The Serious Pod Network

Thomas and Lydia
Serious Inquiries Only

AS153: An Atheist In A Catholic Church

..plus Portable Atheist, kind of. You'll see. This weekend I had the unique experience of attending a Catholic wedding. It has been a while since I've stepped foot in a Catholic Church and it certainly was fascinating. Also, we were set to do Portable Atheist but the selection was very short and not too amenable …

Follow Serious Inquiries Only:

Transcript

This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors — the audio is the record.

0:00:31 Thomas: Hello and welcome to Atheistically Speaking. This is episode 153, and I am your host, Thomas Smith. Wow, do I have a lot of stuff to tell you guys. This going to be fun. At some point I might hit that documentary music, but maybe not for now. I don't know, it's hard to say. When the whole thing becomes like sort of loosely a documentary, I never know when to quite hit it. Well, I'll first start before that with, I was very pleasantly surprised to get an email the other day that read something like Matt Dillahunty has become a patron of the show. You know, it was the Patreon email. And at first I thought you guys might remember that I've had some people using some silly names on Patreon lately.

0:01:17 Thomas: And I thought, oh, maybe someone just, you know, plug that in as a joke because it would be weird for Matt Dillahunty to become a patron of my show. But so I clicked on the email and it takes you to the profile and it said Matt Dillahunty is creating videos, you knows, $3,200 a video or whatever he's at because he is kind of a rock star. And I just thought, okay, never mind. That's Matt Dillahunty. That is very odd. And then I saw that he sent me a message on Patreon and it was, it was really cool. He, I guess it turns out he just today debated Blake Junta, who old listeners and not age old, but as in listeners who have listened the entire time will remember I've had Blake on.

0:02:04 Thomas: I think I've had him on twice, but I don't remember. I, in any case, I actually had already reached out to Blake on Twitter recently, maybe a month ago, because he had made an argument that I thought was really interesting in a kind of a dumb way. But anyway, I think Blake is really smart and I like debating with him because he sticks to his guns and he's very nice, very nice guy. So I had asked him on, but anyway, unrelated to that, I guess Matt Dillahunty had just was scheduled for a debate debate with Blake, like I said, and someone, some angel, I don't know who this person is, someone pointed Matt to my podcast that I did with Blake. And so Matt sent me, Matt Dillahunty sent me a message saying, hey, someone, yeah, what I just said, he's debating Blake.

0:02:56 Thomas: And they said, "Someone pointed me to your episodes with Blake, and they were helpful in my preparations for the debate. So I thought I'd add you to the list of shows I support." And so I think what also has happened is that Matt has gotten to a success point in his atheism career where he's giving back, because, I mean, I don't think he listens to the show or anything, of course. I mean, I kind of doubt he listens to really any shows. I mean, he's a big-time content producer, and oftentimes it seems like those people don't, – they aren't the kind of people who are sitting around listening to podcasts like mine, basically. But, uh, but at any rate, it doesn't matter, because he was honest and he said, "Oh, I found this part helpful."

0:03:42 Thomas: And so I'm going to support your show. And I thought that was really nice. He certainly didn't have to, he really didn't have to, I mean, he could have listened to the episodes and I never would have known. And, uh, that would have been that, but no, I, I, I commend Matt Dillahunty. I, It's very, very nice of him to support the show. And I just thought that it was a funny story and I wanted to tell you guys because that doesn't happen every day.

So, oh, and then also the other important thing is he said he would come on the show at some point. I asked him if he wanted to do a sort of a post-mortem on the debate, but he said he does his own on his video on his YouTube channel, so it might be a little redundant, but he also said he might do it, so I don't know. We'll see.

The debate was live streamed but I wasn't able to see it because of personal stuff I had to do, but which I will get to. Um, but I'm going to see if the entire video will be up and then I can link it out to everybody, but, uh, and then we can talk about it.

0:04:42 Thomas: So we'll see. But at any rate, I think I can get Matt to come on the show at a later date, and that'll be really fun, 'cause he's a very interesting guy. So that, that'll be awesome. So there you go. That was, it made my day, to be honest. And, um, you know, he's only a $1 supporter, supporter. He's not like my awesome patrons who are, you know, two, three, four, five dollar supporters, or even ten dollars. Yeah. So he's not in, my he's out of my top list of patrons or anything, like like other patrons who I should thank later in the week. But, you know, every little bit helps. So that was that. So maybe I'll hit that music there.

