The Serious Pod Network

Thomas and Lydia
Opening Arguments

The Epstein Files Transparency Act Turns One, and DOJ Still Hasn't Complied

One year ago this week Congress demanded that federal agencies publicly release everything they had on Jeffrey Epstein within 30 days. So how's that going? We review a year in Epstein transparency. Also: your questions about last week's FAA debacle which canceled nearly 13,000 flights, and a footnote about the largest plaintiffs ever to appear before the Supreme Court of Hawaii.

Cases and sources discussed:

Check out the OA Linktree for all the places to go and things to do!

To support the show (and lose the ads!), please pledge at patreon.com/law! $2+ patrons also get a new Law'd Awful Movies every month.

Follow Opening Arguments:

Transcript

This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors — the audio is the record.

0:00:33 Thomas: Hello, and welcome to Opening Arguments. This is episode 1315. I'm Thomas Smith. Over there is real-life immigration attorney Matt Cameron. How are you doing, Matt?

0:00:40 Matt: Hey Thomas, just sitting around waiting to see which part of the American infrastructure is going to break today.

0:00:44 Thomas: Mm, yeah. Got the infrastructure death pool. I chose pools on my infrastructure death pool. It's really confusing. Public pools. Oh, they already died. Never mind. Racism killed them. I'm saying, I've checked my notes. That's racism killed pools.

0:01:02 Matt: Yeah, what a week. What a week.

0:01:03 Thomas: What do you have next? Trains, planes, automobiles.

0:01:06 Matt: Yeah, I don't know. I mean, our trains are already broken, so that's an easy one in Boston. They've been broken.

0:01:12 Thomas: I thought you guys did things better over there.

0:01:14 Matt: We do. We absolutely do. I mean, at least we have trains.

0:01:16 Thomas: I loved the public transportation when we, when we visited.

0:01:20 Matt: No, you got lucky. Yeah, you weren't on the red line or the green line really, but yeah, or that much.

0:01:22 Thomas: Oh, I see. Boy, poor colorblind people. They're going to, they're just like, I don't know which one. Oh, it's a bad one. Dang.

0:01:27 Matt: Yeah, that's true. I never thought about that. When it works, it works, but we've been breaking down more and more, you know, just a lot of things not working right in this country right now. All at the same time yeah, well, last Friday, one of the most important things, uh, infrastructure wise did not work and that was our airport. So I don't want to talk about what happened and why, because there's a lot of blame being thrown around. I'd love to say it's Russ Valt's fault or that it's, Sean Duffy's fault or that it's Donald Trump's fault. I'm not really sure I can say any of that, but I did look into kind of the law around this and how all this breaks down and what happened.

0:01:38 Thomas: Speaking of, what are we going to be talking about today? I think we have a good show lined up.

0:02:01 Thomas: Yeah.

0:02:01 Matt: And you know, is this going to happen again? Are there warnings of this? It's all pretty interesting stuff to see what's going on with our reports right now. Little scary to see what they're being held together by.

0:02:10 Thomas: Yeah, I mean, Lydia and I touched on it in something. I've been aware there's a book we just recorded that's going up tonight. And I expressed skepticism over the copper wire story. That doesn't seem right to me. No, that makes sense.

0:02:24 Matt: No, it's not exactly.

0:02:25 Thomas: But then again, it is so specific. Think what happened to what killed it is someone also said, you copper wire, upgrading to fiber optic, you know, people, upgrading analog to digital. I was like, well, that's not, that's not that it's all, it's both digital. It's two different digitals. So I think because of that, I was skeptical of whatever the hell that was. And, you know, it's this administration. So then I was thinking about it. I was like, well, that is a very specific story that there's probably something there. Like it's This probably is related to something about that. Otherwise, it would be a very specific lie to tell about a third party because it's a contractor or whatever. So on second thought or third thought, I'm curious what you have to say about it. I know we're not approaching it from a technical perspective, but I'd be curious any thoughts you have on it.

0:02:41 Matt: Right. Right. Just kinds kinds of wire. Right.

0:03:13 Matt: Yeah. Copper wires are related. They're part of the story. They're not the story. And also just to make sure that I understood a little better, I went and listened to some aviation podcasts. So you don't have to actually some pretty good ones out there. I

0:03:23 Thomas: Everything aviation related. The people who do those things like, so YouTube channels. Yeah. Whenever there's a crash or like a, you know, an alien craft sighting, allegedly there's a lot of really sharp people with so much interesting info in aviation circles. I love them. I absolutely love it. It's so cool. They're always so precise, you know, and they got, and then they're really, really interesting people. So that, that must've been a pleasure.

0:03:25 Matt: Yeah. Super cool.

0:03:41 Matt: Yeah. Yeah. And we've got at least one listener who's an ATC. So I hope you're keeping your eyes on the skies while you listen to us, but appreciate it.

0:03:49 Thomas: Yeah. Hey, Michael Rops, If you still listen, I can't remember, but if he, if he still listens, but he was a pilot and he would, uh, he was a patron and interacted, uh, for a lot. So yeah, it's cool doing a podcast. You get all kinds of cool people just write in sometimes and be like, Oh, I do this.

0:04:00 Matt: That's cool too. Know more about you than other things that we talk about happens all the time. So we'll talk about that, but I also, I just learned today, I just realized that it is the first anniversary of the Epstein Files Transparency Act.

0:04:10 Thomas: Yeah. Oh, happy anniversary, Matt. I didn't get you anything. Thing.

0:04:20 Matt: Well, The House Democrats got us a report. It's pretty good. It's worth a look.

0:04:25 Thomas: I got you not exploiting children.

0:04:28 Matt: Thanks. I'm continuing to not do that. Yeah.

0:04:30 Thomas: I thought you'd like it. I don't know.

0:04:35 Matt: Yeah. So just a quick look back here on the whole debacle and how it's been going for the year, what else maybe Democrats can do to move this thing forward, the competing House reports tell us or don't tell us about all of this. So I just thought it was worth a check-in. Haven't talked about Epstein in a while, and there's been some news, so I thought that was worth a look. And then we have a footnote involving the largest plaintiffs ever to come before a court ever in history. They're very large.

0:05:00 Thomas: Humpback whales.

0:05:01 Matt: Largest land animals.

0:05:02 Thomas: Oh, okay. Interesting. I remember what that is. We'll see. All right.

0:05:07 Matt: You will in a moment when we

0:05:09 Thomas: Can't wait.

0:05:09 Matt: Get there. All right.

