Serious Inquiries Only
AS114: Hate Speech Laws, with Michael
Previous guest and awesome Patron Michael, AKA Bangs Naughty Bits, joins me to talk about free speech. In particular, we're discussing a very interesting article which I read aloud on the show: http://reason.com/archives/2015/02/18/after-copenhagen-the-myth-of-civilized-c Are hate speech laws on the same spectrum as shooting people for drawing Mohammed? That is the allegation of the author, and it's …
Transcript
This transcript was generated automatically and may contain errors — the audio is the record.
0:00:31 Thomas: Hello, and welcome to episode 114, I think it is, of Atheistically Speaking, with your host, Thomas Smith, and with a special guest, you may know him as Bangs Naughty Bits, Michael, how you doing? Michael's returning to the show, you've been on at least once on the prime time here, I I think we've done a bonus content maybe twice on the main show. I'm trying to think. But either way.
0:00:57 Michael: You had me on for the inaugural Meet a Patreon. It's
0:01:01 Thomas: Oh, yes. Yes. That was awesome. Oh, I actually was trying, meaning to put a post out there. Oh, maybe I'll just announce it. I want to have a patron of the week next week. I want get that going again. So feel free to message me on Patreon if you want to volunteer. If not, I will try to track more people down. OK, when last we spoke on here, Michael, we were discussing freedom of speech and it was so we had so much to say that I'm pretty sure we didn't even get to a lot of what we were meaning to talk about. Um, yeah.
0:01:35 Michael: Always like that, isn't it? It's
0:01:36 Thomas: Totally, and it's a, it's a really important and murky issue. Like, it's, it's not very straightforward. I, I, I don't think I could talk that long about, say, like gay marriage, because it's just like I believe that that should be right. It's pretty, pretty obvious, you know, it's that's more straightforward to me. We could maybe, if we found someone, or if I found someone who disagreed, you know, maybe there'd be some conversation, but I I don't know. At a certain point, that one's pretty easy. Whereas free speech to me, there's so much going on because I think there are very real concerns. And even when we agree, which I think you and I agree on a lot, I think that we that I may have some different ideas on some stuff, or you may have som different ideas and some stuff. It's it's very interesting. Controversial, I think, and important.
0:02:27 Michael: It's always like when two people's rights intersect in a way that's not helpful to one of them.
0:02:32 Thomas: Right. That's very well put.
0:02:33 Michael: No.
0:02:36 Thomas: So you sent me we've been going back and forth. And then you sent me an article on Reason.com, which I found to be very excellent. I think it put things in a way that I agreed with, but I didn't realize. I just hadn't thought about it. And I think I'm going to just read the article. I do that sometimes on this show. I can't think of a better way. There's a lot here. So I was going to try to summarize it, but there wouldn't be much summary going on. It would pretty much be just leaving out a couple words. So I figured rather than do that, I'll just read it. If that's okay with you, if you have anything to say ahead of time.
0:03:19 Michael: I think we're all set. All.
0:03:20 Thomas: All right, well, this was on February 18th, so one week ago, and it's by Brendan O'Neill. So it's called After Copenhagen, the Myth of the Civilized Censorship. The two recent acts of censorship by murder in Europe, first at the offices of Charlie Hebdo in Paris and then at a free speech debate in Copenhagen, have put the continent's political classes in a pickle. For as much as European rulers want to and do condemn the brutal actions of these Koran-thumping offense-takers, the fact is they also share something in common with them, a devotion to shushing and sometimes punishing those who offend people's sensibilities. Oh, and Michael, if you want to stop me at any time, I am totally okay with kind of inserting discussion in between paragraphs or something. So let me know.
0:04:12 Thomas: There's only so much distance the elites of Europe can make between themselves and these cartoonist loathing shooters. So this is already pretty controversial, just to make sure everyone's on the same page. The author is kind of pointing, or at least he's about to point out, a connection that may be an uncomfortable one between what he's called the elites of Europe and the actual shooters in the cases of Charlie Hebdo and the Copenhagen shooting. So we'll
0:04:12 Michael: Right, it's A mighty broad brush, but there it is. Yeah.
0:04:44 Thomas: See. Let's see what his thesis is here and how he goes into it. For while our elites might not summarily execute people for the crime of being offensive, they do arrest them and put them on trial and occasionally jail them, all of which are acts tinged with menace, underpinned by the threat of violence, where it's understood by all that if any of these offense-givers were to dodge arrest or jump jail, they could be restrained by force. It isn't only Islamo-censors who use violence to silence. All censorship, by its nature, is violent. That's a very interesting point.
0:05:21 Thomas: You could write that off as kind of rhetoric, you know, like, oh, any censorship is violent. But I think he actually has a pretty good point. Because imagine for a minute, just if, let's say, Islamic law, you know, Sharia law or blasphemy laws, if they were universal and no one broke them, they would still essentially be violent because there's always the threat that if someone breaks them, violence could happen. You know what I mean? Does that make sense?
0:05:52 Michael: It makes great deal of sense, and it has two prongs. You're censoring what someone is allowed to say, what you are allowed to stay, and you're centering what someone's allowed to listen to. What you're are allowed to listen to, indeed.
