saudi Arabia and the UAE run pretty vicious, murderous regimes.

0:04:51 Matthew: And so, you know, every investigative journalist, first of all, let's start here. Every investigative journalist in America for the last 50 years has used anonymous sources. It's bread and butter. And since Woodward and Bernstein broke Watergate, that's just a fact of life. And one of the things that happens when you are are covering national security and government secrets, things that are classified and things that are very sensitive, is you have to make, every journalist and every news organization, every editorial staff has to make a determination, a value judgment about what they say, about how they know something, or what they say about their sources, who their sources are, and how they know something.

And in this particular, in the reporting in this book, And, You know, as someone, as I lay out at the beginning of the book, I was the victim of a phone malware hack on my phone by the UAE government when I was in the last time that I was reporting in the UAE in 2017. And three years later, as I was starting to unspool parts of this story while I was a security reporter at The Intercept, I published a story about Eric Prince, whose subject in this book as well, a more minor subject, but nonetheless, and his relationship with the Russian mercenary firm Wagner at the time. And he sued me for libel. And I came to learn most, if not all of the money that funded that lawsuit came from the UAE.

0:06:25 Matthew: In both of those cases, the effort was to try to find out who I was talking to and who my sources are. And so on a personal level, I am familiar, very familiar with the lengths in which at least one of the governments that I'm reporting on will go to to try to figure out who is leaking their secrets. And so as I put together the book and thought about how to deal with attribution, I had to constantly wrestle with my sources, with my editors, with the lawyers at Simon & Schuster about how to best attribution.

And so I'm not going to give you a satisfactory answer because The Full answer requires too much disclosure, disclosure that I don't feel comfortable with. And, consequence of that may be that, some people are skeptical about what's in the book or the sort of most significant that's in there. And I have to live with that. I'm okay with that. I'm quite comfortable with the reporting. I stand behind it 100%. I am very confident that in time, it will all bear out. And so, this question came to me when I was on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart.

You know, the last big story that I did prior to this book was I co-published a, co-authored a story for the New York Times about a SEAL mission to North Korea that President Trump had authorized in the first administration that resulted in the SEALs killing some unarmed North Koreans, and President Trump withheld the mission from Congress, two things I want to say about it.

0:07:09 Matt: No. Of course, sure.

0:08:07 Matthew: Number one, my reward for making that information public and putting it, you know, information that I believe was absolutely in the public interest is that I've been the recipient of a subpoena, a federal grand jury subpoena, to identify my sources. Okay. But more importantly, in a story that we published at the time, we weren't asked, I wasn't asked, well, did any of your sources give you sand from North Korea to prove that they were there? Right. Did anyone, you know, were you, did you see the sub that was used to deliver these guys. I mean, right. So it's, it's, it's, I understand that in our, in this day and age, you know, there's, there's plenty of skepticism and that's fair and fine. And I'm, I'm happy to to, contend with it. But I think that the better way of viewing it is, is that I've been a national security reporter for 25 years. I have consistently throughout my career published government secrets and secrets that people don't want out. My first book, a compilation, was essentially of war crimes and corruption in SEAL Team 6, one of the most secretive units in the US government.

0:08:34 Thomas: I

0:09:21 Matthew: And what all of these things have in common on one level is, believe it or not, in their world, in these worlds that I'm sort of getting into as a journalist, these things are actually not so secret. I'm doing is making them public and in public interest. And there's, you know, I've had several conversations recently, but I've been thinking about this. You the secret financial relationship, not all of which does my book uncover, by the way. You know, the book, I think, opens in a lot more questions than in some ways than it has answers. I mean, there's enough there, obviously, that I felt confident that was it important to publish. But the Middle East, Kushner's relationship, secret financial relationship with MBZ and MBS is an open secret. And the difference, I mean, in some ways, it's a little bit like being in the matrix or something.

0:10:12 Matthew: There's like a cognitive dissonance between the fact that we've, first of all, governments keep secrets. We know that, right? There's constantly things that come 50 years later after they occurred, public had no idea. So the idea that we can't imagine what was going on behind closed doors, and because we can't imagine it or we didn't see it, it therefore couldn't have happened, is to me, I don't live in that reality. And as a professional, as a journalist, I've never lived in that reality. I covered spies and special ops and and covert intelligence, and covert action. And by the way, all things I was never present at four. So I don't mean to go, I just want to give your audience and your listeners a sense of what goes into this To try to answer that question as best I could.

0:11:02 Matt: Yeah. Appreciate that, and it's where you start the book. I think it's the best place to start the conversation, because this is a courageous book. I mean, I think everything you've written over the course of your career has been courageous to some degree, as you said. Getting International secrets. I mean, this is real investigative work. I I mean, I,

0:11:13 Matthew: Thank you.

0:11:17 Thomas: Wanted to ask on a personal level, don't you, don't you get nervous? Don't you get scared of any of this stuff? I mean, it

0:11:23 Matthew: I don't get scared from the standpoint of my physical safety. I mean, I think there are some countries trees that I no longer will ever travel to. And that's, you know, and I don't, that's just the cost of doing business. And I, doesn't it bother me. I investigative reporter who into the things that people who are powerful or wealthy don't want you to know and and C, have to contend with over time. There's an exhaustion level that comes with the conduct that you're uncovering and what you're looking at. It can be tiring. It can be stressful. It is stressful. It can be dispiriting at times. And what's scary, I think, I it's scarier to me to learn what I've been reporting on for about a decade and not make it public. That to me is scarier than making it public and then sort of contending with that the material is dirty, feels dirty, right?