0:05:10 Thomas: Action Action-packed show, we better get to it. We'll take a break, support the show, patreon.com/law. Thanks so much to our patrons, a lot of movies coming at you pretty soon. Uh, also avoiding the ads and just supporting, uh, good work and expertise like Matt's. We need more of it in the world, so thanks for sharing and supporting, everybody. We'll take a break and we'll get right back to it.

0:05:33 Thomas: Right, Matt, you want to start with, uh, some copper wire pod?

0:05:39 Matt: Getting to the point in America where we're ripping out the copper wires and selling them.

0:05:43 Thomas: Yeah, that's actually, that's what was going on, it's just stripping it for parts.

0:05:47 Matt: End of empire, fun times. So a couple of things here just to get going. Obviously, I think everybody caught probably that the entire air system shut down, but

0:05:55 Thomas: True. Story, when I was in the air Yeah.

0:05:58 Matt: Wow, lucky.

0:05:58 Thomas: And so I was a little nervous, because I was, I didn't know, you know, we had no idea, it was just like, oh yeah, I see a, nowadays, since you can have the internet on the planes, I see an alert that's like, uh, flights are shutting down, like, this doesn't seem great, I'm in in midair right now.

0:06:14 Matt: Yeah.

0:06:15 Thomas: Like, I was wondering if they're just going to turn the plane off, you know, it's just like, oh, no more plane, and then we just fall out.

0:06:19 Matt: I mean, as long as there's not an F-18 pulling up next to you, probably okay.

0:06:21 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. It, I was a little worried, because if it's like, okay, air traffic controller, something, I'm flying back into Sacramento in zero visibility weather, so I was like, I'm not, not nervous about whatever's happening right now, but by the time it, like, it popped up, of when I was like maybe 45 minutes away from landing, by the time I was closer to landing, it kind of, more details came out to where I was like, okay, I'm not that nervous, but I just barely got out, had my flight been a little later I would have been stuck.

0:06:53 Matt: It's been a mess. It was a mess for a lot of people. It was only about four hours and 20 minutes that it was down, but that's enough.

0:06:54 Thomas: Yeah. Enough to cancel a million flights, yeah.

0:07:02 Matt: Yeah, exactly. Especially when they don't know when it's going to resume. So yeah, I think that was pretty much the whole day. I went down at 3.54 PM is what I've got here, came back around 8.15. first of all, this involve copper wire in the sense that they are replacing the copper with fiber optic, which is of course what it should have been a very long time ago. And what they call the legacy equipment, which includes about 400 different sites, they're using floppy disks, just FYI.

0:07:02 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah, sure.

0:07:24 Matt: And they have to go on eBay, Bay, according to Sean Duffy, to replace these floppy disks sometimes. I appreciate the nostalgia of floppy disks, but maybe not on our air traffic controlling systems.

0:07:28 Thomas: My God. Can't be literally floppy disks. Those hold no Information, are they, that they're not the better, like Later Version, like tape or whatever

0:07:34 Matt: Literally floppy disks. No, I think they're like the zip drives now. No, I think they're What I saw, like actual floppies, three and a halves. There's a lot of 80s style technology being used here. Obviously we need modernization. And this is not limited to the Trump administration. Obviously, we've had a very old system for a long time. There are different approaches to all of this. And I do think that you can blame the Trump administration for some of this. I'll get into that. Incredible to me that this whole thing comes down to a router somewhere in El Dorado, Arkansas. Nature of how interconnected everything is. But we had these contractors, L3 Harris, who were swapping out out and diswire. And I guess there was something that was swapped out or shouldn't have been, or they didn't turn something off they should have, who knows. But it's contractors. That was it. The only other time I will note that we've had a full shutdown of the airports since 9-11 was in 2023 when something similar happened when contractors accidentally deleted an entire database.

0:07:42 Thomas: Wow. Yeah.

0:08:28 Matt: That is relevant. And of course that was under Biden. Don't find it to be that useful sometimes to just talk about who was president when something happened. I mean, It's obviously huge government, lots of contractors, but I do think in this case, after taking a look at the Government Accountability Office's do report, seem to be warning, and I saw it and I heard in these podcasts, I was just kind of spot checking to see what industry professionals have been saying about this this week. Some agreement that the Trump administration is rushing this at what the GAO calls an unprecedented speed.

And I think that has a lot of something to do with it. It does seem like they're pushing This modernization program very, very quickly, which is, you know, it's good. There's some real risks here, some of these copper wires are from the 60s. But you also need to be responsible about it and you need to have some oversight. And this podcast that seemed to be very credible that I was listening to, AvTalk, I guess, they were saying that this is an oversight side issue more than anything, this seems like maybe not even, you can't even say it's the fault of the systems themselves.

0:08:35 Thomas: It only depends if It's causally Related, yeah. Uh Yeah.

0:09:20 Thomas: I mean, and like you say, okay, during, during Biden we got knucklehead still eating entire thing, like, it's not, it is a little easy to just blame Trump for whatever happened, but there's something to be said for the awfulness with which they presented the information, like Blaming other people, blame, it's just being able, the other thing is, like, I don't trust it because the story is presented stupid, like, like, he's Talking like it's a copper wire, like it's an actual, like, wire, like it, like he's diffusing a bomb and he's like, they cut the blue, blue one instead of the red, again, colorblind problems. In a different administration full of competent people, you might've had an expert up there, right? Like talk and, like, give you better, a explanation.

0:09:35 Matt: Very bad.

0:09:44 Matt: Right.

0:10:00 Matt: They did have the technical person, which, uh, the, the podcast guy seemed to have a lot of respect for whoever It is, I'm forgetting the name right now, it's like the actual operations manager.

0:10:03 Thomas: Yeah. Leave it to that person.

0:10:08 Matt: Does Sean Duffy, of course, former, former reality star, I was doing a lot of the talking, was, I was going to suggest, perhaps for a lot of movies, did you know that, uh, Sean Duffy and his family actually have shot an entire reality show while he's been. I just learned this.

0:10:17 Thomas: Yep. John Oliver covered it. Probably everybody knows about it, but it was, we've been, I've been on Sean Duffy ever since. So I was covering the, Charlie Kirk's wife's morning festival, uh, that one last year that they did, it's been about a year now, geez, and it had so many, so many guests, uh, it was the most interesting thing, I could have covered it for 20 episodes because the grift and the just bullshit was really interesting, and the way the grift was integrated into like the guests, you know, like the guest speakers, that, here's our speaker, this is this cool guy, and it's like, oh, oh, they're just a grifter there to, like, sell their crap. Anyway, the Duffies were one of them. I was like, who the hell are these people? And I was like, oh, it's reality stars that are in charge of our entire infrastructure. That's when I kind of got to know them. This was, again, a year ago. And yeah, that's not who should be in charge.