0:05:28 Thomas: There it went. It's it's done now. So this is now officially commentary land. Well, OK, so here's what happened. I'm I'm going to explain. I had planned to do Portable Atheist this week or at least, you know, like one episode this week or whatever it would end up being. And that was my whole plan. And I was so busy that I, of course, left it to a little late. And then I turned to the Portable Atheist and I find the reading is kind of, I mean, I don't want to speak negatively about it. I think it has its function, but it was simply a passage about Hume's death and that someone kind of recorded a conversation with him, recorded on paper, of course, this is the 1700s, so there's really not a lot of substance there, but that's fortunate because I have to tell you, I just have to tellyou about the Catholic wedding I went to.

0:06:22 Thomas: I think it is a very worthwhile thing to say, to talk about, and it's very worthwhile while commentary material. So it totally works. I'm still going to do The Portable Atheist, but it wasn't going to, it would have been, well, it's going to be very short. So I figured this will be a good way to make up for that sort of shortfall in The Portable Atheist.

And then we'll see, I might just go to the next one immediately so that we actually get a good Portable Atheist segment. So that's, that's what's going on. So this wedding I went to, I just want to first say I really don't mean any disrespect to the participants before I talk about this. I don't know them really personally. They were friends of my wife's, and I know that they will never, ever, ever hear this, but that's not the point. Just cosmically for no reason. I just want to express congratulations to them. And I was very respectful, and I went through it, but it was very Catholic.

It was in a Catholic church, and that is a very surreal experience for an atheist like myself who, I mean, I've been to a Catholic wedding before, and I'm familiar with it, but it's been a number of years, so it's always an interesting refresher to kind of go in and see what, you know, what's going on. I don't know if it matters. I'll include it just merely for informational purposes. But it was an Asian wedding, pretty much entirely Asian. I was, we were one of the very few groups of white people there.

0:07:55 Thomas: I say group, couples, I don't know, whatever. I couldn't think of a clean way to say that. We were part of the few non-Asian people there, and that's interesting. It would be interesting to look at the history of Christianity and Asian culture, because Christianity is such a growing thing in Asia and Asian culture. And I mean, it's kind of unfortunate because I wish, I wish it weren't growing so rapidly in any community, just because of obviously how old-fashioned and kind of, frankly, absurd the ideas are, but it was interesting. It seems, it's very odd. It's also interesting to look at how this meme, the meme of Christianity, the meme of Jesus and his sacrifice and all that, it's interesting that that meme can cross cultures so easily.

0:08:50 Thomas: I mean, it can, it, it's, here's this guy who was a Jew. He was not Asian. He was not, you know, he was not white really by any, he wasn't yet. And he was not black yet. Those are all communities and cultures of people that can pick up on the meme. The meme can kind of take hold of those cultures. And, and it's it's such a, I think it's a very fit meme. Um, as I've mentioned before, it's Christianity is very, uh, evolved to survive and it constantly has to evolve to survive because that's how memes work. And that's why it changes as, as society changes, as secular society, uh, decides something, usually Christianity, mainstream Christianity soon follows because it needs to survive.

0:09:41 Thomas: And people, including Christians, usually want to live mostly in harmony with the rest of the world, but obviously there's exceptions to that, but anyway, that was an interesting part of it, to see, uh, an Asian priest, um, because it's funny that there, there can't be female priests, um, but there can't be, and the reasoning in Catholicism is something like they have to be men to know the, well, you know, let's take advantage of the internet. I've looked it up, up here, and I found a selection that'll be interesting, actually, and this will be a good thing to talk about. This is on catholiceducation.org. Why doesn't the church allow women to be priests? I know plenty of women who could give a more moving homily and be more understanding in the confessional.

0:10:28 Thomas: There aren't many issues, and thus is the answer, there aren't any issues within apologetics that require as much sensitivity as this one. In a culture where opening the door for a woman can be seen as an act of misogyny. It's no surprise that male-only ordination strikes some as sexist on the church's behalf. Yeah, in the male- only, or sorry, opening the door for a woman being seen as the act of Misogyny, it's telling that they emphasize that as an example, as though that's like the only thing that's happening. There's, the only Misogyna is that kind, like a fake kind. There is no actual Misogyne that we need to deal with. Anyway, Anyway, it can't be denied that there are women who could be more moving orators than some priests and provide more consolation within the confessional.