0:11:31 Thomas: Yeah, no freaking kidding.

0:12:23 Matthew: I mean, certainly there are days when I'm like, uh, I can use it. I could use a drink, for sure.

0:12:29 Matt: Yeah, is, no, I mean, it's, it's top level stuff that just beyond anything I really could have imagined. And just, just to kind of lay this out, let's, let's get into the content a bit here. We've got Jared Kushner, obviously a familiar to American listeners on anybody who's paying attention to the news as an actual Prince of the United States. And that's one thing I think the book brings out immediately. It's in the title. And I hadn't really considered the possibility. This is more than metaphorical that other countries with monarchies see him as a Prince and treat him as a Prince. That's what I've learned from this book. If you can, can you elaborate on that?

0:12:55 Matthew: Yeah. I mean, you know, there were, even in the first Trump administration, the chief of staff, uh, John Kelly, referred to, Ivanka and Jared as the Royal couple. And And what, in a lot of ways, what Trump did when he named Kushner as his sort of point man in the White House for the Middle East was breaking down American governance, the system of governance, you know, with the executive branch and experts who are diplomats and intelligence officials, replacing that with family. And, you know, whether you want to think whether Trump thinks of himself as king or just an autocrat or a wannabe autocrat, what they are and what he ran was a family shop.

That mirrored these Gulf Arab leaders who themselves were trying, in some cases, to preserve their position of power in their country. There's no distinction between themselves and their country, actually rung on the ladder, as it was with MBS from Saudi Arabia, who came knocking at the door of the White House and Jared Kushner at the beginning of 2017 to basically get a blessing on soft coup over his cousin, who was the crown prince. And so this is a story of, in a sense, royal families. And unfortunately, uh, for the American public, it happens to be that, that Trump and Kushner in their American way mirrored that, without a doubt.

0:14:22 Matt: Yeah, it's pretty direct. Many strange details in here, but even the fact that both families had incidents in which there was sexual blackmail committed on video against members of the family. I mean, it's just, there's so, I don't know, so many strange things going on here.

0:14:34 Thomas: Wait, what? Which, which ones are we talking about?

0:14:36 Matthew: Well, well, that's the, yeah, you're, you're alluding to, uh, the Kushner family, Charlie Kushner's sexual blackmail against his sister and MBZ, the, the, for your audience who might I'm familiar, he's the ruler of the UAE, Mohammed bin Zayed. And he committed sexual blackmail, ran a sexual blackmail operation against his older brother, who at the time was the crown prince. And actually, when I was reporting this, that was one of the key moments where I started to understand that there was something deeper here than just a question of potential government corruption, that there was a story here, not just a news item. And that was that there's sort of like water seeks its own level, right? So Charlie Kushner, Jared Kushner's father was, you know, the second wealthiest man in New Jersey, a prominent Democratic Party donor, the biggest backer of the New Jersey governor at the time, Jim McGreevey.

0:15:35 Matthew: All the while, as wealthy as he was, he was committing business and tax fraud. Some of the victims of that fraud were his siblings in a shared pool of business that they had. And his brother and sister eventually began cooperating in some capacity with federal prosecutors. At the time, it was Chris Christie, who is the U.S. attorney in New Jersey, and in an effort to dissuade his sister from cooperating, he set up her husband with a prostitute in a New Jersey motel that was wired with a hidden camera to film them having sex and then deliver that video to his sister and her husband, uh, as a means of warning them off of helping the feds investigate.

0:16:23 Matthew: And there was, it was, goes beyond that in that the prostitute was Charlie Kushner's prostitute. Uh, he had been using an escort for many years in New York. He had a sort of secret life going on, away from the modern Orthodox, Jewish community that he was a part And that Jared was raised in. He eventually ended up pleading guilty. He was sentenced to two years. He pled guilty to 18 felonies, one of which was witness intimidation based on the sexual blackmail. 10 years earlier, Mohammed bin Zayed, who was third in line for a successor to his father in the UAE because he was the third son, his brother, the Crown Prince Khalifa's weakness, which was that he was secretly gay, and had his brother set up with a man in Europe in a hotel, had it filmed.

0:17:13 Matthew: And then had the video delivered to the father, their father, who was the ruler of the UAE and the founder of the UAE, under the pretense that it was a Russian government or a Russian mafia attempt at the ruling family. And the father knew instinctively that it was Muhammad, not any kind of, that it was, that was a ruse and was somewhat pleased with his third son at his sort of ambition, prohibition, and, you know, the the halifa's secret was not, was a, like, like I'm describing as an open secret, that was a really eye-opening moment in my reporting because it was, it, it tells you something, right, the water seeks its own level, that they're, that, that these are people who, to protect themselves or to get ahead, will do, um, these kinds of unbelievable things to their own family members.

0:18:03 Matthew: And so then the question becomes, you know, especially with someone like MBZ, who is the ruler of this country with a trillion dollars in personal wealth, what isn't he willing to do, right? And that's where the book really, you I think the reporting starts to take off, which was that, you know, in the beginning of the Trump administration and even in the 2016 election, the UAE wanted to influence the election and they wanted to get in with the next president because they wanted to protect themselves and go after Iran and eradicate the last remnants of political Islam as best represented by the Arab Spring. And so you, you know, as a reporter, but as a storyteller, you're looking for people's intentions and motivations.