0:10:18 Matt: Oh, okay.

0:11:07 Matt: Just to be fair, he is a lawyer and did serve as a legislator at some point, but yeah, he's still a reality show at the end of the day. And they seem to have made their priority while in office being a reality star. So that's not good.

0:11:17 Thomas: Is a lawyer who should be in charge? What's his name? Who's not like a, I don't know. I don't know what the best qualifications are. Being a serious person, you know, and and Sean Duffy is not a serious person, so.

0:11:21 Matt: A bit of judging. Yeah. Right. I mean, lawyers are not serious people, so I'll give you that. No, no. And I think this press conference really proved that from what I saw. The buck really stops at Pete Buttigieg is what I learned.

0:11:36 Thomas: Yep, was in there with those copper wires, chewing the wires actually.

0:11:39 Matt: Right, yeah. Well, he put the wires in. I mean, I don't know what he was thinking, but putting 1960s copper wires in. Just because I was looking through some of the legal issues around this, 2024, everybody should be aware of this. One of the things that Pete Buttigieg did do for us, and he was a pretty effective Secretary of Transportation from what I understand, he finalized a rule that airlines immediately have to refund you as soon as a flight is canceled.

0:11:44 Thomas: Yeah, Yeah.

0:12:00 Matt: Like, just no questions.

0:12:00 Thomas: What?

0:12:00 Matt: That just has to happen. Along with your bag fees, which of course we'll have to pay now. So that's, you know, I can thank Pete Buttigieg for that. There were 12,462 cancellations according to the FAA from that one day. That is so many. Also, just because we live in an idiocracy, I also learned that this initiative, that this very rapid infrastructure change, because of course, obviously the government's been trying to modernize infrastructure for a while, but DOT called this push the brand new air traffic control system, the BNATs, brand new air traffic control system.

0:12:31 Thomas: Brand new like in the Great Big Beautiful Bill sense, like that stupid kind of crap crying out loud, but

0:12:35 Matt: Was literally in the big beautiful bill we're children. We're just all children now. So you guys want a brand new aircraft control system?

0:12:43 Thomas: How else will I know whether I like something or not? This is the great debate. This is a good one. Good. Air trap, okay.

0:12:49 Matt: It old?

0:12:50 Thomas: I like It's new and good.

0:12:50 Matt: It might be old. Okay. Yeah. But apparently as part of the BNets, they've been pushing this really hard and really riding the contractors and probably not providing it for every site. I naturally thought of two things when I saw this news. I was like, well, can we blame Doge for this? Because obviously Doge was cutting and slashing all over the place. I looked and looked. I can't see any evidence. I mean, obviously Doge did some things, the FDA. I can't see any evidence that Doge was doing this. If anything, it seems like the GAO was concerned that they were moving too quickly with too many personnel at once, right? There's just too many projects happening at once. They're not watching them all. So that's sort of the opposite of Doge.

0:13:06 Thomas: Yeah, yeah, Is give them credit, it wasn't what I expected you were going to be saying. I mean, it does sound like they wanted to have like a cool presentable thing, you know, deliverable or whatever, and so they're just like, "Hey, breakneck, do all this," which is its own kind of bad, but I mean, I guess I appreciate that they're trying to do stuff. That's nice.

0:13:24 Matt: Yeah, Yeah.

0:13:42 Matt: Trump also ordered that they produce the biggest Navy ship ever made in the world by the end of his terms, which they told him he couldn't do. They just flat out told him that. Doesn't take no as we know. Not a man who takes no. $50 billion obviously was put over. Now, the question becomes about Russ Vought, the Office of Management and Budget, who's been illegally withholding lots of things, as we know, that he just doesn't think should be spent. And his job is not to to decide what should be spent, but just to make sure it gets spent as it's supposed to be.

0:13:48 Thomas: Cool. Oh, is that still happening?

0:14:08 Matt: Yeah, he's still doing some impoundments, as I understand it. He's still at least delaying things.

0:14:12 Thomas: So he's still, he's still impounding stuff. I thought that was, you know, pretty decidedly not okay.

0:14:16 Matt: Many of the cases where it's been reviewed, it hasn't been, but he's delaying things. And there's this $5 billion that's supposed to go to some modernization that Democrats have been harping on and saying that delayed this until sometime middle of next year when he didn't have to. He's saying he just delayed it the next fiscal year and it's within his rights. There's been a lot of back and forth. I can't honestly, I have to go pretty deep to figure this out. I can't really tell what the truth is. It's one of those things where it might be convenient for Democrats to say that. I'm certainly willing to believe. And now, of course, Duffy and Vought are co-signing, asking for another $30 billion. Then Duffy says he wants $50 billion. Obviously, Republicans are pushing back now and saying, we don't know what you're going to do with that. We need to know.

0:14:46 Thomas: Well, is this for infrastructure? Yeah. That's like a 1% of what we gave freaking ice to be stormtroopers. Like, yeah. How about we spend way more than that actually?

0:14:52 Matt: Exactly. Exactly. Fix the airports. I use them a lot. I'd really like to make sure that they can work. I have no problem with putting as much money as possible to actual infrastructure. Maybe do it at a responsible pace,

0:14:57 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. I'd like to wait until real people are in charge, but sure.

0:15:07 Matt: Yeah, sure. Are claiming there's about 8 billion that is unobligated. Duffy had this whole explanation about how it's all these different buckets and he has to spend it the right way. I don't know. It's hard to say. There's no evidence at least that I can find that any missing money caused the outage. It seems like if anything, it was the speed. It was trying to move things. It was trying to do too much at once.

0:15:23 Thomas: Yeah.

0:15:24 Matt: That's where I'm at with it.

0:15:25 Thomas: Yeah. And again, crap happens with this kind of thing, I mean a lot of yeah complicated project, yeah, exactly.

0:15:27 Matt: It sure does. There's complex systems. Yeah.

0:15:31 Thomas: All right. So nothing, uh, legally weird going on here. Nothing. It's just kind of is what it is.

0:15:31 Matt: Yeah. No, it's just the system itself, just continuing on as it does. And I think it is just a reminder that it's not really always helpful to try to say that everything that happens while Trump is president is Trump's fault, just like everything that happened to Biden wasn't Biden's fault. Some things are just big and complicated, and this is the infrastructure deep state network. Work. So that's what I can say.