0:11:16 Thomas: Well, thank, well, hey, women listeners, you'll really need to thank Catholics for the vote of confidence there. Look, it cannot be denied there might be one or two women out there who could more moving orators that some of the priests. I don't know why, just the way they phrase it is so funny. But the debate over ordination is not over who could be a better priest, but who could be a priest at all, because that's somehow a different question. If so, if a woman's abilities are not in question, what's keeping the church from ordaining her? For one, it should be noticed that Jesus did not ordain any women.

He selected all of his apostles, and none were women. See, none were Asian men. None were black men. None, were, you know, like that's, that's what's interesting, that's why I thought of doing this, because I, I knew the reasoning would kind of apply, because the reasoning's so bad it would kind of imply to Asian men, uh, which is why it's kind of interesting to see an Asian man in all the Catholic priest garb. It's like, huh, so women can't do it, but Asian men can, despite the fact that Jesus never had. Anyway, I, the whole thing is just obviously absurd all the way around, bound.

But this is kind of funny. I want to read the rest of this. There's only a couple paragraphs. Some say that he was bound by the cultural norms of his era to suppress the roles of women, but no one has been able to prove that this was his motive.

0:12:46 Thomas: I just love that. It's such a perfect indicator of how religious reasoning can work sometimes. So, some say he was bounded by the cultural norms, but no one has been able to prove. Why would you need to prove that was his motive? Wouldn't you just need to say, well, it's possible he was motivated by, you know, the sort of the sexist norms of the time, and, uh, you know, but the, the reason it's important for him, to for whoever wrote this, to say that they haven't, no one's been able to prove that this was Jesus's motive, is because, because when you take Jesus to be perfect, and, you know, Jesus to be God, like his word is the word of God, then you have to like pretend to be all scientific about what he said and did, like every, every, the, all the minutia of what he said, and even things that I bet the authors of the Bible didn't even think of.

0:13:40 Thomas: Everything, just every action described of Jesus, you have to assume like, okay, that's in there for a reason because it's God's perfect book, right? Everything he did is in there for a reason, and so if he didn't choose a woman as any of his apostles, then definitely he meant to do that, and like that was a very conscious thing, and he meant us to keep women from being priests. Furthermore, this accuses Jesus of sexism, and it paints an inaccurate portrait of Christ who had no qualms about shattering the cultural norms regarding interaction with women. Oh yeah, he just shattered those norms. The idea of priestesses was not unknown to him since it was a common and practice in religions of his time and culture, though not Judaism. If Jesus had wanted women as priestesses, he would have had an ideal candidate in Mary.

0:14:28 Thomas: Here was a woman who could have spoken the words of consecration literally, this is my body, this is my blood. Yeah. There were other roles that Christ had in mind for women, for example, cleaning and baking. No. For example, they played a key role in the spread of the gospel, being the first to spread the news of the risen Christ. They were the, well, okay. I hope, again, female listeners, I'm sure you are just thrilled at this. You've been honored by being allegedly the same gender as some people who discovered the tomb. So, rest assured, your rights are just as equal as men because that that thing. It's so dumb.

0:15:14 Thomas: They were also allowed to pray and prophesy, I guess, in church, but they were not to assume the function of teaching in the Christian assembly. That was restricted to the clergy. Two thousand years later, no one, including the Pope, has the authority to change the designs of the church that Christ instituted, except all the times where I'm guessing the Pope has changed the designs. Specifically, the church is unable to change the substance of the sacrament. For example, a person cannot be baptized in wine, nor may any substance other than the bread be used for the consecration at Mass. Ooh, well, I'll get to that later. If invalid matter is used, then the sacrament does not take place. Likewise, since the priest acts in the person of Christ, the church has no authority to confer the sacraments on those who are unable to represent the male Jesus Christ.