0:06:03 Thomas: Right. Right, exactly. And he's right. I mean, if you did try to dodge, it may not be violence so much as force, I guess. I mean it could turn into violence, but there's not too much of a distinction there. I think he's – there may be some tiny moral ground on which you could say, well, one form of censorship wouldn't decapitate someone I guess, but still, I mean that's – you're grasping at straws there. I think He has a good point.
0:06:33 Thomas: Did I read this already? The awkward fact of a shared outlook between the opinion-forming set and the killers of cartoonists surfaced once again following the shoot-up of a debate about Islam and free speech in Copenhagen at the weekend. I'm taking for granted that everyone has heard about that by now. I hope it's not news. The smoke from the gunfire had barely disappeared before cagey columnists were saying that if we don't want to get killed, then we should stop offending people. A writer for The Guardian, which is linked, said Copenhagen should remind us of the obligations, quote, obligations upon those who wish to live in a peaceful, reasonably harmonious societies, end quote. The, sorry, primarily the obligation to, quote guard against the understandable temptation to be provocative, end quote, especially by publishing Muhammad mocking cartoons. Tunes. Shorter version, to avoid being shot, zip your lip. The Guardian writer is effectively doing the shooter's dirty work for him, spelling out in words what the shooter said with bullets. If you offend, you might die, so don't do it. Another Guardian columnist said the peoples of Scandinavia should now step back from their principles.
There are, quote, strong belief in moral imperative of free speech and show more of the pragmatism for which Denmark is also famous, end quote. So, in short, Denmark and its neighbor nations should do what the shooter wanted them to do, ditch that pesky principle of free-speech, that old right to provoke, and instead earn an awe before saying or showing anything edgy.
0:08:17 Thomas: So interesting. So this, just to make sure for for anyone who tuned out. He's now referencing a couple of Guardian articles, two different columnists, I believe, who said that the response to these shootings should essentially be to make sure we don't piss anybody off, you know, and offend anybody too badly. And it's interesting because they made this appeal like, sure, Denmark is known for free speech, but also for practicality and pragmatism, so maybe use that side of it. So that's interesting there. These responses to Copenhagen, this effective aiding and abetting of the shooter's profoundly illiberal message by the supposedly liberal commentariat, echo some of the grislier responses to the Charlie Hebdo massacre.
0:09:12 Thomas: There was the infamous Financial Times column that slammed the editorial foolishness of Charlie Hebdo. Apparently, the cartoonists brought their murders upon themselves, and the new statesmen screed against free speech fundamentalists who say, who stupidly say, je suis Charlie, when the fact is we all know there are free speech lines that cannot be crossed. It sounded almost like a threat, an echo of the sentiments of the Charlie Hebda killer themselves. Cross the line and you'll regret it. So twice now, the great and the good have condemned the actions of offense killing gunmen, while at the same time embracing and spreading the moral message behind these actions. The idea that there's a line that shouldn't be crossed, that things shouldn't be said, and principles that should now be ditched.
0:10:00 Thomas: In essence, liberal observers have made themselves willing participants in acts of terror, behaving as the propagandistic spokespeople I think I want to pause now, just because I don't mind breaking up my monotonous reading, and say This could be where you and I may disagree, or at least I know that I have an opinion here that people might not agree with. I think there are some people who are very quick to call any criticism of Charlie Hebdo's cartoons victim-blaming, and I want to just make sure that we're not dogmatic in that. Despite the fact that I firmly believe, I'll say now just in case anyone doubts this, I mean, I firmly believe that obviously the people who shoot people for words are completely 100% wrong, but then full stop, separate issue, you can talk about the content of the cartoons and whether or not you agree with it.
0:10:22 Michael: It's
0:11:08 Thomas: I mean, imagine if they were cartoons that said, you know, horribly racist thing, I'm not saying they were, but imagine, uh, they were cartoons that were just awfully racist or homophobic things. You could still say, uh, well, I don't like those articles, um, but the killers were wrong to shoot them for him. I mean, what do you think about that, Michael? Okay.
0:11:29 Michael: Not that, because at that point we're talking about them. They're still talking to us. It's a separate thing. We haven't shut them down. What The article is trying to get across, from what I see, is it's a continuum from death to state-sponsored violence or force of some sort, to social force, to society taking a larger view and discussing the matter. And along that continuum, there, there comes a point you're no longer talking about the subjects in question, and That's where I see the difference being. Once
0:11:38 Thomas: Okay.
0:12:07 Thomas: Interesting. Okay, I think I, I think I understand what you're saying, so, uh, so it's more like as long as you're discussing them with the mindset that they're open for discussion, versus saying they shouldn't be saying any of that at all, no matter what, like, is that what you mean? Or do I understand you properly?
0:12:28 Michael: It's No Longer open for debate. It's, it's a question Of how closed is the debate? Is it a fine? Is it pressure from the government? Is it somebody with a large knife or an axe coming into your home? That's a wide berth that we're glossing over there. And the article glosses over that pressure. But the point is, it's the same instinct on the continuum. Well,
0:12:30 Thomas: Okay. Right.