0:15:54 Thomas: All right, well, why don't we take a break, and then we're going to talk about I'm going to wish you a happy anniversary. All We'll celebrate the anniversary of maybe something happening on Epstein, but not. Is that a good way to sell it?

0:16:05 Matt: That's about right.

0:16:06 Thomas: Okay. Okay. Matt Epsteiniversary. Huh? What did this thing do? This, uh, this bill.

0:16:06 Matt: Yeah.

0:16:15 Matt: All the way back on November 18th, 2025, if you can cast your mind back, Congress did pass an act saying within 30 days that all of the Epstein files, everything that DOJ and FBI and everybody else had, had to be released. Obviously, it could be redacted. There which they stretched as far as they could. To be fair, I have to be fair here, that's a lot to release in 30 days if you're going to try to comply with those requirements.

0:16:38 Thomas: How many days are in a year? Is it, have we hit that 30 days yet, Matt? I can't remember. It was like 19 days in a year.

0:16:44 Matt: So a few more, I think.

0:16:45 Thomas: I can't remember something.

0:16:45 Matt: I'm not great at numbers. A few more than 30. the Epstein Act was probably the most bipartisan thing that's happened in years. It was 427 to 1 in the House, with Clay Higgins being the only no,

0:16:46 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. Wow. That person should be arrested immediately. There should

0:17:00 Matt: Investigate it, at least, what's going on with you.

0:17:01 Thomas: Have been like tons of police waiting just like with handcuffs out. Like what's the vote? Who's the, anybody against this?

0:17:06 Matt: Yeah. So it passed the House on November 18th, and it hit unanimous consent in the Senate November on 19th, and then immediately signed. So it said that by December 19th, 2025, the Attorney General is to publish all unclassified records held by DOJ, FBI, and the U.S. attorneys in a searchable and downloadable format. And that is a big order. Like, that is a lot to put that all up, not only to have it available, but to have us be able to look at it. And of course, for those of us who've been delving into the files for a while, it is not very searchable. It is pretty hard to use the format they released. I can recommend, if you're especially enjoying and you should take a look at, enjoying isn't really the word, but if you want to review Jeffrey Epstein's emails, there's something called Gmail, which puts his emails all in a Gmail style interface.

0:17:24 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah. Right. Yeah.

0:17:46 Matt: And It's great to use. It's really helpful. It's also super creepy because the last email that he received, I'll let you see that. But And of course, we're talking about the Epstein files. That is a very broad term. So they define it did best they could. Anything from any of those agencies that relates to Jeffrey Epstein, including all the investigations, investigations, prosecutions, anything relating to Ghislaine Maxwell, any flight logs or travel records, including all the manifest and pilot records, any individuals named or referenced in connection with the criminal activities, civil settlements, immunity agreements, plea or investigatory proceedings, any corporate, non-profit, academic, or governmental entities with known or alleged ties to trafficking or financial networks, and immunity deals, non-prosecution agreements, plea bargains, or sealed settlements, any internal DOJ communications. We read through some of those communications, especially those relating to communications with Alan Dershowitz. You might remember that they, they liberally redacted the names of the prosecutors who were involved in those communications, which

0:17:46 Thomas: That doesn't make any sense, Matt.

0:18:34 Matt: It does not. They are not people who need to be protected. They are not victims of Jeffrey Epstein. They are, in fact, enablers of Jeffrey Epstein. Any documentation of the detention or death of Jeffrey Epstein. So there was a lot from that, too. You. Specifically, the attorney general may not withhold from publication. This is very important. Delay the publication of or redact any record, document, communication, or investigative material on the basis of embarrassment, reputational harm, or political sensitivity. But they definitely did that. There was a lot of that going on. They may permit, obviously, personal a identifiable information from anybody who was harmed by Epstein, anything that might constitute child pornography, anything that would jeopardize an active federal investigation, any graphic stuff. F. this was very minimal, very limited. They pretty much had to publish everything. Did they do that? No, of course they didn't. We know they didn't.

0:19:13 Thomas: Well, they did publish some of the the stuff that they weren't supposed to that docks people and violated privacy so

0:19:17 Matt: Yeah. And they put a lot of people on this. I mean, it's hard to get everything, but you'd think even using AI they could, or whatever, even just using control F. I mean, I would think you could go through and search for every single name you know isn't supposed to appear there and make sure you redact them, but they didn't seem to manage to do that. If you're going to redact anything, category. You have to have a written justification published in the Federal Register and sent to Congress. They were really trying to make this very clear about what they're doing. Obviously, none of this was complied with. Just looking at the timeline here, of course, they blew the first deadline. They put out a very partial thing of 4,000 files, I think. You might remember the first round, there was a lot of blacked out pages. We covered that at the time. There was photo a that was pulled after the release for further review of Trump, Epstein, and Maxwell that made some attention.

They just continued bits and pieces in December all the way through, remember this. DOJ admitted by January 5th that there was 2 million plus pages that had still not been released. By January 30th, they said they'd compiled about 3.5 million pages plus 2,000 videos and 180,000 images. Wall Street Journal found that 43 out of 47 victim names at some point appeared unredacted

0:19:38 Thomas: That's Not a good ratio.

0:20:21 Matt: It's very bad.

0:20:22 Thomas: Almost did entirely all of them, geez.

0:20:25 Matt: Yeah. No, it's really bad. Finally, in February 2026, they sent out the report they were supposed to send to Congress, and Democrats criticized it as perfunctory. They had a lot of blanket privilege claims. They had to list out every name that they redacted, and they could publish that to Congress. And then they allowed members of Congress to read unredacted files in a special reading room. I think that still exists from February 9th. And the Federal Register of Justifications still were not published on time. I think maybe some of them still haven't been published. This was one of the main reasons that Pam Dondi was fired, ostensibly, because she was not able to continue to do this. Some of the grand jury materials were released. There were three judges who eventually granted the unsealing. As we've discussed, that is very unusual. The Epstein Files Transparency Act did clearly intend, the judges found, to make public the grand jury materials. So those were eventually released. Recourse here is difficult because there's no direct in the statute for what to do if this is not followed.

0:20:26 Thomas: Wow.

0:21:15 Matt: It's just something they have to do. Obviously, they could hold the Attorney General in contempt of Congress, and they probably should. Someone withstanding, one of the victims, could bring an APA claim, or anyone else, I guess, who's able to do it. Administrative Procedures Act is really the only vehicle that's available. So, the big suit right now is from of MSNBC, DOJ, of course, is disputing her standing as a private citizen who wants to see these records and just entitled to them as a member of the public. Section of the APA allows them, this is the main one that allows any kind of agency action that's been delayed or that's arbitrary and capricious and abuse of discretion, which arguably all of that applies here.