0:18:49 Matthew: And those two sort of mirroring stories of sexual blackmail, you know, you can't make it up, as they say, right? You know, the truth is stranger than fiction, but it's all true.

0:18:58 Matt: A certain kind of family, for sure. That's very specific. Yeah.

0:19:00 Matthew: It's not, it's not my family.

0:19:02 Thomas: You. Think they maybe met in a forum or something for like that particular hobby, you know, or?

0:19:02 Matt: Right.

0:19:07 Matthew: You know, it is, you know, your question is, is like, is it, people have, like, a sexual blackmail fetish, is that like a, you?

0:19:12 Thomas: Just.

0:19:12 Matthew: Know, subgenre?

0:19:12 Matt: Right, yeah.

0:19:14 Thomas: You know, like, how to, you know, like, tips on Reddit, you know, like, oh.

0:19:19 Matt: No, so getting into kind of the meat here, because, you know, this is, you're talking about something that if this could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt in court is so far beyond Iran-Contra which, of course, has, went all over, North, you know, essentially arranged a lot of money to be slushed around, uh, to accomplish two things the government wasn't supposed to be doing. This is so much worse. And And you lay out why it's so much worse. And it actually involves Oliver North, too, which I had to laugh. That's another you-can't-make-it-up kind of thing, that they'd bring him back for this.

0:19:45 Thomas: It does.

0:19:46 Matthew: Yeah, well, that's, no, I mean, I think the reason why that reporting is in there is because if you think of the, leaving aside the issue of constitutionality and illegality on Iran-Contra, what the point is, is that what it represents is the notion of executive power, right? That presidents and, white, and the people working for the president, despite what Congress may have passed in a law or what they can get away with publicly, believe that the best way to achieve foreign policy policy aims and goals is to use outside forces, use foreign government money, use mercenaries, use peristatal structures of running operations. And so, in the best way, the shorthand of it is sort of thinking, operating everything as if everything is the CIA and you're running covert action.

0:20:36 Matthew: Now in Iran-Contra, that was a government within a government that was essentially led by the director of the CIA. Ollie North was the main sort of manager in the White House from the NSC, but it utilized parts of the State Department, parts of the CIA, and then it had this external apparatus of former government officials doing things. Is, I think, a virus, right? The idea that there was something awesome about what they did. And Ollie North, what he represented most was, you know, for, for people in the conservatives in it, you know, national security officials who identify with, you know, as conservatives, Ali North was a hero.

0:21:22 Matthew: He went before Congress, raised his right hand and said, yep, I did all of that. And I do it again. And when they asked him, what did the president know? He conveniently couldn't remember, right? He took it on the chin to protect the president, and that made him and what he did heroic. And so when you get Eric Prince, the founder of Blackwater, who has this sort of love affair and obsession with a fantasy of CIA covert action, and in particular, Iran-Contra, and who has Ollie North as a close family friend and mentor, what you're getting is a virus that's spreading. And believe it or not, real genesis of the reporting that ends up in this book the secret arrangements with Kushner and these pools of money, which we can get into in a minute, really came out of – in December of 2017, I published with my colleague Jeremy Scahill at The Intercept a story about – We reported that Eric Prince had brought Ollie North into the White House to pitch this private CIA unit, off-the-books unit, spying unit, that would report directly to Trump and directly to CIA Secretary Mike Pompeo at the time.

0:22:34 Matt: And would draw from one of the greatest talents of conservative media.

0:22:35 Thomas: It. Just goes to show everything's a sequel or a reboot nowadays, you. Know, there's no.

0:22:40 Matt: Yes.

0:22:41 Thomas: There's no original scandals. Come on.

0:22:44 Matthew: Well. Well. Well, and so, and they bring Ollie North in to sell it to the White House because he was a Fox News, uh, contributor, so they thought Trump would love it because he knew Ollie North from TV, and because Ollie North had run, not this exact thing, but was familiar with the kind of programs that this was aping when he had been in the the White House. And so, and, you know, and at the time the White House essentially acknowledged that Prince had pitched it and then basically said, we're you not doing it. It was too toxic. No one in the U.S. government wanted to do it. And Prince was not, you know, Trump's not like very close with Eric Prince. And so at the time I thought, well, you know, that's the end of that. What I didn't know or realize, but would come to later understand, was that the concept there was embraced by the ruler of the UAE.

0:23:33 Matthew: And he was using and would use Eric Prince to reconstitute it. And what became significant was that Kushner was party to it in his role, sort of running a secret shadow foreign policy from the White House. And so there's a, what I I think is, and I don't know if you would agree with this, but what I think you can see in the reporting in the book that is, there are very few that these are continual threads that go and stretch on as ideas and as concepts and as people from, you know, they have a start somewhere 20, 30 years ago, and they lead all the way up to today. And that's not a a coincidence.

And I think one of the things that's hard is that the Vanity Fair excerpt, which got the most, obviously, explosive attention, is a truncated version of a chapter in a much larger book about a sequence of events that I'm, and just to give you another way of answering your question before about sourcing and receipts and documents, I think that when you see it in a a context of what it is, it's not just not, is it not implausible or unbelievable? It's logical. And I believe I certainly have my experience as a journalist and as a, as a reader, as a consumer of, of news and information for 30 years can say that that truth has a weight to it.