0:13:00 Thomas: Okay. Well, I just want to make sure that, um, that we're on the same page with the point I'm trying to make, because I remember when I said, originally talked about Charlie Hebdo. And I, I said there are some people who think the cartoons might've, I did have people say like, whoa, you're blaming the victims, blah blah, and that's not at all what I meant. I mean, we could totally, like, imagine none of the shooting had happened, we could talk about the content of Charlie Ebdo and like, oh, maybe this would just, or replace a hypothetical cartoon, you know, we could talking about X cartoon and say, is this racist, as a separate issue of whether or not someone deserved to be killed for a potentially racist cartoon. And I think That
0:13:39 Michael: Political Cartoons take advantage of stereotypical attributes. So They Are Race, racist, to a certain extent. No.
0:13:44 Thomas: May all Be Fine. Sure. And again, as long as my point's clear, then we're talking about the question. Maybe the answer to the question is, no, they're not racist. Or, like you said, maybe they're utilizing Certain stereotypes or whatever. Maybe that's the answer that answered to the question. But all I want to say is merely bringing up the question had some people commenting to me that I was victim blaming. And I think that's a misunderstanding. Would you agree? Do you think I made that point right, or do you still? Okay.
0:14:17 Michael: I agree with that point. I have very little truck with people who claim victim blaming in all circumstances. Kitchens.
0:14:18 Thomas: Okay. Understood, so just wanted to make that little point because it was pretty relevant to that section. Now, I wasn't saying, I, uh, yeah, okay, I think we're on the same page there, so I'll continue. These creepy commonalities between small gangs of killers and whole layers of respectable society reveal that these attacks may not be as alien to our way of life as some would have us believe. In fact, the two shooting sprees can be seen as simply a bloodier expression of something that's now depressingly mainstream in Europe, the idea that it's bad to give offense, so bad that you can be punished for doing it. The massacre at Charlie Hebdo and the shooting in Denmark didn't happen in a vacuum. They happened at a time and on a continent where offensiveness is actually a punishable offense.
0:15:11 Thomas: So in France, in the six weeks since the Charlie Hebda massacre, far-right ideologues have been arrested for the crime of anti-Semitic speech, and three people who wrote homophobic tweets have been convicted of committing a hate crime. In Copenhagen, just four months ago, an art exhibition was canceled on the basis that it was racist. The Danish Penal Code forbids any speech that threatens or simply insults or degrades a group on the base of its race, ethnic origin, sexual orientation, or faith. Was it the Quran that gave the Copenhagen cafe shooter the idea that any slur against his faith was an intolerable crime? Or was it the insult punishing law of the land in which he was born and brought up? His own nation sent him the message that anyone who degraded his faith deserved to be punished.
0:16:00 Thomas: Very interesting. So this is where I, because I totally, and I mentioned it before, I pretty much see any sort of hate speech law as problematic. And I think this article will go on to make the point, drive the point home. But I just wanted to intro it by saying, I think I mentioned this when I said, I don't believe someone should be in prison for Holocaust denial. I mean, I can't remember who originally brought that to my attention, but it might have been like Sam Harris or somebody. Or no, sorry, Michael. Yeah, thank you. That was in the Hitchin speech. And I remember watching that at the time and thinking that's a great point. I mean I mean, it's as you've said, and I think is very important, you know, the easy speech doesn't need protection. You know, hello, how's your day going? You know that doesn't mean protection like it's it's stuff that we might be uncomfortable with that really needs protection.
0:16:38 Michael: Toronto Speech. I
0:17:01 Thomas: And I'll just go ahead and continue and we should be finished pretty soon. Then then you can we can unleash all our thoughts across Europe. A glut of hate speech laws now control what people can say and write. Right. Over the past 30 years, everywhere from Britain to France to Finland, laws have been passed forbidding the insulting or ridiculing of religious folk, women, ethnic minorities, gays, and others. These laws don't only punish those who shout the word nigger or faggot, which would be bad enough.
They punish people for their actual moral and political convictions. Like the Swedish pastor given a one-month suspended prison sentence for expressing his belief that homosexuality is a tumor on society, or Brigitte Bardot arrested and fined five times in France for describing Islam as barbaric, or the novelist Michael Hollenbeck, I think, dragged to court in France, for describing islam as the stupidest religion, wow, just saying that, huh, that's pretty crazy, yeah, that is A good point, so you are right, he should go to prison. Or The far right British politician given a suspended eight-month prison sentence for expressing his disdain for Britain's immigration policy and using the word darky to describe foreigners.
Or, the Swedish artist sent to jail for six months for producing paintings that mocked black people. It's the return of the mindset of the Inquisition, the old rotten idea, idea that those who offend orthodoxies, in this case PC, may be punished, sometimes severely. Maybe the Charlie Hebdo and Copenhagen killers were mind-warped by the online ravings of some extremist finger-wagging imam from the Middle East, or maybe they imbibed the thinking of their own societies, of the laws in France and Denmark which remove the liberties of those who insult Muslims and other groups and turns these insulters into criminals, outcasts, moral lepers.