0:16:04 Thomas: Now, but it's okay if he's Asian. Somehow that's okay. So, this is so scientific, guys. This is, I really want to, I wish I could, you know, get a panel of Catholics, Catholic scientists who I'm sure studied exactly what degree of likeness to Jesus Christ you have to be in order to perform the sacrament of mass and the consecration or whatever. I'm sure they did all kinds of tests, you know. Do you have to be the same height as Jesus, roughly speaking? I mean, what's more, what's more similar to Jesus, a seven foot two male, or a female who's exactly Jesus's height and like weighs the same as Jesus?

0:16:52 Thomas: What's More? You know, the Catholics are very considered people, and I'm sure they must have answers for all this. I mean, they've done studies. They've, uh, done like test, um, consecrations of the, the bread and the wine with different people and like then tested the wafers to see like, Hmm, what percentage of Jesus is this? You know, like, cause seriously, what, what kind of an idiotic rule is that they, they, you have to be able to represent the male Jesus Christ. Well, I don't get it. Like the bread in the wine become Jesus, right? Can't you just get someone to do whatever voodoo, you know, causes that? It has to be a man to do that for some reason? That doesn't make any sense. Sorry, I know. This just in, guys.

0:17:38 Thomas: Catholicism doesn't make any sense. Sorry for getting sidetracked here, but I just saw that and I wanted to give you guys some info on why women can't be priests, and that was too funny to pass up. So yes, I think the same logic applies. I think if there can't be female priests, there shouldn't be any priests that are any race other than what Jesus was. It's the same logic, right? And they should be roughly the same height and they should have the same hairstyle. They should just look like Jesus. Look, I'm not going to believe this bread and wine is the body of Jesus unless there's like an actual Jesus impersonator. And I'm not talking about white Jesus. I'm not talking about, you know, 21st or 20th century, like white male model Jesus that I love seeing pictures of. It's so hilarious when he's like, he's doing like blue steel in the, in the pictures that people make of Jesus, but no, I want someone who looked, I want that documentary they did where they tried to, you know, recreate what Jesus would have actually looked like.

0:18:38 Thomas: I need that, like someone who looks just like that. Otherwise, it doesn't, by your logic or dumb religion, could you just have someone say the words and say, here, this is the body of Christ, and then it's fine. Does it matter that they have a vagina? Does that somehow stop the magic? There are very very specific rules to this magic. Anyway, whatever. I couldn't resist having a little fun at Catholicism's expense because I had to sit through a two-hour Catholic wedding ceremony. So you'll forgive me for being a little punchy with this stuff. But yeah, so anyway, the mask goes on. There was a picture, I almost would post it. I don't know if it would matter if I posted it. It. There was a picture of a saint in kind of the main, I don't know what you would call it, the main backdrop for the, I almost said theater. It kind of is a theater, like it's a big production. But anyway, the main background for the church was this saint, and I have the picture St. Lawrence, and the picture, the stained glass window, it was Donald Trump. Really odd.

0:19:52 Thomas: Maybe I don't know where I can post that. But anyway, it's not that funny, but it's a little funny. He looks a lot like Donald Trump. And so I was distracted by that. But what I wanted to talk about with this Catholic wedding is, again, with meaning no disrespect to the specific people involved because they just were doing the ceremony. That's a lot of my takeaway was what people get out of the ceremony, these rituals and these all these little rituals. It's so interesting to see them. What people get out of them is they get a feeling, I'm fairly certain about this, they get a feel of this is what should be happening. This is, we have to do it this way. And if we do it, this very way, like that's the emotion I kind of feel like fuels a lot of religion and a lot of religious belief.

0:20:41 Thomas: It's like, no, we, we go up to the, you know, whatever the main, there's probably some church term for it. I don't know. When you go up to the stage to go speak, they have to bow before anyone goes up. There's a bunch of bowing. It was very interesting.

And it's like all these little things, just probably if you could take a count, if you could post it in a highlights magazine, I don't know if that's a reference anyone gets, where it's a picture and it's count all the weird little rituals and what they are. I bet there would be hundreds of them that I didn't even realize. But there's all these little things. And another thing I find funny is that everything has to be symmetrical. Like the church itself, The backdrop and where all the candles were and where like the sort of just fixtures and stuff, some drapes, just random crap that I don't know if it has a specific function or not, but it all has to be very symmetrical to make. It's so interesting. It's interesting because it's like when you're a little kid and you're drawing something, you kind of make these designs and you want everything.