0:24:16 Matt: Yes. No,

0:25:02 Matthew: It's got a weight. It's like a, you know, I mean, and as the kids would say, it's got some aura. I feel is that when you read from start to finish, that weight becomes very clear

0:25:14 Matt: It does. And I think, as you say in so many places, the sequence of events. There's really no other way to explain it once you have this information. But I do want to point out, too, just because I don't want to bury the lead here, because our listeners are really going to appreciate, and Thomas is really going to appreciate, that when Eric Prince was trying to do this, he was tapping James O'Keefe and Project Veritas as the private spy agency. That's the judgment we're working with here. Yep. I thought that was incredible.

0:25:35 Matthew: Well, I'm sorry. You guys didn't give me my flowers. I was the first to report that Prince had been working with James O'Keefe and had trained them. And later, my peers at the New York Times, Mark Mazzetti and Adam Goldman, did a series of fantastic reporting to fill out, get further into the machinations. But again, it's the idea of it. It's the, you know, Eric Prince sees an opportunity to use O'Keefe's organization for essentially domestic political dirty tricks and having a private, you of commercial espionage unit, if you will, and then using it for his ends. And those ends are not democratic. I mean, that's what they all, all of the shares is sort of this impulse towards,

0:25:39 Matt: Yes. I want to make sure it came out.

0:26:26 Matthew: You know, they're all patriots and love America, but their conduct is frequently, seems pretty undemocratic.

0:26:32 Matt: Sure. Well, let's get in. Go ahead, Thomas.

0:26:34 Thomas: I was just laughing. I was thinking like, like, maybe this James O'Keefe isn't on the level. Starting to think, yeah. Someone should look into that.

0:26:38 Matt: Might be something to do that. Speaking of things they don't want you to know about, so let's get into it. The core claim in your book, which honestly, I'm still reeling every time I really think about what it means. Starting with the idea that this was all accidentally discovered by the Dutch. So if you want to set up kind of what we know and how we know it.

0:26:59 Matthew: So when we say it was all accidentally discovered, that's just the way in which, as a reporter, I first learn about it. You know, the reality is, of course, is that the people who were involved knew about it well before the Dutch did.

0:27:14 Matt: But it's why we have this book.

0:27:15 Matthew: Yes, yes, we, we have this book because I received a call, uh, in during COVID, from a source, um, as I was reporting on Eric Prince and a civil war in Libya that he had tried to help. With a sort of query, which was, uh, I have a series of bank transfers, um, that that I need to try to understand the meaning of the genesis of them was the Dutch had broken into Jared Kushner's phone, and in the process of their surveillance of the phone, see his access to a bank account that was held in the UAE that was receiving money, hundreds of millions of dollars from another bank account in Azerbaijan. And some of the transfers included money going to Eric Prince and the Libyan, aspiring Libyan dictator, Khalifa Haftar, others.

0:28:10 Matthew: And so that was the sort of the first thread that I was pulling on, but in the context of having worked on something, working on something similar, which was, you know, and that the account was, if not Kushner's by, you know, that it was Kushner's access and potentially his, like his actual account. Account. Um, it wasn't at the initial version. It wasn't, totally.

0:28:34 Thomas: What did Kushner do to the Dutch to piss them off? There's a lot there you've already given us. I

0:28:38 Matthew: Well, so, you later I would confirm the existence of the account and verify some of the transfers from the account. What later came at even further after that. Now, now, when I did that, at that point, story the in my mind, it was not about the Dutch or Azerbaijan. In fact, it was, you know, the question that had been posed to me is sort of, what is the meaning of this? What is the meaning of these, what are the meaning of these transfers? What is the meaning of this bank account that Kushner has access to in the UAE? None of the transfers, it was related to me at the time, went to one of his personal accounts, for instance, right? That it wasn't the money going into the UAE account and then going out to pay his Citibank bill or anything like that.

0:29:28 Matthew: And so the question was, what is this about? And I ultimately stumbled into sources who knew the bigger picture of what they were about, without having any knowledge of the Dutch hacking into the phone. I would later get sourcing to support and confirm the Dutch hacking, which was actually, in a lot of ways, made much more sense once I unraveled the whole thing, which was the Dutch government their main focus, their intelligence service, focuses on Russia. That's their main enemy. And they're a NATO partner, and they have this little unit that is sort of like have in the US, the NSA has a little unit called the Tailored Access Operations.

0:30:14 Matthew: And they're the ones who are really specialized in getting into anyone. They pick a target and they get in. And they are very good at it. They're not broad, but they're very good. And their main target is Russia. And they had, as an example, some of your listeners may remember that Russia interfered in the 2016 election, and that in the years even leading up to hacking into the DNC, the Russian government had hacked into the State Department's email system during the Obama administration. Well, this Dutch unit, these Dutch spies, had hacked into the Russian unit that had done that, and was watching them do it as they did it in 2014, and relayed that information to the US at the time, right? So there's a history of Dutch spying activities on the Russians, watching the Russians do what they do, and then working from there against the Russians.

0:31:08 Matthew: And so they had run an operation against a Russian operative working for this unit, the military intelligence unit known as the GRU, and found a way to flip him, basically gave him an option to either end up in an English prison or work for them. Them. And the operative chose to work for them. And in the process, what he gave them was access to some of the remote servers that this unit, this spying unit, this Russian unit used. And when the Dutch got into that remote server, which was inside Russia physically, they stumble upon the insides of Kushner's phone, that the Russians have access to Kushner's phone.