0:18:03 Michael: Agree, I would not agree with him, there are many Stupider religions In Islam. So
0:19:03 Thomas: These killers can be seen not so much as an invading foreign strain of intolerant Islamism, but as the militant enforcers of the now mainstream European creed of offense avoidance and criminalization of hate and ridicule. Some will say, but our censorship is more civilized than theirs. We don't kill, we just arrest and fine or imprison those who misspeak or misthink. Please, what underpins the state's ability to criminalize and in some cases incarcerate those who give offense? Force does. Violence does. It's the knowledge that anyone who refused to pay his fine or serve his prison sentence for the crime of saying what he thinks would be made to do so by the enforcers of the state will.
0:19:50 Thomas: Censorship is inherently threatening. It is never civilized. In fact, it's the antithesis of civilization, for it calls into question the ability of the public to judge for itself which ideas are good and which are bad, and it elevates with menace tiny clicks of people into the arbiters of what may be thought and said. Final paragraph, to rebuild freedom in Europe, it isn't enough to condemn the actions of small groups of gunmen.
We must also dismantle piece by piece the vast legal structures and censorious culture that empowers the offense takers making them believe that they have the right to silence and punish those who criticize them and to live in a safe space, an anti-social bubble in which a cross word is never uttered. Let's invade their safe space, let's burst their bubble, let's challenge the idea that words of any kind, be they gratuitously offensive or just morally dubious, should be in the business of of either the state shouldn't, oh, sorry, they're challenging the idea, it should be in the business of either The State or Islamo murderers, man, I got so close to the end, and then messed up that sentence, so that's the end there,
0:21:06 Michael: How many chapters of the Bible is that equal to?
0:21:08 Thomas: Let's see, let me estimate here, I would say that's, they vary so much, but an average one, I'll say that two on average, maybe, could be wrong, yeah, yeah it's, It's interesting, but the Bible, I feel more, I can give myself breaks by stopping and ranting. So, whereas here, I didn't want to do that too much because I figured we'd lose the storyline.
0:21:20 Michael: Something out of the roof, maybe. I
0:21:39 Thomas: Yeah, so fertile area for discussion because you could look at this and on the surface, you could kind of write this guy off as like, oh, another anti-PC free speech fundamentalist. And this is where we may disagree, Michael. I feel like calling you bangs. I almost...
0:22:00 Michael: Answer to almost everything. At
0:22:03 Thomas: This is where we could disagree because I do think there is such a thing as kind of an annoying free speech activist who sort of... What I think of is the negative quality of free speech warriors in a derogatory sense. Not in a good sense. There's a very good sense of that but there's a derigatory sense where they bring it up at the wrong time. Basically, when they, you know, at inappropriate times, they think we ought to let someone, we oughtto support someone when they're really just mean the government shouldn't be limiting their speech. But I don't know. That's just me.
0:22:42 Michael: A funeral, perhaps.
0:22:43 Thomas: Well, no, I mean, the people I think of who kind of honestly I get annoyed with sometimes online are the people who are defending like, Like, how dare you, let's say, how, how dear Fox News, or no, not, that would be a bad example. How dare, you know, NBC or somebody fire someone for something they said that was racist, like free speech, you Know, or something like that. Personally, I think that that doesn't fall under free speech. I think That falls under a, you Now, a corporation can decide that they want someone on the air or not, You Know, based on what they say.
0:23:19 Michael: Right, we're talking two separate things. One is a state-powered institution, and the other is the institution in a private or corporate manner. But all of this under the envelope of the social contract that we live under.
0:23:21 Thomas: That's Yes. Right.
0:23:31 Thomas: Yeah, so That That's What I Mean, Right, and I know that that line does get interesting. I mean, I, I think the last time we talked about this, it seemed like you were more on the side of there's such a thing as socially limiting free speech too much via, you know, criticism or something. I don't know, maybe I'm remembering wrong, but I, I do seem to think we, we had a bit of a disagreement there. Does that, am I recalling correctly or?
0:24:01 Michael: You're recalling correctly, I probably fall on that side of the line that you're more comfortable following on the other. I would not doubt that.
0:24:02 Thomas: Okay. Well, I'm, I just think things like, you know, for example, the hypothetical example of a news anchor spouting some, you knows, racist nonsense on, when he's not on the job, like that sort of thing. I, I am okay with a, a company, you now, ditching him because they want to maintain their image. That's almost their free speech, you know, right to.
0:24:33 Michael: And it's usually written in a morals clause or something like that in the contract that they hire him under. For
0:24:36 Thomas: Yeah, yeah. And I'm OK with publicly ridicule using your own lots of people using their free free speech to, uh, make fun of people who have horribly racist or homophobic ideas. Um, I don't, I'm not a fan, obviously. I'm, I'm a fan of, of, uh. I don, I, I am a fan. I, I don't support, uh, government, any sort of government censorship. I don't support any sort state sponsored. That's where I draw a hard line. Like I, I don't, I don't support that at all, but I think socially there are some things that we can render completely, um, useless to say. Now they can still be said, hypothetically be said. Of of course, but we can make them pretty, pretty, make the people who say them regret it socially with their reputation. I don't know. Do you think that's a step too far? Are we talking too general?