0:21:50 Thomas: Wait, you're saying in the, even though they passed this law, they have to use this other thing for any consequences or or something?

0:21:57 Matt: Yeah, there's no right of action. So there's no civil consequences. There's no criminal consequences. The best way of saying maybe contempt of Congress for not complying with the law?

0:22:05 Thomas: Good is a law then. I don't know, I thought laws did stuff.

0:22:08 Matt: Great question. You got to go to stay and try to do this. I remember, Fang had a partial victory there. They did actually get reviews, some show cause orders on some of the names and emails and things that hadn't come out. The merits appeal is still pending on all of this and the idea is trying to get argument. We'll see how that all goes. They're also trying to go through FOIA because obviously this should be subject to FOIA if these are supposed to be public records anyway.

0:22:28 Matt: Defenders Fund has been working on that suit. Unfortunately, also covers FOIA exemptions, which are much broader than the exemptions that are in the Act, so you might still end up with less, depending on how that goes.

0:22:38 Thomas: Well, But then I also want FOIA on all the conversations around this. Like, did that have to come out?

0:22:43 Matt: That was in the Act. It did say all deliberations, all internal discussions, basically, inside. So that would overcome any claims of privilege that might otherwise apply for FOIA, probably. That's why we do have those internal emails, because otherwise they never would have released them. And Thomas Massie did team up in some of the Maxwell litigation to try to get a special master appointed, there was a finding there that they couldn't do that. The lawmakers can sue, but they couldn't bring this within the particular Maxwell litigation. I'm just kind of going through everything that's touched on all of this since the time that it passed. Congress did at least threaten to bring an inherent contempt, which we talked to, I think, recently about how they have the power of inherent contempt.

It hasn't been used in about 100 years. But they would never put that up to a floor vote. And that hasn't been used, as I said, since 1935. DOJ, the Office of Inspector General, for whatever might be left in the Office of the Inspector General has announced an audit as April, of and we'll see how that goes. No report back on that yet. And GAO has also announced a redaction review. There has been a proposal to pass the Epstein Files Transparency Act 2 because

0:22:49 Thomas: Wow. Okay.

0:23:45 Thomas: Text.

0:23:45 Matt: This needs a sequel apparently. Sequel's never as good,

0:23:48 Thomas: Of which would just say that, did we not make ourselves clear.

0:23:52 Matt: Yeah. Yeah. Right. I remember about the F to two, it would add the ability for state AGs to start to get involved, to get in the party. That has been referred over to judiciary and nothing has happened on it. But I thought it was worth mentioning that there's at least some attempt on the part of Congress, and that's something Democrats can do to pass something a little more teeth so that there can be more enforcement. And of course now there's a demand to Todd Blanche for preservation hold, what they, they called a preservation hold because they know that obviously the new Congress is going to come in and be doing a whole bunch of subpoenas, a whole bunch of requests. They're going to try to get these people in, document production. So as of today, there has been a request now for Blanche to do a preservation hold on whatever might be left. That brings us to the two dueling reports I want to talk about very quickly. I've sent you the House Judiciary Democrats report, which is great reading. Love the title and the title page. Very artfully done here, House Democrats.

0:24:24 Thomas: Oh, Oh, yeah. We got a great cover art here. House Judiciary Staff Report, October 26th. Subject. So it's a redacted, partially redacted. We have certain things in common, Jeffrey. The case against Donald Trump emerging in the Epstein files And DOJ's desperate efforts to to cover it up. Oh, was this the recent one? Okay.

0:24:50 Matt: It's so good. Yeah, from October. Yep, last month.

0:24:56 Thomas: Yeah, we were almost going to cover that. I thought it was like 20 something pages. That's weird. 53 pages, okay. Yeah, this was interesting. They, I feel like this maybe could have gotten more coverage than it did.

0:25:05 Matt: Yeah, man, well, we can do our part here. So I wanted to talk about what's in here. I love an executive summary. I love a good executive summary. And just check out the first paragraph. It's worth a read.

0:25:08 Thomas: Yeah. Sure. A growing body of evidence demonstrates that Donald Trump was an active participant in Jeffrey Epstein's sexual abuse of young women during the mid to late 90s. The Department of Justice and Federal Bureau of the FBI are doing everything they can to keep the American people in the dark about it.

0:25:28 Matt: This is a great bipartisan issue. It really is. It just seems like this is something that a lot of people who call themselves conservatives are actually getting fired up about. But I love that it says straight up that he was an active participant in the Epstein crimes. I think that's really important. So I want to go down to the questions they have for Todd Blanche, because there's some really good stuff here.

They're alleging, I think very credibly, that in the course of his interview with Ghislaine Maxwell, which we covered with Liz Skeen at length, I had a lot of fun going through those tapes. Of course, they were all released to the public. That even in the course of that interview, and even just the fact that he did that interview, that he might have been engaging in criminal obstruction of justice just by doing that.

I think that's a great point to make because he kind of was directing her. And as they point out here, he actually told Maxwell on the record during this interview not to discuss one individual who's known pseudonymously as Jane. And that was somebody whose report to the FBI implicated Donald Trump, according to this,

0:26:18 Matt: And whose claims weren't known to the public. He actually kind of steered are away from that. So just right there, we've got basic abstraction. Who might have known something or telling her not to talk about it.

0:26:18 Thomas: Pattern of obstruction is, of course, not limited to the Maxwell interview and her subsequent favorable treatment in a minimum security camp. The public has rightfully questioned why DOJ has engaged of in of denials, dubious assertions, and secrecy with respect to files, the particularly after so many administration officials promised to release the files during the campaign. The explosive Trump-Epstein connection helps provide an answer to these perplexing questions.

0:26:54 Matt: Yeah, let's read some questions.

0:26:56 Thomas: After publicly and vehemently demanding for years release of the Epstein files and then promising to release them, would Donald Trump and his his handpicked lawyers refused to release them and actively worked to thwart their disclosure.

0:27:07 Matt: Question.

0:27:08 Thomas: That's a good one. Why did DOJ and FBI then abruptly close close the case in July 2025 and declare without offering any explanation or supporting details that DOJ and FBI, quote, did not uncover evidence that could predicate an investigation against uncharged third parties, despite having the names of over 20 alleged co-conspirators from nearly 50 survivors.

0:27:29 Matt: You might remember there there's that memo from the FBI in July, 2025, that basically in a page or two was like, yeah, we're done. We reviewed it. It's nothing else to say here. Yeah.