I know when I was a kid anyway, I won't speak for anyone else, I do remember wanting things to be symmetrical, like any drawing or anything I did, and it always bothered me when I was trying to fold some paper or do some weird thing and I couldn't make it symmetrical. It's weird little instincts like that that we have that are so interesting because somehow, somehow, all of it serves some evolutionary purpose.

0:22:15 Thomas: Others have written about that. And yet, you can see that you can really, if you go to church with a keen eye, you can see them all take hold. It's so interesting. Like, and one thing that I wanted to bring up is the use of technology now makes it so funny. It's a, it's so, what's the word, out of time. There's a word for that. I believe it's anachronistic. That would be the word, because this wedding was a media circus.

This is a separate, aside from the Catholic part, just real quick, everybody, separate side note, weddings these days, it was like it was almost like a press conference. And, you know, the typical footage you see where someone's trying or maybe a politician or somebody, some criminals walking out of a court of law and all the reporters like, oh, Mr. this or something. What a question. Everybody's asking questions. It's kind of like that. There's a bunch of cameras just everywhere. Like it's so funny that we can't do anything without getting a million pictures of it. Now it is very interesting. Now I will say that I filmed our wedding, but that was it. We had one photographer in a very kind of, well, it was smaller, so it was It was easier for the photographer to not really interfere with anything. And we filmed it, but that's it.

This wedding, it was like, I think it was four photographers who are in this church. And that's the funny thing about it. We're in a church, we're in an holy place where everything's supposed to be just right. You know, like all the candles are supposed to be just, just right and symmetrical and blah, blah, blah.

0:23:55 Thomas: Meanwhile, there's a bunch of cameras flashing, like people walking photographers, you know, kind of surrounding the party as they walk down the aisles and like, ooh, I'm going to get a close-up of when the they first, you know, come toward the priest, and there's some sort of weird salutation going on with the, you know, that it's, it's so funny to see the, the combination, the, the juxtaposition is probably the appropriate word, of those two things of all this old stuff. And that's, that's another thing I thought, I had everything that's holy is old. There's no such such thing as like, now we will take the holy consecrated iPhone and, you know, do something with it, or this app that I have to do. It's all the holy stuff is old. And I think there's more to that than simply, oh, the religion is old. I think there's a little more to it than that.

0:24:49 Thomas: Now, there, I guess it's possible. And you have those religions that developed like the cargo cults, like John Froome, or whatever kind of of things where, if anyone doesn't know, they're, they're sort of, uh, Africa, I think it's somewhere in Africa, there are these cults that developed that worshipped the people who came in plane airplanes, um, and they sort of formed a religion around them, like they were gods, which, man, it makes a lot of sense when you think about it. I mean, if you were sort of a, I hope it's not offensive to say, like a primitive people, people who don't have very much technology or whatever, and some people, people come in these flying contraptions out of the air, you know, like miraculously out of the sky, come in, these flying machines to, you know, give you supplies or something, or, or maybe I don't know what they were doing there.

0:25:40 Thomas: There's different, different ones, but, uh, it makes sense that you would worship them. And what made me think of this is in those cargo cults, they do worship like, um, I guess symbols that love like airplanes or like landing strips, you know? So I guess a big part of it is the fact that the religion took place when it did. But I also think there's just in general, we have some reverence that I think is, I want to say a percentage of it is independent of the fact that the religion took place in a certain time or was founded in a certain time, rather. And it's like we view old things as holy, would be kind of a circular way of putting it. We view them as as as sacred in some ways, you know, like old books or old, you know, old corpses in old tombs.

0:26:31 Thomas: You know, they're all, they're sort of, it's, it's just so funny that there was that juxtaposition of here's this person wearing this, this priest, whatever outfit, I don't know what you would call it, robes and stuff. And and the people who are helping were wearing all this, this appropriate church appropriate stuff, stuff. And then, oh, meanwhile, here's the photographer, one of whom looked like he was probably gay and had some piercings and was taking pictures. And it just was hilarious to me that you have the one side that's all this holy stuff that these rituals have to be just right. We got to walk down the aisle just right, we got to say the right thing, we gotta do these prayers just so, because that's how it has to be done. And meanwhile, it's, well, whatever you need to do to capture it media-wise. I thought it was funny.