0:25:31 Michael: Example, the Duck Dynasty people from A&E. And That's good, because I'm about to say you have no right to head down that road. Because they were expressing their constitutionally protected First Amendment views on religion. Religion, and I want you to tell me that you think a company has the right to censor somebody based on their religious views. I just want to hear you say that they
0:25:35 Thomas: I was thinking that too.
0:25:57 Thomas: You know, here's the thing. I, I, it sounded like I was going the other way, but when I think of that example, I'm actually surprised that A&E would ditch them for that, because right
0:26:08 Michael: Ditched them for a week or two, what?
0:26:10 Thomas: Yeah, okay, that's true, they did, I guess it didn't end up, it's such a moneymaker, like they're obviously not gonna lose it, but um, yeah, I actually don't, I actually didn't really support that one, because, and I can't remember which of my 70 podcasts I talked about it on, might have been one of my comedy related ones, because I thought that it's just so obvious that they would have that point of view, that like why would this be news to A&E, I mean they know that, but that's their religious view. They know that, you know, that's probably the religious view of most of their viewers that watch Duck Dynasty. Like, it just seemed odd to me, an odd face-saving thing. And, but how, I guess, maybe this is a more general legal question, but where can you draw the line with your sincerely held religious belief?
0:26:57 Thomas: Do you see that as a clean line? Because, I mean, obviously, there are things that we've accepted as a society that don't count. Like you can't just, oh, it's my sincere religious belief that I need to murder my kid. You know, like there's certain things where you can accept it. But is that not a big deal? What do you think?
0:27:16 Michael: If it was a sincerely held belief, religious, or merely a political belief, that gay marriage is a good thing, an equitable thing, and should be supported, can they be fired for supporting that, that view, which is politically incorrect today, 10 years ago, not so much, so
0:27:39 Thomas: You're, sorry, I think I switched.
0:27:41 Michael: If, if we switch the narrative, if we're talking about, if
0:27:44 Thomas: Sure. Oh, I follow you now. Yeah, yeah, sorry. I thought you switched the thing, but I think you switched it. I switched it in my mind. So yes, yeah. That would have been not so politically correct. Yeah, 10, 20 years ago, definitely.
0:27:58 Michael: We were talking 30, 40 years ago, 50 years ago, integration, race relations, if somebody held a belief that we currently consider perfectly PC, perfectly correct today, that many years ago, people were fired for holding those beliefs. So you can't have it both ways. They're
0:28:18 Thomas: Now, does it – right, I agree, and I think this was a big part of my disagreement that I was not sure – I'm not totally sure on, but this is why it's such a tough issue with the Cogdiss folks, you know, Tom and Cecil. I think I may be blending these conversations because for them, they seem to think that it's no matter what, it's your right to fire someone for any reason at any time. Time,
0:28:47 Michael: Good libertarians. That's all I can say.
0:28:48 Thomas: I wonder if they would bristle at that description.
0:28:52 Michael: I hope so.
0:28:53 Thomas: Yeah, it's interesting because I think it has to do with contracts more than anything. I mean, I think the specifics of the contract you sign, let me know if you disagree with this, but I mean if contracts are structured with A&E, for example, Duck Dynasty, that, you know, if you want to say that you'll never say say anything publicly that could be construed as hateful toward any group. I mean, if you sign that contract, is it, I think it's a different story, right? I mean it can, it can almost anything be negated by a contractual agreement when we're talking about free speech rights up to a certain point.
0:29:31 Michael: Legal rights up to a certain point can in fact be abrogated. You can sign them away to a certainly extent. So I'm okay with that. I I understand what you're saying. I understand that.
0:29:34 Thomas: Sure. Okay. But is it if, if let's say just hypothetically with the, the, were they any example? Um, is that, do you think some vague or nonspecific morals clause you're saying you don't think that cuts it in that situation? I don't want to put words in your mouth.
0:30:02 Michael: I'm saying that we are putting
0:30:04 Thomas: Yeah. Let me know.
0:30:04 Michael: Under the morals clause what is a fairly literal and not particularly disruptive view of somebody's religion. That's not, in certain evangelical circles, a complicated or nuanced view of the religion. That's the literal reading of the book as their people interpret it.
0:30:27 Thomas: Well, that's what they say it is, but there's no, there's nothing in the Bible about marriage, But yes, I know. I think you're, I agree with your point. Interesting. Yeah. I, I, uh, I wonder if people disagree with us on that. Cause I actually did think that one one was a little odd whereas if you just spout if they just spouts some hateful nonsense what about that. So uh, let me ask you this hypothetical, so I believe the comments were more just not supporting gay marriage, right, or did they go in, now had they gone into um horribly foul homophobic language, uh, what about, what then, I mean, it's technically probably still their belief, for example, that all those, you know, faggots are going to burn in hell or something. Like if they, if they start spouting more hate-filled language like that, do you believe that A&E can cut them for that?
0:30:30 Michael: Yeah, I know.