0:27:36 Thomas: Yeah, The investigation was closed, why did then Deputy Attorney General and former Trump personal attorney Blanche suddenly fly to Florida and interview Maxwell in prison immediately after she was called to testify before the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform? What information was he seeking to find or suppress that would spur him to make such an abrupt, extraordinary, and unprecedented trip?

0:27:57 Matt: I seem to remember having the same questions.

0:27:59 Thomas: I'll seriously go back, folks, in the YouTube, especially we covered that, because that is insane, absolutely insane.

0:28:05 Matt: One of my favorite bits of journalism that we've done. Yeah.

0:28:08 Thomas: Why was Maxwell transferred to a minimum security camp after the interview and showered with deluxe treatment, all in apparent violation of the Bureau of Prisons policy, preventing sex offenders from being sent to that institution? Wow. Boy, this is the, this is the, the, the right is the people who fantasize about doing all kinds of, like, extra, you know, vigilante justice things to pedophiles and stuff, like they're really into it, in a way that's like borders on, that's creepy that they're they're into that stuff, but not now, all of a sudden it's like, no, we're cool, we're cool with it, we don't care that the pedophile is getting good treatment here, that's great. Why did DOJ's obstruction continue even after Congress passed the Epstein Files Transparency Act, and why were Trump and his lawyers so determined to cover up the contents in their possession that they refused to release a huge portion of the documents and heavily redacted the ones that were released, even after Congress had passed EFTA? Why do journalists, survivors, and members of the public keep identifying additional records that DOJ, under Attorney General Blanche's direction, has unlawfully redacted or withheld? Yeah.

0:28:20 Matt: Yeah.

0:28:36 Matt: It's weird. Yeah. Yeah.

0:29:14 Matt: Because they exist. I think that's why they're being identified. And then the next paragraph is well worth the read.

0:29:15 Thomas: Yeah. These questions have a straightforward answer. The Trump administration took these actions because because Donald Trump is personally implicated in Epstein's sex trafficking operation. And these questions lead inescapably to this one. Are Attorney General Blanche and DOJ deliberately covering up further evidence that directly implicates Trump in Epstein's crimes of sex trafficking and abuse of female minors?

0:29:39 Matt: There you go. It appears that they are, as they say. So if this is what we're going to get, I mean, this is the Democrats in October, October 2026. If this is the kind of energy we're getting from Democrats coming into Congress, I'm feeling good about that. This is good stuff. It's a good report. They conclude the report, and Jamie Raskin has been very loud about this recently, asking for a special prosecutor to be appointed. Obviously, that's not going to happen because Todd Blanche would have to do that. Todd Blanche at this point should be recusing himself from even appointing a special prosecutor, the same way that Jeff Sessions did once he was implicated, now that he's been implicated in abstraction, potentially violating the law here in the Transparency Act. They note, of course, they don't expect that a prosecutor will be appointed. They're just saying there should be. That would make sense. For contrast, let's take a look at the Republicans. The Republicans are trying to ride the line here because they want to show that they understand that there was a lot of bad stuff that happened

0:30:25 Thomas: Now, this came out November 10th. Okay.

0:30:27 Matt: So it's not a direct response. There's not a lot of overlap actually between these, but I did want to highlight a few parts here.

0:30:33 Thomas: Talk about a rap battle, you like diss tracks back and forth.

0:30:34 Matt: Yeah, I got to say Dems have better bars on this one. Should mention that the Democrats' reports did not have a lot of new evidence about Trump because they didn't have the subpoena power, of course, skits are not majority. But they did include, before we move on, a new firsthand allegation we didn't have before from a beauty contestant named Beatrice Kuhl, who claimed sexual assault at the Trump Plaza in 1993. she had mentioned that she'd been harassed by Trump before, but she had not mentioned the extent of it.

And I certainly find it to be a believable account, just like all the rest. They note that it comes out to about 25 total allegations against Trump, if you add them all up, including two witnesses who were actually called to testify in Ghislaine Maxwell's criminal trial, who had both implicated Trump as well. So if the government thought they were credible enough to testify against Maxwell, I think that's got to be important.

Just comparing these reports, though, very quickly, this is kind of the bigger picture, talking about how the government failed over decades. They want to draw the attention away, obviously, from Trump failures.

0:30:40 Thomas: Oh

0:31:27 Matt: They want to talk about the non-prosecution agreement, which, of course, as we've covered many times, is an outrage and did not happen under Trump, talk about all the other sort of distracting ancillary stuff. They're just going to complain about, why are Democrats even talking about the president? What's going on here?

0:31:41 Thomas: See Democrats focused all of their efforts on President Trump, not on justice for survivors.

0:31:47 Thomas: Sure. During the committee's investigation, Committee Democrats were obsessed with trying to implicate President Trump and insinuate that he was involved in the crimes of Epstein and Maxwell. Their unfounded witch hunt continued without regard for the interests of survivors, even though the facts gathered during this investigation do not suggest President Trump is implicated in any of Epstein's crimes. President Trump's lack of involvement is confirmed by numerous lines of testimony in interviews or depositions with various individuals. Each time a witness was asked about, oh, this sounds super specific. Each time a witness was asked about President Trump, the witness responded either that they knew nothing about the president's ties to Epstein and Maxwell, or that they vehemently disagreed with any premise that was involved in any way with the horrific crimes committed by Epstein and Maxwell. Oh, there's a footnote.

0:32:31 Matt: Hey, there's a footnote, number 754. Let's see who's being deposed to get that information.

0:32:35 Thomas: Let's see. It says, this is what we think would happen if we asked anybody.

0:32:41 Thomas: Deposition of William P. Barr, former attorney general, et cetera, et cetera.

0:32:46 Matt: He didn't know anything about Trump's crimes. Who would have thought? Alexander Acosta, who the prosecutor is responsible for the plea agreement for

0:32:51 Thomas: Oh yeah. So it's all the interviews of the like people who interviewed people. It's interviews of interviewers.

0:32:57 Matt: Right. But then also Les Wexner, who was close with Epstein, and Bill Clinton, who, of course, was a little too close with Epstein, as we know. But these are not like his inner circle talking about this. These are people that are just around. Bondi, everybody else, they're very much like handpicking what they want from all this. But the fact that they have to go, I mean, think about this in any other administration. If this were happening, do you think there would have been six pages about how the Democrats having to justify that Epstein had no connections with Biden, right?

0:33:20 Thomas: Yeah.