0:27:17 Thomas: But there's something I want to say that I don't want to take away from anyone else's wedding, and I don't want to at all say that my wedding was perfect, not that any of you know what happened during it. It was very imperfect. And honestly, to me, that kind of made it perfect. But I understand other people might want something a little more rigid. See, that was the dangerous part and why I found it interesting to talk about my wedding, is we did everything ourselves, ourselves. And we did the ceremony ourselves and boy, was it rocky. Like there's, there's a reason why churches are good at what they do in a lot of ways, because they form all these little rituals and they make things seem important. They're very, very good at making things seem important and seem like they need to be done a certain way. And when Lydia and I did our wedding, we didn't have that.

0:28:05 Thomas: We made up our ceremony and, and it was, I gave a very long, uh, heartfelt speech about meeting Lydia, and I told a story, a long story that no one had ever heard all of, and I, it was very important to me to tell that because it just said so many things about our relationship and everything, and I had, a honestly I knew I wanted to do that long before I knew anything else about the wedding, I knew I wanted to make a nice heartfelt speech, and it was very, again, I'm not saying there's one right way to do a wedding or anything at all, and and I think anyone just do what feels right for you, for sure. But I will say that one quality, one general quality that I think makes more sense for a wedding in this day and age, is do something that's personal, you know, because it's so sad that, I mean, I understand for Catholics, it's important for them to do a Catholic wedding and to do all these ceremonies.

0:28:59 Thomas: But for me, as an atheist, when I see this, it just feels so robotic, you know, it feels insincere. It doesn't feel customized to them. It's just like, oh, okay, here's a bunch of very rigid stuff. Here's another thing that happened. Whenever someone messed up, because people mess up. I mean, inevitably, there was some awkwardness with microphones. The groom was very quiet. He wouldn't speak up. So there's awkwardness there. There was people, the piano, the keyboard player were kind of messed up quite a bit, which I thought was, I mean, it's unfortunate, but you know, what, what are you going to do? And when that stuff happens at a wedding, like say mine, where it's informal, it'S from the heart, whatever. It's like, ah, who cares?

0:29:44 Thomas: Whatever. We're doing a little ceremony. Who cares? When it happens in the context of, okay, all this religious stuff has to be just right. It's all going to be exactly. So when it happens, you're like, oh my God. Oh, that messed up. Oh, it's going to ruin it. You know? And it was kind of unfortunate. And I mean, the wedding, all in all, it's a wedding. It went fine. It's not a big deal if little things go wrong. But I think it's bigger deal when you make everything so sacred, you know, when you make it so everything has to be just right. Little human mistakes, which happen, become a bigger deal. And maybe that's the goal of these rituals. It's to try to transcend humanity in some way and to try to be perfect. And that's why they do all these little things just so. And I found it really off-putting myself, but I got through it.

0:30:32 Thomas: So that's far longer than I expected to talk about that, but I thought it was so entertaining and interesting, and just a lot of things to go into this church and just to see Catholics and what they believe. Oh, sorry, I can't resist, I have to go on further. The guy was so... the priest talked a lot about how God was giving a sacrament today, and like a wedding, a marriage is not real without God's love, he said.

It was really funny, Lydia and I exchanged lots of glances over the course of the ceremony because apparently we're not really married and we don't really know anything about love because we don't have God's love and we don't love God, so, and this was seemed to me to be quite a progressive church as far as Catholic churches go, again, they're, they're not, not very progressive, But it was so funny that he just flat out said, like, you don't have, it's not a real marriage without God's endorsement, you know, and God is coming down to bless this. And then what I thought was funny, my first thought was, well, if, if there's a divorce, doesn't, shouldn't the church have to issue a correction?

They really should have to retract some statements like, hey, all right, everyone, there was a divorce and a lot of you may remember, there's probably video footage of the original marriage in which time the priest was saying, well, God hereby endorses this marriage and he's given you a sacrament and it's totally going to be a real marriage because you have God's love, all that. I think the church should have to issue a correction, be like, all right, we were wrong about that one. I guess God wasn't actually blessing that marriage or maybe God did bless the marriage and all that, but you know, is there any liability there?