0:31:55 Matthew: And that was a three alarm fire for the Dutch. What is this about? Why are they spying on him? Remember at the time, this is late 2017, Trump is very hostile to NATO. He's making kissy faces with Putin at summits in Europe. And, the Mueller investigation is fully underway. Way. And so, you the Dutch have a question. What's the relationship between Russia and Trump? What's the relationship between Russia and Kushner? And so they did what any spy service would do. And they decided to figure out how the Russians got in to his phone just on a technical matter. And it took several months, but by early 2018, they were successful and they got into Kushner's phone.

0:32:45 Matthew: And while they were in his phone, they couldn't control it. As the reporting in the book shows, it's not malware where they could, the UAE, for instance, the malware that they used on my phone, unbeknownst to me, for six months, they had the ability to turn my phone on and off if they wanted. They could use my microphone as a listening device. They could turn the camera on and see where my phone was and what I might've been doing. Okay. That's the level of control. The Dutch didn't quite have that on Kushner's phone. What they had was the ability to see what was going on on the phone, on the screen, when it was in use. And that's when they start to see this bank account and these transfers. And so that's the genesis, if you will, for the reporter pulling the thread.

0:33:31 Matthew: But I want to emphasize that the Dutch part of the story is in some ways pretty insignificant in terms of what the mystery, mystery that they were trying. And to this day, I have no information that the Dutch ever really fully understood what was going on. And it's an open question that I'll always have and hope someday that there'll be an answer to. But my job as a reporter is to follow the leads where they go. And that's what I did.

And my leads went to the UAE and Kushner. And that's where I started to develop something that was much more significant than a European government hacking Kushner's phone, which was that there was a secret deal going on, some kind of arrangement in which leaders of the UAE and Saudi Arabia were working with Kushner on this sort of secret foreign policy that UAE and Saudi Arabia were trying to remake the Middle East and were engaging with people like, like specifically Eric Prince, to build mercenary armies using assassins and private armies to try to overthrow governments and help support one side of a conflict in countries around the Middle East and North Africa.

0:34:50 Matt: That's the sort of Iran-Contra sort of part of it. I mean, and again, it's worse than Iran-Contra because it's not even close to a sanctioned thing. But you also have what you call the beta account, which is the one that seems to be much more personal for Kushner. What's that about?

0:35:01 Matthew: Yeah. And I want to be clear about what the reporting says and what but it doesn't say. The beta account, and so I called these, I gave them names so that they were just easier to digest. The alpha account is the UAE account. And that one is, and I say it explicitly in the book, you know, imagine it being like the Iran Contra. This is, know, you a foreign policy, foreign secret military operations funded by a foreign government, which a senior White House official is engaged in, involved, but significantly had access to to the account. Now, that doesn't mean, and the book doesn't say, that he spent the money himself or took money from the account himself, but that he had access.

0:35:44 Matthew: And he was a signatory on this account. That's right. According to my reporting. And the beta account is different. The beta account was of a larger or underneath what was then secret negotiations and arrangements between Israel and the Emirati government. This is prior to the Abraham Accords. And what I write in the book is that the beta account was provided by MBZ, roughly a billion dollars, for Kushner. And that Netanyahu, in the course of this, and it's an open question, I'm not sure how or I don't know how Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu first learned about it, but he ultimately recommended and suggested to Kushner and the Emiratis that the money for the beta account be put in the Israeli Central Bank essentially a government account.

0:35:44 Matt: It was a signatory.

0:36:37 Matthew: When Kushner wanted money from the beta account to come out, there was a mechanism to move it out that required him communicating with Netanyahu. One of the things that in the immediate aftermath of the Vanity Fair excerpt was reporting online and in the Jerusalem Post that there were details that were wrong about the mechanism and how the Central Bank of Israel works. And what the problem was, was that all of that mischaracterized what I reported. The setup and the arrangement was specifically used and designed because it was not a personal account. The account at the central bank was a government account. It did not have Jared Kushner's name. What my reporting says was that the money was for Kushner's use or benefit.

0:37:25 Matthew: And now that leaves open plenty of interpretation. Interpretation. The book does not say how much of that money or if any of that money ultimately ended up in Kushner's pocket,

0:37:37 Matt: We're talking about $1 billion, just to be clear. Yeah, approximately.

0:37:39 Matthew: Yes. And, and, and there were other, and there, there were, again, you know, what I would just describe these as sort of pools of money. And I think the, the, the, what the book and the reporting that I felt was, important uh, important to make sure that, you know, sourced and credible, was some of the mechanism in which money was moved out of the account, which showed, just as it did with the Alpha account in a different way, that the design was to make sure that the transfers essentially were, that the whole existence of the system was deniable. And that it wasn't directly, that Kushner was not directly necessarily accessing the money, right? It's not a personal account. He can't just walk into the Bank of Israel and make a withdrawal.

0:38:25 Matthew: And so it may be frustrating for readers, but there are plenty of still unanswered questions about where all the money went and what it was all intended for. What I'm quite confident in is that the arrangement and the existence of the money is accurate. And that there, but there is still, I mean, you know, to be totally honest, there's a whole element of the Israeli side of this arrangement that I am still missing understanding, right? I can see that there's a missing part of it. I could see parts of it, enough to know, you know, if I had more or better sourcing within, within, Israel, I might have been able to fill in some of the gaps. But the point is, is that there is enough there to know that there was something that was not authorized.