0:33:20 Matt: I mean, this is classic kind of when you know that you're in the majority, but you're wrong, where you're going to try to hit on the really obvious stuff about what was wrong with the investigation. And then, basically you see your guy had nothing to do with it and get out. There is some conspiracy stuff kind of looking into perhaps what was going on, at the SHU and when he was killed or died. Just talking about the institutional failures at the correctional facility was held, but nothing too spectacular here either. Um, but of course they really don't want to talk about the Trump stuff. That's where we're at. I think that Democrats really should push and make a lot of noise about appointing a special counsel.

I mean, it probably doesn't matter how much noise they make about it. Certainly, though, now that they control Congress, they can embarrass Trump by passing a bunch of bills that really force the point on the Epstein-Fells Transparency Act. They can hold as many hearings as they want about Trump's involvement with Epstein, about what people knew and when they knew it. There's lots of ways that they can continue to raise this thing. And it is, as I said, a very popular bipartisan issue that people want to know about for good reason. The mask is slipping just a little on

0:33:34 Thomas: Yeah.

0:34:20 Matt: A whole part of very wealthy life that we'd never got to hear about. I think that it's well worth Democrats making some time for.

0:34:27 Thomas: I would say so. Mean, I'm interested in what else could come out.

0:34:31 Matt: Survivors are also taking the opportunity, which is great, I think, to talk about specific legislative reforms, like the closure of the Voluntary intoxication loophole, which I think you were talking about recently. Also making it much easier for statute of limitations to bring these things. And this is a good opportunity to talk about better public policy as well. So I do appreciate that they're looking out for other survivors and future policy changes we can make. It's a good time to do it. This is just one year in. I'm sure that unfortunately, we're probably going to be coming back and talking about this another year about how much more we know or don't know. But we'll see. I hope the rest comes out soon.

0:35:00 Thomas: Do you have confidence that that could happen? I mean, is there, does anything change with Congress or, I mean, it feels like since this was a bipartisan thing, Congress was already kind of doing okay on this and the DOJ just doesn't comply. So does, does us winning Congress change that?

0:35:21 Matt: Well, they signed off on the inception, but the execution didn't go so well. And Congress can help with the execution by, now they have subpoena power and they can try to get other documents that they haven't seen. They can try to bring in people that they haven't seen to explain to them what happened. Know, potentially there's a lot more of a record you could build here. So there's that at least.

0:35:35 Thomas: All right. Well, we'll definitely keep an eye on that and a happy anniversary.

0:35:39 Matt: All right. See you next year.

0:35:41 Thomas: All right. We'll take a break and then we'll get to the footnote. I'm excited about this. Matt, what's going on with our footnote?

0:35:50 Matt: Well, we've got habeas corpus for elephants. That's what we're talking about today.

0:35:53 Thomas: Habeas porpoise. Oh, no. Okay.

0:35:55 Matt: Actually, in the recording I was listening to, I am absolutely certain that one of the judges said habeas porpoise, which I really appreciated. The Non-Human Rights Project is an interesting legal organization that's been bringing suit around the country for some of the most sentient species that are on the planet, specifically for chimps and elephants especially. Elephants, of course, are largest the land animal on Earth. Round of lawsuits, as far as I know, is the first time that elephants have ever gone to court.

0:35:55 Thomas: Almost. Oh, Okay. Well, we've covered this in the past. We've got Happy the Elephant, we've covered. We had somebody who, uh, was on on that case in front of the Supreme Court, I think.

0:36:28 Matt: Oh, cool. I didn't hear that one. Happy was actually probably the height of the victory for this attempt to get habeas for elephants because it was in the Bronx Zoo in 2018. And the judge did order at that point that the show cause for them to actually proceed with a full habeas hearing, which they did. It was ultimately denied, but they'd had to put it on the record as to why this elephant was being held. But this is a particularly interesting case out of Hawaii that was just argued at the Hawaii Supreme Court. And I have a recording of it here. I don't want to talk about what's going on. These are two elephants that are being held in a pretty small pen. I saw the picture. It's not great. And of course, elephants room need to roam. And they're very, very smart creatures. I'm sure you've heard all the stories about how they'll track down the person that stole their baby and stomp them to death 40 miles away or whatever. They're really good at this stuff. Very smart. Don't forget, they have elaborate morning rituals.

0:36:29 Thomas: Yeah.

0:36:59 Thomas: Should.

0:37:10 Thomas: Get them on the Epstein enforcement.

0:37:12 Matt: That's right. I would trust vengeance to an elephant. That's the way to go. There's a couple of interesting things going on here because it's Hawaii that I thought were interesting legally. First of all, Hawaii, this is unusual, has a state habeas statute. There's reference in the Hawaiian constitution to the idea that they do follow common law, but that they can replace common law, and obviously, as you always can. And habeas corpus, of course, is the oldest. It's the great writ. It's the original common law that we work from, that you can always have the right to bring people who are holding you captive, in this case, in front of a court and ask them why they're doing it. Hawaii did actually codify this in an interesting way that us a different tone. The other interesting element to this came up in the arguments, and I just wanted to play a bit of this. This is from the oil arguments a few days ago. This is Justice McKenna.

0:37:56 Clip: We're going to find necessities of the time, the prevalent role in political theories, intuitions of public policy. So this court has repeatedly recognized that the common law does evolve. So let's talk about the common law and what it informs our common law. Let's talk about our Constitution, the preamble to the Hawaii State Constitution that says that we, the people of Hawaii, grateful for divine guidance, and no, I believe we're the only constitution that uses divine guidance instead of God, or the Almighty. And it says, my faith is our Hawaiian heritage, and we, as an island state, dedicate our efforts to fulfill the philosophy decreed by the state.

0:38:42 Clip: State, we deserve the right to control our destiny, to nurture the integrity of our people and culture, and to preserve the quality of life that we desire. So let's talk about Hawaiian culture. You know, this whole rejection of the world as applicable to animals, it's really based on Western cosmology and the concept that animals are beasts under Genesis that are to be dominated and exist for human beings who are much more superior. And Aristotle also thought that humans were much more superior and had rationality and things that were not recognized by Aristotle. But our Constitution says look at Hawaiian culture. What does Hawaiian culture teach us under the Kōrero Book as to what the relationship is between animals and humans? And plants, starting with color, and animals, Hawaiian culture is that living things are our relatives.

0:40:00 Clip: They are not, we are not dominating beasts. These are our relatives that we must respect. So should that be considered when we consider whether or not to expand the court to at least certain types of evidence? The court may absolutely consider Hawaiian culture. Although that is not the same source of knowledge that any other courts have drawn upon, I would suggest that the majority of humans in Colorado, in Michigan, in New York, have all written their opinions with great reverence for all animals, and they know the magnificence of elephants, and they deeply care for the welfare of those animals.