0:32:16 Thomas: There. Could there ever be a lawsuit where it's like, hey, the priest, he messed up the ritual. He didn't do the communion just right, or he didn't doing this just right. And, you know, that's what ruined our marriage because we didn't receive the sacrament. You know, it's funny how people are so strict in some ways, but they don't really follow the logical conclusion of it. You know, if the marriage doesn't work out, well, it is just the people just, you they messed up. It's not the fact that God gave his sacrament or didn't, or the priest didn't do this just right. But if the priest doing that just right has no effect on the marriage, has no impact on whether or not the sacrament is holy or whatever, then why do it? Either that has some responsibility that has Some impact on the marriage or it doesn't.

0:33:05 Thomas: And if it does, well, then I think the priest should be liable and should have to issue a statement whenever there's a divorce, you know? Maybe that's why divorce was banned originally and why it took a while for Catholics to recognize divorce. But okay, there's more I could say, but man, I can't believe how long I can go on. But oh, it is so interesting.

0:33:39 Thomas: All right, now to fulfill the requirements of the Portable Atheist segment that I've been doing, I'm going to read the part that was by Christopher Hitchens, which says, okay, so the chapter is called An Account of My Last Interview with David Hume, Esquire. And it is a little interesting. This biographer, I think he was, this author of some kind, spent some time with David Hume before he died. Now, I've already covered David Hume pretty extensively in the last Portable Atheist episodes.

Go and check them out if you haven't listened. And we talked about Of Miracles, and it was very fascinating, to me at least. And so one part of David Hume's life that was interesting is that he was diagnosed with cancer, he died pretty quickly, but he knew he was going to die, so he was able to, if you remember, he was able to kind of prepare all his more, you know, heathen material, more his more atheist material, prepare it for a posthumous release, but also he was able to sit down, or rather this Boswell guy was able to sit down with him. Now I'll read the intro by Hitchens. I always want to do that at the very least. James Boswell was reluctant to believe in Hume's stoicism, which is what helps lend to the account its authenticity. Hume died just as the American Revolution, which he had foreseen and supported, was breaking out. His own views had a marked effect on many of those who signed the the Declaration of Independence. That's pretty cool. Oh, wow, this takes place on the Sunday forenoon.

0:35:13 Thomas: I'm reading the first line, the 7th of July, 1776. Wow, that is so interesting. I actually missed that the first time around and I don't tune out the dates. But yeah, right around the revolution. So unfortunately, there's not really the reading is just this guy asks David but Hume like, so do you really not believe there's an afterlife? And Hume says, nah, where would you fit everybody? And I can't tell if the guy isn't sure if Hume is joking or not. And I also am not, I imagine he's joking because it's not, well, I don't think he's fully joking, but I think Hume had an argument about immaterial souls and all that. But maybe this was a bit of a kind of a humorous reference to that argument. But yeah, that's really all there is to it.

0:36:00 Thomas: It's, It's not very long, and it's just a segment that talks about how he, there's some weird specifics, and then they talk about like, oh, remember this guy, remember this guy. And it's like, yeah, it's not really, honestly, it doesn't make for terribly interesting summarization on my podcast. I usually like to have an argument to summarize or, you know, to go through the premises of an argument and stuff like that. But there really wasn't much here. So that's why I spent the the time talking about the Catholic wedding I went to. So yeah, not much to summarize, but in the end, basically, I will say that Hitchens always referenced the fact that there have been fake deathbed conversions for, you know, God knows how long.

0:36:45 Thomas: Many famous atheists also have a famous fake deathbed conversion that Christians or, well, I guess could be, it doesn't have to be Christianity. I'm sure it's happened in other cultures, other religions, but Christianity is the one I know of where people fake like the person converted. They repented. Think Kevin Sorbo in, is that his name? In God's Not Dead, which I still haven't watched, but I've heard about.

0:37:12 Thomas: They repent last minute. They knew all along that God was real. And when they die, they finally see. And to me, how unimpressive are these? They are colossally unimpressive. I mean, if something is true, it should be true for all points in your life, or it should be a truth that you can equally access through arguments at all points of your life or at least most, maybe not when you're little and your faculties are not all there, or maybe not when your old, which is another argument, or dying and your faculty's aren't there. But a good argument or a position that the afterlife exists or doesn't should be accessible to me right now. A healthy, I think healthy person, unless you guys know something I don't, um, a healthy person.