0:39:17 Matthew: It was certainly not an official government program, right? One of the things that I was able to verify and be sure of is that this arrangement, either with the alpha or the beta accounts, were not part of some signed memo authorizing a covert action or a secret program, right? And that's my experience as a reporter. I'm an intelligence reporter and I work with understanding how the bureaucracy works, you know, which can include using, you know, the sort of nebulous world of cutouts and back channels and unofficial couriers, if you will, but that this was totally outside of that. And that is in part why some of the sources who were talking were talking, because what they were were describing to me was something that was, at the very least, wrong and potentially very illegal.

0:40:10 Matt: Extremely.

0:40:10 Matthew: That there was this, you know, essentially a secret deal that had been cooked up behind the scenes that would later become the Abraham Accords, in which the UAE and a few other governments, but especially the UAE, entered into diplomatic relations with Israel and recognizes Israel as a country, normalized relations, which was a big deal and easily Donald Trump's biggest foreign policy success of the first administration. But that behind that was something that was not something, there was something else that was secret and very troubling. And so the alpha and the beta accounts were sort of the path there to understanding part of, you know, I say in the book very clearly that the central unanswered question in the reporting here is, what did President Trump know?

0:40:57 Matthew: And there are only two scenarios. Either Kushner made these deals with MBZ and MBS behind his father-in-law's back, which is complicated since he's married to his daughter, or the president knew. And I don't know the, you know, I, you know, my job as a journalist is to make the public, you know, make the information public, bring it out in the public interest. And that's where I have to leave it, unfortunately. But, you know, I think that that's a question that everyone should be demanding an answer to.

0:41:26 Matt: So many questions out of this. And the other one I want to make sure, before we finish this interview, I want to make sure we talk about other thing that really did shock me. And I don't know how much of this was available before, but direct benefit to Kushner, who again, is a security risk unto himself. He will not be cleared by the intelligence community. John Kelly refuses as chief of staff to declare him as S. Trump, you're going to make me do it, and it's not happening otherwise. And one of the reasons he's such a security risk is because he's in significant amounts of debt, about a billion dollars in debt from the 666 Fifth Avenue project. And your reporting here shows that the Cutter has secretly funded that bailout.

0:41:59 Matthew: Yeah, so that's right. And it's important to understand that lay out in the reporting, besides, I mean, some of it is new and exclusive, but there's not always a clear quid pro quo. But also conspiracies don't require, in real terms, they don't necessarily require a quid pro quo. I mean, one of the failures of both, mostly the press and the public is to understand is that someone doesn't need to say, if you do X, I'll do Y. Or if I give you X, you'll give me Y. It can literally be, I would like X, and then you get X, and the other person says, I'm going to give you Y. Now, you have been written, you know, I talked to federal prosecutors for this.

Federal bribery laws do not necessarily require you to have an explicit arrangement. Arrangement. But what, when you lay out the chronology and sequence of events, what you can see is this, is that, so yes, on the security clearances, but with a little nuance. He was a security risk in part because the family business was a real estate business that had a foreign investment. And so it was opaque and they had this debt.

So, you know, you have this opaque, That's an avenue for, potentially, for foreign governments and entities to try to use to gain leverage on a government official who may be given security clearance. And so that's the issue. The other issue was that there were questions and concerns about his family, the Kushner family relationship with Netanyahu, which stretched back 20 years.

And, uh, was, you know, Charles Kushner had, had paid Netanyahu, I think $400,000 over a period of time in it to, for speeches that Netanyahu gave in, in New Jersey.

0:43:39 Matthew: So he was a political supporter. And then once Trump is actually, sorry, once Trump is in the White House and Kushner's working with a temporary clearance, what the security officials in the government saw were as many as 20 omissions in his contacts with foreign government officials. There was more.

It was not just the omissions, but then in some of the transcripts and intercepts that they were getting of Kushner with foreign government officials and foreign government officials talking amongst themselves, what they found were troubling questions about what some of the subject matter of his conversations with these foreign government officials were. And so there was both the fact that the contacts were happening and Kushner wasn't disclosing them unless asked, and the content of the communications. And so the U.S. government, you know, security apparatus is flashing a big, like flashing a big red, neon red, you know, light at Kushner's security risk and saying, "We're not going to give him a top secret clearance because he's a huge risk." There's no one who would get this. I mean, none.

I mean, I had someone who said to me, "Look, if you, if you apply to get your security clearance and you have one omission, they'll let it slide." Depending on who you are, you're somebody's nephew, maybe you can get a second one, but not 20. And at 20, you're not looking at omissions, you're talking about lying. You're hiding something. And so that was the determination of the counterintelligence experts who studied his, so you already have indications inside the government that Kushner is a problem and a risk.

0:45:15 Matthew: That happens to coincide with the decision by MBS and MBZ in the summer of 2017 to declare a blockade on their neighbor, Qatar, which is another US ally in the Gulf that has a US military base with 10,000 troops on it. And they sort of start this Cold War with threatening with the possibility of a military invasion. And that goes on at the same time, around the same time, that the first pool of money that they've secretly agreed to with Kushner starts to flow, okay? And there's a sort of civil war inside the Trump administration between Trump and Kushner on one side backing MBS and MBZ.