0:31:17 Michael: It's an interesting question because you're trying to find where that line is. One side of the line is protected, one side of line isn't. And it varies over time, it varies in the circumstances where somebody will fall down on that line. And I tend to push farther into that veil of protected speech than many people do. But every time that I see somebody say, that's too far, that is a step too far, that is a mile too far, if you flip the context suddenly you're having what we're considering to be perfectly acceptable things.
0:31:21 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah.
0:32:00 Michael: Today, you know, in 10 years maybe they won't be as acceptable, and then your views are on the wrong side of that line, and I just get very nervous when somebody base starts enforcing their views on another person's life because of their closely held beliefs, right?
0:32:22 Thomas: It's interesting. And it's something that I think could be dealt with a certain way. I mean, maybe if... It's so hard because it's all about PR. I means, nothing has anything to do with anything with these companies like A&T or whatever news... When we're talking that situation. Nothing has anything to do with anything except their image. That's all it is to do. Are people, yeah.
0:32:45 Michael: You're bringing disrepute onto their image, you're costing them money, you're costing us money. You're gone I
0:32:50 Thomas: Well, and they're costing them, you know, public opinion when they don't do something like fine them or, you Know, that's what they're worried about. They're all there. I guarantee you, these people don't give a shit. They'RE worried about, okay, if we don't, you know, if WE don't suspend these, you KNOW, people who obviously have this, who, spoiler alert, don't support gay marriage. I don't know how that was a surprise. But if we don't suspend them, what are people going to think? That's all they're operating on. It sucks that that's what it is. I wish it were some more noble thing like, oh, I'm going to try to make my speech heard by this act that I'm doing with my employee. But I guarantee you, and the evidence of that is the fact that they let him back and started making money again and everything was happy.
0:33:37 Michael: Want to point out, though, that we are drawing that line at a where a solid 30 to 40 percent of the United States population supports that view. So we're saying 30 to 40 percent of the population would fail this test if that's where you draw the line, because that's a, you are not talking about the extremes as much as many people would like to think. You know, in my view, the right to marry, you know, Article 4, 14th Amendment, yeah, you know, equal equality under the law pops your uncle, there you go.
I see no reason that, uh, you, uh, if you're going, going to have government endorsing marriage, and that means something for taxation and medical benefits and everything else that marriage in the governmental sense leads to, I don't see why there would be a problem there. I think that's a nice conservative argument, and I've made it many times to people on the right side of the spectrum, and they have a hard time arguing with that. And you, you see people with a certain amount of cognitive dissonance suddenly start to think, you know, that may be right. We should get government out of marriage.
0:33:53 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah, it is interesting.
0:34:10 Thomas: Equal protection. Yeah right.
0:34:52 Thomas: Yeah
0:34:52 Michael: And there have been attempts At, I forget what state it was in. It was something southern where they were going to abolish the marriage, and somebody was pushing something forward. And it was silly, and it was never going to get any traction, but it was a reaction to a valid modern interpretation. And right now we're, what, 36, 37 states that in some form allow marriage between a man and a woman, a man in the man, a woman in a woman, and it's on an equal basis. Some of them are still in the courts in that 36, 37, but we're at two-thirds of the states as it stands right now. You
0:34:53 Thomas: Yeah right.
0:35:38 Thomas: I think my favorite and the most frustrating response to that, you just reminded me, was I came across someone who was arguing, oh, sure, I don't think the government should have any say in marriage. So if there's a bill that, that says, get the government out of marriage, I'll vote on that. But until then, I'm not going to vote for the government to get even more in marriage and say that two men can marry. It's just like, okay, so the, you're saying that you don't think government should have any say on marriage, but right now, as it is, it's unfair to gay people, but you're not going to do anything to change it because why, you know, no reason. That was a very, reminded me of someone I argued with on some various, uh, medium, but yeah, but
0:36:20 Michael: Can get that from a good libertarian argument where why should the government be involved with that kind of personal relationship. I can see that argument, that this is where I it's
0:36:30 Thomas: You also have to look at the facts as they stand now. And this is, again, this isn't a gay marriage podcast right now. I mean, we could talk about that sometime.
0:36:37 Michael: A nice hot button issue to have the debate over, though.
0:36:38 Thomas: Yeah. Yeah, but okay. So to try to bring it back, I, it is a difficult line and I, I'm very sympathetic to what you've said on this. I think that you, you've made some good points so so far on, you know, just 10 years ago, we would have been the opposite side of this issue or whatever, based on popular opinion. But is there a difference between expressing a political or religious opinion like, I don't believe gays should marry? Personally, I do not think anyone should lose their job over saying something like that. I mean, half the country, or like you said, I mean maybe now it is 40% or whatever the latest numbers are, lots of people think that. That. But when you start personalizing and moving toward hatred, what do you think? When it's more, it's not so much, I don't think they should marry as much as it is, you know, gay people are disgusting.
0:37:29 Thomas: You know, a bunch of personal stuff. Is that, are you still unwilling to say that an A&E or somebody, a hypothetical A&T could ditch someone for that?