0:40:49 Clip: But the Court found that it was not appropriate to address animal personhood through Hades. That whether and how we evolve this fundamental issue of animal personhood, of how we align them, currently would be a monumental shift that a common law does not take.

0:41:13 Matt: So that was the attorney for the city of Honolulu, obviously, on the defendant's side. I just thought it was a very interesting exchange here where the judge is saying, because obviously, Hawaii is the only state that was once a monarchy, that was its own kingdom, has its own different set of approach to the law. And obviously, we have any number of indigenous cultures that think think about animals differently from the Western model. The main obvious response to a habeas petition brought by an elephant is that elephants aren't people, habeas is something that has to be brought by a person. That is why the court below obviously found there was no habeas rights. And the plaintiffs, I think, are making a pretty strong case that personhood is a cultural determination. It is whatever we say it is, and that we can grant personhood to chimpanzees or elephants if we want to, and that there's lots of evidence that they're autonomous. And there's another interesting question from one of the justices saying, well, how do you determine which animals get to have this kind of personhood and which don't?

0:42:01 Matt: Do we stop at reptiles? Do what level of sentience do we have to work with? And I thought the answer was very good. He said, this is habeas, and habeas is individualized. So it is up to the court to sort of like bring each case before it. And maybe we can find that elephants do, maybe we can find the chimps do, maybe somebody tries to bring it on behalf of mosquitoes and we find that they don't have it, right?

I mean, it's just, this is how it goes. And yes, I do understand this little pre-slope argument, certainly that it's a really bad idea to open the door this wide potentially to have every animal that might be kept in captivity have a right to come before the court. I mean, obviously, I'd love to see the end of factory farming. Interesting stuff going on throughout this argument. A lot of things I hadn't thought about. It's not an issue I'd encountered before at all.

Just the question of whether the statute is the sole means for habeas, which I never thought about, or whether it can be the common law habeas. Even the Hawaiian indigenous law cuts both ways, because later on in the argument, the Chief Justice mentions that there's a Hawaiian word for kanaka, which is a special word for humans, and that actually works the other way.

0:42:55 Matt: They do distinguish between human rights and other kinds of animal rights, right? So maybe we can't necessarily. But even the idea that you're drawing from Hawaiian culture and using the Hawaiian language, I just thought it was super cool. I've never heard of any of this stuff. It makes me want to learn more about Hawaiian law. Is the third major state court, I think, to consider an elephant habeas argument. And I think elephants are a great choice because they're very smart and they're also very large and they require a lot of room in a way that other animals don't. The other habeas issue here legally, as somebody who's done a lot of habeas work now, usually habeas is I want to be released from custody. And the argument they're making here is we want these elephants to be transferred to an elephant sanctuary, so a different kind of custody.

0:43:31 Matt: And that was actually an argument in the city's favor as well, that this isn't really habeas, you're just asking to change the conditions of custody. So I thought that was an interesting thing as well.

0:43:38 Thomas: Is that Not a normal habeas thing, like is habeas kind of all or nothing, can't be like, oh, we need this, is whatever the conditions are, is that like a different thing?

0:43:46 Matt: It can be, but it's usually conditions in this facility, like if I'm being tortured and there's no other way to review what's going on. But you can't file a habeas to be petitioned, to have yourself transferred to Montana or something, right? You can't take it to be held where you want to be. And that's essentially what this is, is saying we need to send them to an elephant sanctuary where they'll be safe and happy and out running around without the elephants.

They're very social animals, and I understand all that. Mentioned the Happy case in 2018, and that was, as I said, the closest to win because they got a full trial court hearing. And they even specifically said that they had to deny it regrettably, that they felt like there's a real argument here. And the dissents said they specifically would have ruled in favor of the elephants in that case. It's pushing things forward.

There have been a number of cases trying to bring these things on behalf of chimps. I just hadn't seen it for elephants. Incorporation of Hawaiian common law mixed in with this English common law, mixed in with the statutory stuff,

0:44:29 Thomas: Very, very interesting.

0:44:30 Matt: It's all really interesting. Just the way that American law has become just very much like American English has become this pastiche of so many different things. It does seem like they need to develop more of a record just from having listened to this. So it seems like it's possible this could be remanded for further proceedings, which would be a win in itself, they could fully develop the record and get more scientific evidence about the autonomy of elephants and which animals might be autonomous and which aren't. I do see the argument as to if you can say that this is an autonomous being that not just fully ascension but has its own sort of rich interior life, that this kind of confinement is torture, and it's harmful, and we need to look at it. And as important as it is to be able to see elephants in zoos, there are other places we could see them, so I get that.

0:45:06 Thomas: I don't think there's like an obvious answer. You know, it's like the legal realism thing where so much room when you're talking about the common law and the Hawaiian law and all this stuff together. Other, or it's like I don't think there's any reason why this law would be so predetermined logically that you couldn't possibly do this. You know, there's so much room for interpretation and all that.

0:45:14 Matt: Yeah, for personhood. I mean, we're extending personhood to fetuses, right? I don't consider those to be people, personally. Why not extend it to elephants? Why not consider extending it to something that is so much more intelligent than a fetus.

0:45:35 Thomas: All right, well, fun footnote, an animal related, uh, yeah, hoof note. No, I don't know, what are they, what are they, elephants had their feet? I don't know, yeah, trunk, I feel like they don't have feet, but they don't have hooves, I, there needs to be some term for that. You know, nothing. I, yeah, I don't know.

0:45:43 Matt: Chalk note.

0:45:52 Thomas: I don't know what it is. Yeah. Yeah. It's probably a good idea.

0:45:52 Matt: No, I feet personally, but All

0:45:57 Thomas: All right. Well, thanks so much, Matt, for the breakdown. Thanks everyone for listening. We'll see you on Monday.

0:46:02 Matt: Right. Thanks.

0:46:06 Clip: This has been Opening Arguments, produced by Thomas and Lydia Smith, with editing help from Peter Baird. The intro is by Thomas Smith. This outro is by Matt Cameron. Support the show at patreon.com/law. Contact us through Patreon or openarguments@gmail.com. Make sure to follow our blue sky, at OpenArgs. But most of all, please share the show. Thanks for listening.

0:46:38 Thomas: How else will I know whether I like something or not

0:46:43 Matt: Think I remember that either.

0:46:44 Thomas: Did you have me read it? Habeas porpoise. Oh, no.