And then Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis trying to find a diplomatic solution, block the Saudis and the Emiratis from a military invasion to overthrow the Qatari government and essentially protect the Qataris who are an ally and come to avoid a civil war or a war in the Middle East, another conflict. And there's a lot of going back and forth. Trump is tweeting and demonstrating support for the Emiratis and the Saudis. And it's sort of a cold war going on for several months. During that time, the Qataris learn that MBS and MBZ have provided some kind of access to money for Kushner. They're debating what the hell to do with that information.

0:46:50 Matthew: While they're debating that, they're asking, they keep asking the White House and the U.S. government, what can we do to resolve this diplomatically? How do we end the blockade? And the answer that they were getting back indirectly, back channel, was the Kushners have this building on 666 Fifth Avenue that needs to be purchased. And they kept saying no. And they would go back, how do we resolve this diplomatically? The answer would come back indirectly again. The Kushners have this building. 2018, Secretary of Tillerson is fired by Trump and the Qatari royal family panics because from their vantage point, Tillerson was the only thing preventing a military invasion and a potential overthrow. And so they send a message back to the White House that they will arrange to get the building purchased.

0:47:42 Matthew: And they spend the next several several months, arranging for the building to be bought through a real estate company in which they were a passive investor, but doing it in a way that gave everyone plausible deniability.

0:47:54 Matthew: By that time, in the spring of 2018, after the Qataris had signaled back that they would take care of that problem, Trump came out and told MBS and MBZ that the blockade had to end and invited the emir of Qatar to the White House for a dog and pony show and say what great friends they were. And so the thing to remember about 666 Fifth Avenue was Kushner had, to some extent, had divested his ownership there. Although by divestment, he gave his ownership pieces to someone else in the family. But the company, it's the family business. It's his father's building that he helped buy that was in debt to the tune of $1.2 billion and was threatening the entire family, his family's fortune, right?

0:48:45 Matthew: I mean, big, the misconception that Kushner has tried to sell from the beginning was that he was independent. He wasn't. He's a dependent, first of his father. Then when he gets into office in the White House, he's dependent of his stepfather. And even with nothing else, when he leaves the White House, his three investors for his fund are the same three Gulf rulers who were working with him secretly to help him in the first administration. So in any way you cut it, he's got nothing but sugar daddies, right? Right? And so 666 is up for, his loan is up and he's facing it, it's a ticking time bomb for the family. And so Kushner's response to my reporting was that he got no benefit from the sale.

0:49:36 Matthew: He denies that the Qataris paid for it. He denied that he had anything to do with his sale. I mean, wholesale, he denies everything. So I want to be clear. He denies everything, says it's all untrue. But one of the things that he says in his denial was that he didn't make any money off of it. And the book doesn't say that he made money off of the sale. What the sale was, was the saving of his family's wealth, his father's wealth, his father's wealth and money. And so, um, this is, you know, what I've been saying is I should have probably said it in the book. This is a real-life Game of Thrones that this book tells the story of Jared Kushner's involvement in a real-life Game of Thrones with three Gulf Arab And it is all too real and true.

0:50:21 Thomas: Feel like the Game of Thrones people would be like, yeah, that's a little corrupt. I don't know.

0:50:24 Matt: And little much, right?

0:50:25 Thomas: This is, oof. Targaryens are like, what are you doing, man? Come on.

0:50:26 Matt: Yeah. Yeah. And I really want to pull back since we're in our last few minutes here and make sure that people understand kind of the through line we're talking about here, because it's just staggering when you really pull back and think about the effect this one man, Jared Kushner, has had on Middle Eastern policy, on American foreign policy, the ways that he has used all this to enrich himself. And again, I'm taking your reporting as true, but even just from what's publicly available, there's just so many questions that were already raised. This answers a lot of them for me, but, but, know, how much different do you think the world might be right now if Jared Kushner had not been doing any of this?

0:51:05 Matthew: Oh, that's, I mean, that's, I can't answer that question. It's an unanswerable question. I think what I'm stuck with is watching in the second term the safeguards and guardrails for preventing president and his family using the office and American foreign policy to benefit themselves and enrich themselves have been stripped away. And what they've done, so book my is sort of the origin story of that, how by placing Kushner, his unqualified son-in-law, in this job that had no statutory authority, he didn't have any government authority, he had no power, but he had all the influence because he was family. But he also had no oversight because he didn't have to go through a Senate confirmation.

0:51:08 Matt: Sure.

0:51:57 Matthew: Not an elected official, he's never really had to go through the kind of vetting that you need to have, one should have in the government to have this much authority and influence. And so in the second administration, they sort of cleverly decided he doesn't even have to get into the government. Before he was, you know, at least a government employee, but now he's not even a government employee, but in arguably the most significant diplomat in American diplomat, period. He leads or is co-leading every major diplomatic negotiation. You know, there was a story not too long ago, the Times reported that there's this, as part of the wrangling the between the Trump administration and Russia over ending the war in Ukraine is getting US government access to Russian oil assets that are outside of Russia and Lukoil.

0:52:48 Matthew: And in that deal that Kushner and Witkoff are negotiating, the investments, some of the money the Trump administration claims would go to the U.S. government. I think the amounts, it's the smaller amount, but some of it would go essentially to the U.S. Treasury. But on the private side of that deal would be MBZ's younger brother, Taknun, who was part of the secret arrangement, by the way, with Kushner during the first administration. Is also one of essentially Kushner's investors in his private equity fund, Affinity Partners, now that he's out of government, is the investor on the $2 billion crypto deal that went to and Trump in the days leading up to Trump's inauguration.