0:37:43 Michael: Can they ditch a vociferous critique of, oh, who's a nice protected group that will offend people if I critique them. Let's talk about Jews, because what could possibly go wrong. Let's say I want to say something nasty about Jewish people, um, let's save these pseudo private police force they have in Williamsburg, have you ever heard of the Shalshalrim? I believe, uh, it's in certain countries, it's a police force of sorts, it's a patrol, it's a private patrol not an actual security group but it's people volunteering to patrol the area, watch out for crime something sort
0:37:56 Thomas: All right, let's.
0:38:12 Thomas: No, no. Yeah.
0:38:23 Thomas: Like a religious police. Huh.
0:38:36 Michael: Of a watch it
0:38:36 Thomas: Like a neighborhood watch, but more of an official Jewish one, kind of.
0:38:40 Michael: Comes from a very Jewish backstory where they didn't want Well, there have been problems, but where they didn't want to interact with the official police because they were being discriminated against, so they would police their own rather than go to the German police in the 1930s, for example. You know, that would not work out well for them.
0:38:48 Thomas: Well, can you blame them? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh-huh. Right. Taking matters into their own hands. Yeah, okay. Sure. Gotcha. Gotcha,
0:39:11 Michael: But this private organization, they could police some of the things themselves. And this goes back hundreds of years, this sort of thing. In Williamsburg, there are people who have spiffy little official-looking cars with blue lights on the top, and there are a number of leaders in the community who endorse the idea that you call these people first rather than the police, and then they'll bring the police in on their own terms if they feel it gets to a certain level. There was a case a couple of years ago where a child was abducted and killed, and the police weren't notified until many hours after the Shaorim were notified, and there have been shootings and beatings
0:39:12 Thomas: Okay, wow.
0:39:29 Thomas: All right, I'm going to try to, well,
0:40:08 Michael: And just interesting, exciting things. So here I am. I have this very weird aversion to a couple of, in the United States, pseudo police or security forces that have certain jurisdictions, or at least they're imposing a certain amount of jurisdiction into the public sector. I I have little tolerance for it, and so let's say I'm critiquing them, am I being anti-semitic by doing that, and if I am, does my employer at that point, because I'm being harshly critical of a very protected class in the United States, it's hard, uh, at this point. Okay.
0:40:49 Thomas: But is critical the, the, I don't know if that's what I was asking, though. I mean, critical versus, well, I don't know. Maybe you think that's the same, but critical of a group versus personally insulting of a group. Is there a difference?
0:41:07 Michael: How about this, uh, continuing on my, uh, picking on the Jews, because the moment somebody, I, I I am, you can just tell, I do this day in and day out, uh, today there was a, uh, agreement between, uh, the New York City administration and the moyles that operate in New Yorke City regarding certain circumcision practices, and these practices in the past have led to the death of children, led to brain damage, it
0:41:12 Thomas: Uh-huh. Sure. Because you're great at it. Yeah.
0:41:48 Thomas: Right.
0:41:48 Michael: Involved how do I want to put this without being graphic, oral suction of the blood after circumcision, I do not recall the, and it's a very minority practice, even in the believing community, I saw this, and basically the status, uh, the status quo that they have reached is go ahead and continue the practices as you see fit, and if you happen to make a child sick, then we're going to ask you to stop.
0:41:48 Thomas: Yeah, yeah. A a fantastic practice, I can't think of a better practice, yeah, wow, really,
0:42:32 Michael: That's The practical upshot of the agreement that was reached today, before they were requiring the parents provide, uh, be provided a form to sign agreeing that they are allowing this dangerous procedure to happen, and they don't have to do that now. So that's the point. So I'm upset, I say something truly nasty about Jews at this point because I, I see it as a sacrifice, a religious sacrifice of children. We know that over a period of time, children have died. Children will continue to die because of this practice. I get upset and I say horrible, horrible things because I see people dying from this. Is that sufficient reason?
0:42:32 Thomas: Really?
0:42:50 Thomas: Man, those Jews, that's the point of this, right?
0:43:08 Thomas: Okay, okay,
0:43:27 Michael: Because I can see myself going off on this, when I read this earlier today, um, in the various news sites, would
0:43:34 Thomas: Well, but I, I would, well man, it's hard, it is really hard, I think, I definitely want to acknowledge that, like, there's no easy hard and fast line, I don't think, and maybe your argument is there should be no line, Like you just, everything is fine. You should deal with it with other words and not with termination, I guess, is what I think is, no,
0:43:54 Michael: I be able to be, would somebody be able to call me anti-semitic if I went down a path of criticism like this?
0:44:01 Thomas: I, well, for me, this may be getting into a separate issue.
0:44:01 Michael: No, you say no, but, uh, I I can see somebody say, uh, now,
0:44:06 Thomas: No, I can too. I, I'm, I came to, and I'm I was just about to say, I think this is getting into a different issue. And it's a problem we, we face with Islam as well, where people see any criticism as, you know, anti-Islam, anti Jewish. It depends on what you're saying. If you say those dirty Jews look at what they're doing, yeah, that's – I mean if you're couching it in language that's personally – that's attacking people's personal characteristics or whatever it is, if you couch it in that language, yes, I think it can be anti-Semitic. If you go on a bunch of anti-gay rants where, sure, your main point is that you don't believe they should be able to marry, that in itself I don't think can be construed as awfully homophobic.