0:38:00 Thomas: And it's really unimpressive to me that, oh, once you're dying and all crazy things are going on in your mind because you're lying. I mean, the dying is one of the, you know, one of the more significant things you do in life. It's a pretty, you know, maybe the most significant thing you do. Uh, it's, it's, it's gotta be very interesting thing on your brain. You've got to be thinking about everything, you know, regrets or things you wish you did, that sort of thing. Your brain's got to go on haywire with the knowledge that you're going to die. That's got be a very traumatic, it doesn't have to be, I suppose, but I would assume a lot of time it's going to be very traumatic and chaotic experience for your mind, not to mention if you're dying of something that actually addles your mind, that actually, actually causes your mind to sort of go.

0:38:52 Thomas: For all these reasons, it's really, really unimpressive if you tell me that there was some atheist that, oh, when he died, he actually, even if it were true, when He died, He actually said He believed and He accepted Jesus Christ as His Savior. It's like, okay, well, then He was losing His mind. It is not impressive to me. And it is funny because I think religious people think that atheists think that way, that like, oh, when push comes to shove, and I've seen it portrayed in movies, and actually there's a play I know of a musical that there's an atheist that's portrayed in this way, and it bugs me because I kind of like the musical. It's called See What I Want to See, in case anyone's interested. It's very interesting, but weird. Anyway, oftentimes religious people are portrayed as having, or sorry, go back, atheists are are portrayed as when it comes down to it, when the rubber hits the road, they don't actually mean it, you know, and it's such an insulting thing.

0:39:50 Thomas: Yeah, yeah, I mean it. I mean, I don't believe in God. If I'm dying, even if I wanted to say, well, I hope, I Hope that I'm wrong. And there's some weird miraculous afterlife, but I don't, I really don't. That's like me saying, I hope I win the lottery. I hope, look, it's even more improbable than that, but we'll go with that. That. If when I'm dying, or to go with the analogy, I'm really poor, and I say, you know, I hope I win the lottery. That does not equal, oh, Thomas believes he's going to win the lottery. No. If I say when I'm dying, if I say well, loved ones, I don't believe this at all, but you know wouldn't be nice if somehow there were some miraculous afterlife where we all could talk again. Yeah, it'd be cool. I don't know. I mean, I assume if there's some entity that were powerful enough to create an afterlife, they would make it a good afterlife.

0:40:41 Thomas: It wouldn't be like lame where you just worship them. It'd probably be cool. I don't think it would be a celestial North Korea. I never really, honestly, I never Really accepted that Hitchens argument. I think you could conceive of an afterlife that would be perfect and would be everything you'd want. But that's a pipe dream. It's it's not really going to happen. And no amount of stress that's caused by imminent death is going to make that a valid argument. So with that said, I guess I'll just say that that was the Portable Atheist chapter, whatever it was, where someone was with David Hume as he was, not as he died, but as he was dying, and I think he died a few days after the exchange. And those are my thoughts, and that's my brief summary, and the next Portable Atheist chapter I looked ahead this time, so I'll know, does look to be very interesting.

0:41:31 Thomas: It's an argument against deism, which I'm very excited to read about because I've always said that I think deism is somewhat tenable as a position, somewhat. Don't run away with that. Don't run wild with that. But at least it's something that I don't spend a whole lot of time worrying about trying trying to convince deists that they're wrong. But this next chapter is Percy Shelley, why deism is wrong. So I'm very, very excited for that. Okay, well, thank you guys, as always, for joining me. Thank you for listening. I was very excited to tell you these things, and I hope that it made for an interesting listen. And if you enjoy my show, please support me in a number of ways. You can always go to patreon.com/atheist, become a patron.

0:42:18 Thomas: You can always go give me a review on iTunes, that's a very nice thing to do. You could give me a review on Stitcher if you wanted. You could go to atheisticallyspeaking.com when you want to buy something from Amazon, click through the banner, and that's all you have to do. It's free, and it will give me tiny, tiny little percentage, and it's a nice little donation, or just, you know, comment on something. There's all kinds of free ways you can support the show and show your appreciation, appreciation. And for those who show their appreciation in not free ways, I really, really, really am grateful. Uh, you, you just absolutely inspire me and you make the show continue. So thank you so much for listening and I will see you next episode.