0:53:33 Matthew: And then the second set of investors are these Syrian-born, Qatari-based real estate moguls who are Kushner's business partners on the potential deal in Albania, on the island in Albania, right? So even if Kushner gets not one penny from that deal, and no one claims that he is, his investors are. And so you can't even be, I mean, the notion of corruption and a conflict of interest, I mean, it's, it's, it's, it's mind boggling. Right. And, and he's at the center of it.

0:54:05 Matt: He's also acting as a foreign agent for multiple governments at this point, right? I mean, it's hard to get him to miss that.

0:54:09 Matthew: Well, I think, I mean, that's, I think that that's, I mean, one of the things that the, the, you know, I have to be careful. Well, I'm very clear. I'm not a prosecutor. And what, if proven in a, in a court, some of activities the that, conduct that I reported may be, may, he may have run afoul of, you know, foreign agent registration laws. But there are certainly things that indicate that he is, you know, his defense and responses, everything that he does is in the best interest of America, that he does everything in America's best interest. And I think just leaving aside what's in my book, just looking at the second term, the Trump administration, that's on its face, almost laughable. I mean, it's false, it's a little bit like gaslighting, I think.

0:54:55 Matthew: So I think I hope people will read the book because they can understand the origin story of sort of how we got here, including the war in Iran, and understand that it doesn't answer every question. It is meant to get more answers to really serious and significant questions about what went on in the first term.

0:55:13 Matt: Is. Yeah, and I think you've really done it. I really want to commend you on the work here and, again, the courage of getting this out. You know, I obviously wanted to hold you to the standards and make sure people understood where this is coming from, but I find no reason for this not to be credible. He can say it's incredible all he wants. I think it's incredible because everybody should read it. So I really appreciate your time, Jane.

0:55:17 Matthew: Thank you. You. I

0:55:28 Thomas: Think the new Congress should read it.

0:55:29 Matt: Yes. Oh, yes. Actually, I meant to ask you about that. I mean, this really should be special counsel. We should have multiple hearings on this. I mean, that's not up to you, I know, but there's so much in here that should support further investigation from the government. I hope that happens.

0:55:32 Thomas: Yeah. Well, yeah, I was going to ask, like, what would you hope the new incoming Congress try might to look at? Who should they subpoena, kind of thing?

0:55:45 Matthew: I think that it's best for me to leave those questions answered by others. My job as a journalist is to get to the bottom of the truth as best as I can understand it and get to it, make it public. And then after that, you know, I mean, I think just generally speaking, the book and the reporting begs all of these questions and the public deserves an answer and answers to them. And how we get those answers, there are multiple ways. Yes, Congress can investigate. Other journalists and news organizations should be asking these questions and trying to get to the bottom of it. That's, but that is for everyone else to do at this point.

0:56:21 Thomas: Sure. But I mean, like, if you could, if you had subpoena power, who would you want to ask more questions of, you know, just as a journalist even?

0:56:21 Matt: Well, I

0:56:27 Matthew: Well, but a journalist can't have subpoena power. So I'm going to, I'm going to give you, I'm going to give you the most frustrating answer, which is that I'm just not going to answer that question. I don't, I don't think it's, I don't think it's, I mean, I'm genuinely speaking, I don't think it's appropriate. I'm not a prosecutor. I don't think about these things as, you know, I go about investigating as a journalist, not about proving crimes, right? It's just telling this, unraveling something and telling the story and trying to get to answer questions that I have or that have been posed to me. And so, my methodology is, working as a journalist with sources and that's it, you know, And hopefully, when I put it together, as I hope I have in this book, that the story is both logical and understanding, but also compelling, right? I mean, and that to me is the bigger challenge. That's my challenge, right? Is to make sure that it's digestible to readers and to the public. And then after that, it's everybody else's work.

0:56:30 Thomas: Sure. Fair enough.

0:57:23 Matt: Can certainly confirm it is. It's a really compelling read. It's our book club selection for this month, and everybody should read it. I just want to say also the integrity of that answer and the way that you framed all of this and the amount of thought that you put into these answers, I think, really speak for themselves as to how much people can trust this reporting. So I just really commend you again, thank you.

0:57:28 Matthew: Thank you.

0:57:39 Matthew: Thank you. I thank you both for having me. You know, I just want people to read it and to, you know, make it their own determination. And I say so in the book, right? The book is very forthright from the beginning, the middle and the end that Kushner denies everything. And, I stand by my reporting and, you know, I leave it to readers to determine which version of events they think is more credible.

0:57:43 Matt: They should. Awesome.

0:58:02 Matt: Uh, well, Matthew Cole, book is Princes and Thieves, again, our book club selection over this month, we'll be discussing it the last Sunday of the month. So thanks again for your time, good talking to you. I

0:58:09 Matthew: Thank you. Thank you, guys.

0:58:10 Thomas: So much

0:58:13 Clip: This has been Opening Arguments, produced by Thomas and Lydia Smith, with editing help from Peter Baird. The intro is by Thomas Smith. This outro is by Matt Cameron. Support the show at patreon.com/law. Contact us through Patreon or openarguments@gmail.com. Make sure to follow our blue sky, at OpenArgs. But most of all, please share the show. Thanks for listening.