0:44:56 Thomas: It's definitely ill-informed, but it may not necessarily be homophobic. You may just have a legal opinion for whatever reason, but once you start well, oh, oh, me too, I'm not saying this is, I am not at all saying this is how everyone thinks, I'm giving you my opinion on this, uh, I think this, and what I'm essentially trying to say is I think we're, we're intersecting two issues here, we're bringing another variable into the equation, is all I'm trying to set. Well, no, here, let me, let me say, sorry, I think the variable that I was trying to identify, um, because you're right that that is one we're looking at. Another one I'm trying to identify is to what degree people associate any sort of criticism of people or ideas and mix those, you know, like to what degree people, people conflate criticism of ideas with criticism and personal attack of people.
That's another element I think we're bringing into this, because what I was, the examples I was trying to go with are you're making personal attacks, personal insult, racist, homophobic insults on people, not well-reasoned, you know, critiques of ideas. You know what I mean? And I think that's a difference there that I think muddies the waters when we're trying to look at this issue. What do
0:45:05 Michael: You're drawing interesting lines, because I see activists on both sides saying exactly the opposite, that you are being extraordinarily extraordinarily homophobic. The variable is the outside social pressure on, in this case, the company employing.
0:46:18 Thomas: You think?
0:46:19 Michael: So it's the difference between having a cup of coffee and then having a rant and having three beers and a whiskey and going off on a rant.
0:46:27 Thomas: Well, that's dangerous territory, because I don't know, I don't think personally that I ever get into, you know, I'm not trying to be all holier than that, but I don't ever get in, as much as I I disagree with a lot of religion, I don't turn it into, you know, like anti-Semitic, what you would think of as typical anti-Semitic language, I never do, I just think like, I can't believe people believe these stupid ideas, but I, you know, I don't know that that's unnecessarily, I don't know that that should be a protected thing. Someone's right to turn a criticism of an idea into a, like, diatribe and a racist rant or something, you know what I mean, just because they've had a few beers, is that, what do you think it's
0:47:13 Michael: There comes a point when what you're arguing is somebody has said something too far. And that's the whole nub of this whole argument That's the argument in its totality, there's a line that someone draws based on the content, and on one side of that line, in the circumstances and with the observers that are looking at this, uh, line, one step is acceptable, one more step is unacceptable. And And that's a very hard line to police. And if you're going to come down deciding where that line goes, I push the line out a lot farther than others. Why?
0:47:23 Thomas: Just you're just saying it's hard to decide what's too far, yeah.
0:48:02 Thomas: Well, yes, and let me just, just to make sure we're all on the same page, when we're talking state sponsored, I'm totally a hundred percent with you with that, there's no, there, where I don't want to draw that line, I think hate speech should not be a crime, I really do, I think that's, it's weird that that's a controversial thing, but but it seems in Europe that it's maybe worse than here based on – now, I just realized I had another – I had a video I wanted to share, pretty brief, but we're already at like a full episode time. This happens every time.
0:48:34 Michael: Do we always do this?
0:48:36 Thomas: I know. Now, I'm trying to think how to proceed because I really wanted to talk about this. I don't know. We're at time. Should we do a part two? What should we do? What do you think, Michael? You're a listener. Now, I already have something lined up for next week. Otherwise, I would just say part two will be Monday. What do you think? Take your vote.
0:48:36 Michael: We always do.
0:48:56 Michael: You could always tease it as Patreon content. And if he wanted to hear the rest of the argument, I
0:49:01 Thomas: Okay. Well, we could – yeah, but I think everyone should hear the – I don't mind doing a certain amount of patron content. So let's – no,
0:49:10 Michael: Tried to give you a freebie.
0:49:12 Thomas: I like your idea except I also have other things I want to be on the main show for us to talk about. But let's rain check. Let's – okay. Here's what we're going to do, fine folks. Fine listeners. Sorry, this is a little, a little on the fly decisions here. We're going to cut off this episode. I'm going to say thank you to my lovely patrons, of which Michael has been an amazing one. So thank you personally, Michael. Thank you so much for your contribution and help with the show. I really appreciate it.
0:49:47 Thomas: And I Will say thank you to my other patrons. I don't want to, I don't think I want to go through the process of finding out which Patreon account I'm on, logging off of that one and then logging on to this one, and so I'm going to cut off the show now. Thank you to patrons, go to patreon.com/atheist if you want to become a patron and you want to see more content like this, and I will say tune in on the special bonus content for additional discussion between Michael and I on this, on this very issue, and then I'll say a rain check on a part two. If it fits in next week, maybe we can resume. If not, we'll pick a later date because this is ongoing. So thank you so much, Michael. I'm going to call this episode and say,
0:49:46 Michael: Always a pleasure.
0:50:33 Thomas: Have a great weekend, everyone, and I will see you next week. So thanks, Michael, all
0:50:38 Michael: You have a great night.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
iHeart
Support on Patreon